0 · Exam Mapcourse + brief
| Assessment | Wt | Format |
|---|---|---|
| In-Class Participation Activity | 10% | First in-class exercise |
| Reflective Writing Essay | 20% | Written reflection |
| In-Class Participation Activity | 10% | Second in-class exercise |
| Analytical Exercise | 30% | Argument analysis task |
| Take Home Final Assessment | 30% | Take-home written assessment |
“This final assessment is open book for unit material. You may access course materials during the course of completing the final assessment.” (ATS2946 Final Assessment page, 2026)
Use this sheet as a desk reference. The final rewards visible reasoning: define the controlling concept, select the fact that activates it, show the inferential link, test a credible alternative, then qualify the conclusion.
Revision cycle that transfers
| Pass | Action | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Retrieve | Recall definitions without notes. | Exact term + boundary |
| Apply | Use an unfamiliar case. | Fact → element → consequence |
| Compare | Test a credible alternative on the same criteria. | Trade-off made explicit |
| Correct | Record the first unsupported link. | Repair + review trigger |
Allocate revision time to the reasoning operation the task asks for, not merely its topic. Before writing, identify the required product, scope and audience; after writing, change one assumption and decide whether the recommendation should survive.
Final-task priority: the Take Home Final Assessment is 30%. Use the assessment weights as a planning map, then follow the current task instructions for scope, format and submission. This page supplies retrieval and decision structure; it does not replace those instructions.
1 · Argument or Explanation?C1 boundary
2 · Reconstruct the ArgumentC1 · P1–P6
Argument = a conclusion together with one or more premises offered as reasons for accepting it. A premise is a statement presented as support; the conclusion is the claim the audience is asked to accept on that basis.
Extraction sequence
- Write the main conclusion as one precise claim.
- List each stated premise separately; strip away examples and qualifications only after preserving what they change.
- Supply the unstated proposition needed to connect premise to conclusion.
- Draw support or opposition; show whether reasons must combine.
- Test a counter-case and name evidence that would justify revision.
Answer spineP1: [material fact] + P2: [stated/implicit link] → C: [qualified claim]
| Element | Diagnostic question |
|---|---|
| Premise | What is offered as support? |
| Link | Why would that fact support this claim? |
| Conclusion | What must the audience accept? |
| Boundary | What changed fact reverses the judgement? |
Representation discipline
| Material | Map treatment |
|---|---|
| Example | Attach it to the premise it illustrates; do not promote it automatically to a premise. |
| Qualification | Narrow the claim or reason it actually modifies. |
| Implied assumption | Write it as a complete proposition and test its denial. |
| Opposing reason | Point it at the precise premise, link or conclusion it challenges. |
An argument map is a visual representation of how premises support, oppose or combine in relation to conclusions. Its value is diagnostic: it exposes where evidence ends and inference begins. After drawing it, ask which single arrow is least secure, what counter-case attacks it, and what new evidence would restore it. Preserve the writer’s qualifications before compressing; otherwise the reconstructed conclusion may become stronger than the original claim.
3 · Support, Validity, AssumptionC2
Deductive support aims to make the conclusion unavoidable if the premises are true. Validity is a property of form: true premises cannot occur with a false conclusion. It does not, by itself, establish that the premises are acceptable.
Assumption = an unstated proposition needed for the stated reasons to support the conclusion as intended. Recover it by asking: what must also be true for this move to work? Then reverse or deny that proposition and trace whether the conclusion survives.
| Test | What it establishes | What it does not |
|---|---|---|
| Validity | No true-premise/false-conclusion case | Truth of premises |
| Acceptability | A premise may be accepted | That it is relevant |
| Relevance | A reason bears on C | That support is enough |
| Assumption | Missing bridge is visible | That the bridge is defensible |
3b · Fallacy DiagnosisC2 boundary
A fallacy is a recurring pattern of defective reasoning whose weakness must be explained in context. Naming the fallacy is not the evaluation. Show the precise damage: which reason becomes unacceptable or irrelevant, which option was wrongly excluded, or why the stated support cannot carry the conclusion.
Required sentence“This move weakens [acceptability / relevance / support] because …; if [counter-case/evidence], the conclusion should be revised.”
Four-pass defect test
| Pass | Question |
|---|---|
| Acceptability | What supports the premise itself, and what would defeat it? |
| Relevance | Even if true, why does it bear on this conclusion? |
| Sufficiency | Could the stated reasons all hold while the conclusion fails? |
| Assumption | Which unstated proposition carries the inference? |
4 · Complex Support StructuresC3
Intermediate conclusion = a claim supported by earlier premises that also functions as a premise for a later conclusion. Mark it twice: first as an output, then as an input. If it fails, every later claim depending on it loses support.
Linked support requires premises to be combined before they provide the intended reason. Removing either linked premise defeats that reason. Keep independent reasons on separate lines so one may survive when another fails.
| Map cue | Stress test |
|---|---|
| Linked reasons | Remove P1 or P2: does the intended reason collapse? |
| Independent reasons | Can each support C without the other? |
| Intermediate C | Which downstream claim changes if it fails? |
| Opposition | Which precise claim does the objection target? |
Build the complete map
Number every proposition before drawing arrows. Start at the final conclusion and work backwards: which claim immediately supports it, and what supports that claim? An intermediate conclusion should appear once as the endpoint of earlier reasons and again as the premise for the later step. If reasons are linked, mark the joint support and test the pair together; if they are independent, test each route separately.
| Change | Expected map response |
|---|---|
| One linked premise fails | The joint reason loses its intended force. |
| One independent reason fails | Other routes may still support C. |
| Intermediate conclusion fails | Trace every downstream dependency. |
| New objection appears | Attach it to the exact proposition or arrow. |
5 · Normative InferenceC3 · P3–P5
A normative claim states what ought to be done, valued or permitted, not merely what is the case. A principle is the general evaluative standard connecting descriptive facts to that normative conclusion.
Normative bridgeFact: [harm/benefit is supported].
Principle: [general evaluative standard].
Therefore: [actor] ought to [action], unless [review condition].
Boundary: descriptive evidence cannot complete a normative inference until the relevant value or principle is stated and defended. Test at least two feasible options against the same criteria and stakeholder positions; otherwise the comparison is one-sided.
| Failure | Repair |
|---|---|
| Fact jumps straight to “ought” | State and defend the value premise |
| Options use different standards | Apply one criterion to both |
| Principle is only named | Explain how it changes the inference |
| Conclusion is universal | Add uncertainty and review condition |
When it bites
Use this frame whenever evidence about harm becomes a policy recommendation. Mark each intermediate conclusion; expose the contested value principle; then change one condition and ask whether the recommendation should travel.
5b · Digital Evidence ProcessC5 process check
6 · Statistical GeneralisationC4
Sample = observed cases used to support a claim about a wider population. Representativeness asks whether relevant features are preserved. Sampling bias is systematic selection that makes observed cases differ from the population.
| Question | What to write |
|---|---|
| Target? | Name the wider set the conclusion concerns. |
| Observed? | Name who or what actually entered the sample. |
| Selection? | Explain the process that may separate sample from population. |
| Relevant feature? | State which difference matters to the claim. |
| Revision? | Name evidence or a changed case that alters the inference. |
Size ≠ representativeness. A larger sample reduces random variation but cannot repair systematic selection bias. For a voluntary poll, ask separately about random variation and whether volunteers differ systematically from the target population.
7 · Causation + Digital EvidenceC5
A causal claim says changing one factor produces or helps produce change in another. Correlation is measured association and alone does not identify which factor produces change. A confounder is associated with both proposed cause and outcome and can mislead.
| Observation | Permitted inference | Next test |
|---|---|---|
| Correlation | X and Y vary together | Direction, selection, alternatives |
| Sequence | X occurs before Y | Whether X produces change |
| Plausible mechanism | A causal story is available | Evidence against rival causes |
| Confounder Z | Association may mislead | How Z relates to both X and Y |