BMAN30071 Cheatsheet · Share Prices and Accounting Information

The University of Manchester · cheat sheet for the final exam. January 2027 examination period, 14–29 January 2027. Full BMAN30071 study guide →

BMAN30071
Share Prices and Accounting Information
The University of Manchester · Semester 1, 2026/27
Open-book exam sheetBMAN30071 cheatsheet QR code – open the full BMAN30071 study guide
Full guide + ask Sia
about BMAN30071
SIDE 1 · METHODS & DECISIONSModel → coefficient → economic meaning → limitationDesk reference

1 · Exam mapofficial facts

Exam 100%

“Assessment Method Exam (100%) in January 2027 examination period” (BMAN30071 course outline 2026/27) · “Students should be capable of completing this open book exam without the use of a calculator.” (BMAN30071 exam paper 2025/26)

ONLINE OPEN-BOOK: online, unseen and open book. 48-hour completion window; answer two of three questions, 50 marks each, combined 2,000-word limit.

What the final rewardsVisible working
Regression evidenceDV, base, units, combined slope
Integrated argumentmechanism → model → finding
Evaluationproxy/design-specific consequence

2 · Question decodercourse FAQ

Exam answer decision flowPROMPTMODELTESTMEANINGEVIDENCELIMITANSWER SUB-QUESTION
Decode first; significance symbols never substitute for model orientation or units.
  1. Define the claim: valuation level, price revision, recognition timing or disclosure effect?
  2. Map the equation: dependent variable, regressor, benchmark/base category, sign prediction.
  3. Read evidence: direction and economic magnitude; then precision; then model fit.
  4. Evaluate the path: timing, proxy noise, omitted traits, selection or forecast structure.

Answer architecture

Paragraph jobMinimum content
1 · mechanismwhy the accounting signal should reach value or return
2 · specificationY, main X, base group, predicted sign
3 · resultcombined coefficient; magnitude and precision separately
4 · evaluationone model-specific threat and how it changes inference
5 · judgementanswer the wording; keep association inside design limits

Questions can integrate several teaching sessions. Link neighbouring mechanisms explicitly: information timing → disclosure anticipation; recognition → conservatism; book value → adaptation or abnormal earnings; narrative construction → investor response.

3 · Price relevanceC1

Earnings news to share price responseActual ESurpriseX−E[X]Future EΔPPersistence ↑ effect
Expectation is the benchmark; persistence determines how many future periods are revised.
Information variableEarnings surprise = realised earnings − expected earnings
Return model: price revision ↔ news during a period
Price model: equity-value level ↔ accounting variables at a date
QuestionUseDo not claim
Value at date?Price specificationlevel = unexpected news
Revision in interval?Return specificationraw change = surprise
Equal surprises?compare persistence, risk, prior informationequal price response

Earnings can grow yet disappoint: the year-on-year change and the surprise can have opposite signs. A more persistent innovation revises a longer expected stream and can justify a larger response, subject to discounting, risk and other information.

Earnings-response coefficient = estimated return change for a defined unit of earnings news. Translate its units; association is not causation.

Persistence decision

Surprise storyFuture revisionExpected response
temporaryfew periods affectedrelatively weaker
persistentlonger earnings stream revisedrelatively stronger
already anticipatedlittle genuinely new informationweaker at announcement

A complete comparison holds the current surprise constant, varies the persistence or prior-information assumption, traces the altered future stream, then qualifies the response for discounting and risk. Do not jump directly from a reported earnings level to return.

Safe synthesis: price models explain value at a date; return models explain revisions during an interval using a defensible news proxy.

3b · Fit is not usefulnessC1 FAQ

A low R² says the fitted model associates earnings with a limited share of return variation in that sample. Timely non-earnings information, noisy surprise proxies and heterogeneous persistence can weaken contemporaneous fit without proving earnings irrelevant.

Exam tip State the expectation benchmark before calling any accounting number “news”.

4 · Regression toolkitC2

OLS fitted line and residualactual Yfitted Ŷŷ=α+βxearnings news Xreturn Y
OLS selects coefficients to minimise squared vertical residuals, e = Y − Ŷ.
Core relationsŶᵢ = α̂ + β̂Xᵢ · eᵢ = Yᵢ − Ŷᵢ
OLS chooses α̂, β̂ to minimise Σeᵢ²
R² = variation in Y associated with the fitted model / sample variation in Y
t = estimated coefficient / standard error

Table reading order

  1. Dependent variable and event/window; sample and scaling.
  2. Base group; set each dummy to 0 and 1.
  3. Direction + magnitude in stated units; combine interactions.
  4. Precision: t-statistic/test evidence is distinct from economic size.
  5. Explanatory power: R² is fit, not the coefficient or causal strength.
  6. Specific limitation: name the noisy proxy/path and predicted consequence.
Dummy interactionY = α + βX + γD + δ(X×D) + ε
D=0: intercept α; slope β
D=1: intercept α+γ; slope β+δ
δ tests the slope difference; the full D=1 slope may require a joint test.
Noise entersLecture consequence
Dependent variable Ylarger residual variation; weaker fit
Independent variable Xslope may attenuate toward zero under maintained conditions

Never collapse: statistical precision ≠ economic importance ≠ explanatory power. A small coefficient can matter if the unit change is large; a precise coefficient can still be economically slight.

Six-sentence table translation

  1. “The dependent variable is … measured over …”.
  2. “The omitted/base category is …”.
  3. “A one-unit increase in X is associated with β units of Y for the base group.”
  4. “For D=1, the slope is β+δ; δ is the group difference.”
  5. “The reported test gives evidence about …, while R² describes sample fit.”
  6. “Interpretation is limited by [named proxy/design path], which may [specific consequence].”

5 · Prices lead earningsC3

Information arrives before accounting recognitionEcon newsPrice moveE recog.Delay
One economic event can be split across periods, weakening a same-period relation.

Prices need not know the future perfectly. Alternative information can update expectations before accounting verification recognises the consequence. Earlier return then contains news without later earnings; later earnings contains recognition after the main price move.

Empirical remedyGainCost
Longer return windowcaptures earlier price responseadmits unrelated firm/market news
Future earnings variablesrepresents delayed accounting consequencesfuture variables/proxies remain noisy

6 · Disclosure anticipationC4

Disclosure anticipation modelDisc. QControlsFuture ENow RQ shifts slope
The hypothesis concerns the current-return slope on future earnings, conditional on controls.
Anticipation testCurrent return = … + β(Future earnings) + δ(Future earnings×High disclosure) + controls + ε
Low disclosure slope = β
High disclosure slope = β+δ

A positive δ is consistent with stronger anticipation only if it is estimated precisely and the design is credible. It does not prove disclosure caused the full association: disclosure groups may differ in predictability, industry, size or incentives.

Controls have jobs: future returns address price-related measurement effects in future earnings; earnings yield, growth and firm traits address specified alternative paths. Explain each from the design, never as generic “controls”.

Joint-evidence test

Show why later earnings can represent consequences priced today; show that disclosure changes that slope; then ask whether disclosure merely sorts firms by underlying predictability. A positive, precise δ is consistent with stronger anticipation, while systematic group differences still threaten a causal claim.

7 · Earnings conservatismC5

Asymmetric earnings timelinessBAD: steepGOOD: flatbad R<0good R≥0return/newsscaled E
The reverse regression asks how earnings responds to market news; the bad-news branch is steeper.
Basu-style orientationEarnings = α + βR + γD + δ(R×D) + ε
D=0 good-news slope = β
D=1 bad-news slope = β+δ
Prediction: δ>0 under the stated negative-return dummy convention.
Correct readingTrap
δ is the incremental bad-news sensitivityδ is the full bad-news slope
earnings responds to return as news proxyreturn responds to earnings
larger magnitude reflected more promptlybad news raises income
timeliness = when recognisedpersistence = how long it lasts

Verification can delay favourable developments while losses enter sooner. The result is a recognition-timing claim, not a claim that losses are beneficial or permanent.

Evaluation points

  • Is return a clean proxy for economic news?
  • Is the dummy coding stated rather than assumed?
  • Do scaling and cross-firm recognition differences change the comparison?
  • Does test evidence support the slope difference and/or the combined slope?

Reconstruction grid

SetEquation pieceMeaning
D=0α + βRgood-news base relation
D=1(α+γ) + (β+δ)Rbad-news intercept and slope
δ>0bad slope − good slopepredicted asymmetric timeliness

Keep sign and magnitude distinct. Negative returns proxy adverse news, so earnings generally moves downward; the steeper branch means the magnitude is reflected more strongly. A positive δ supports asymmetry only under the stated coding and with adequate precision.

Essay bridge: conservatism helps explain why current earnings can lag some value-relevant developments and why equal reported earnings may have different implications when recognition histories differ. Keep this connection distinct from the persistence of the recognised component.

8 · Adapt or continue?C6

Adaptation and recursion value envelopeadaptationrecursionswitching regionearnings ÷ book value
Market value follows the better opportunity: alternative use for weak operations, continuation for strong ones.
Profitability regionRelative anchorLogic
low E/BVbook/adaptation value ↑resources poorly used now
switchingboth matteroptions are close
high E/BVearnings/recursion value ↑continuation produces more

Adaptation includes restructuring, sale, takeover or internal redeployment—not only liquidation. Recursion capitalises sustainable earnings from the existing business technology. Scale earnings by book value before ranking operating success.

Proxy limits: recorded equity may differ from recoverable resources; current earnings may not be sustainable; discrete profitability groups approximate a continuous switching process.

9 · Abnormal-earnings valueC7

Book value and abnormal earnings valuation bridgeOpening BV× required rReportedearningsAbnormalearningsCurrent BV+PV expected futureabnormal earnings
Value starts at current book value; only expected performance above the capital charge is added.
Period disciplineClean surplus: BVₜ = BVₜ₋₁ + Eₜ − dₜ
Normal earningsₜ = r × BVₜ₋₁
Abnormal earningsₜ = Eₜ − rBVₜ₋₁
Vₜ = BVₜ + PV(expected future abnormal earnings)

Use opening book value for the capital charge. Dividends reduce closing book value through clean surplus; they are not deducted again from earnings. Zero abnormal earnings means the firm earned exactly the required return, not zero accounting profit.

Information dynamics forecast persistence and other information. Separate the clean-surplus identity from linear forecasting assumptions: structural change or conservative recognition may weaken the dynamics without erasing the book-value anchor.

https://www.asksia.ai/cheatsheet/manchester-bman30071 · Full BMAN30071 study guide → · side 1/2
Shared by
AskSiaForward this to your tutorial group
v2 · 2026-10-16 · January 2027 examination period, 14–29 January 2027
check the exam instructions on the LMS
BMAN30071
Worked drills, traps & fast recall
Share Prices and Accounting Information · The University of Manchester
Open-book exam sheetBMAN30071 cheatsheet QR code – open the full BMAN30071 study guide
Full guide + ask Sia
about BMAN30071
SIDE 2 · WORKED STEPSCalculate → interpret → qualify5 worked drills

W1 · Growth ≠ surpriseC1 worked

Given: prior earnings 40; realised earnings 46; investors expected 45.

Worked earnings growth and surprisePrior 40Exp. 45Actual 46raw Δ = +6surprise = +1
The information benchmark is expected earnings, not last year's amount.
  1. Raw change: 46 − 40 = +6.
  2. Surprise: 46 − 45 = +1.
  3. For a return model about new information, use the surprise; the expected 45 was already incorporated in beliefs.
  4. Then ask whether the +1 is temporary or persistent before predicting price response.
Answer lineEarnings grew by 6, but only 1 exceeded the prior expectation. The return-news interpretation therefore concerns +1, conditional on the expectation proxy and persistence.
VariantCorrect diagnosis
actual 72, prior 68, expected 75growth +4; surprise −3
equal current surprisescompare persistence, risk, information already known

Fast traps · NewsC1/C3

  • Reported amount ≠ unexpected component.
  • Prices leading earnings ≠ perfect foresight.
  • Longer windows gain timing coverage but lose event specificity.
  • Low contemporaneous R² ≠ accounting information is useless.

Write the mechanism, not a slogan

Return-model chain: prior expectation → realised outcome → unexpected component → revised future earnings/cash-flow beliefs → price revision. Locate persistence between the surprise and the future revision; locate discounting and risk between that revision and price.

Lead–lag chain: economic development → non-earnings information → earlier price response → later accounting recognition. A contemporaneous regression can then place related return and earnings effects in different observations, creating measurement mismatch.

Weak answerMarker-useful repair
“earnings rose”state realised, expected and surprise
“price knew first”name the earlier information and recognition delay

W2 · Rebuild interactionsC2/C4 worked

Interaction slopes for base and indicated groupD=0: β=.60D1: β+δ=.95δ=.35XY
The interaction rotates the slope away from the base relation; it is not the full indicated-group slope.

A · Positive-news group

Base slope β = 0.60
Interaction δ = +0.35
D=0 slope = 0.60
D=1 slope = 0.60 + 0.35 = 0.95

0.35 is the estimated difference between slopes; it is not the entire positive-news response.

B · Disclosure anticipation

Low-disclosure base = 0.20
High-disclosure interaction = +0.30
High-disclosure slope = 0.20 + 0.30 = 0.50

The future-earnings association is 0.30 larger for high-disclosure firms, consistent with stronger anticipation if precise and credibly identified. It is not proof that disclosure causes the entire 0.50.

C · Course overview variant

Low-disclosure slope = 0.18
High-disclosure increment = 0.27
High-disclosure slope = 0.18 + 0.27 = 0.45

The 0.27 coefficient answers the difference question. The 0.45 combined slope answers the high-disclosure association question. Evidence that δ differs from zero does not automatically test whether β+δ differs from zero; identify the test the table actually reports.

CoefficientQuestion answered
βbase-group slope
δdifference between slopes
β+δindicated-group slope
t on δevidence about the difference
  1. Write base group and dummy coding.
  2. Substitute D=0, then D=1.
  3. Add coefficients with signs intact.
  4. Translate into variable units.
  5. Separate estimate, test evidence and causal credibility.

Diagnostic questions

  • Does D change the intercept, the slope, or both?
  • Is X centred or scaled, changing the intercept's practical meaning?
  • Do group traits make the interaction a sorting result rather than a treatment effect?

W3 · Bad-news sensitivityC5 worked

Given: reverse-regression good-news slope 0.18; bad-news interaction 0.27.

Worked conservatism slopesbad R<0good R≥0bad = .45good = .18
Negative-return observations have the 0.45 slope; the 0.27 interaction is only the increment.
  1. Orient the equation: earnings is Y; return is the news proxy.
  2. For D=0 good news, slope = 0.18.
  3. For D=1 bad news, slope = 0.18 + 0.27 = 0.45.
  4. Because 0.45 > 0.18, earnings is more sensitive to the magnitude of bad news—consistent with more timely recognition, subject to test evidence.
Answer lineThe bad-news slope is 0.45, exceeding the good-news slope of 0.18. This is consistent with asymmetric timeliness; it does not mean adverse news raises earnings.
ErrorRepair
“bad slope = .27”add the .18 base slope
“bad news raises earnings”larger response to adverse-news magnitude
“timely means persistent”timing and duration are separate
assume D=1read coding stated in the model

Recognition argumentC5

Mechanism: favourable developments may await realisation or verification; adverse developments can enter through loss recognition sooner. Limit: return is an imperfect news proxy, and scaling/recognition differs across firms.

Second coefficient check

Base return slope = 0.22
Bad-news interaction = 0.31
Negative-return slope = 0.22 + 0.31 = 0.53

Again, 0.31 is the increment. The 0.53 relation applies only after confirming negative-return observations are coded D=1. A negative interaction would contradict the predicted steeper bad-news branch rather than becoming evidence of conservatism by relabelling.

ConceptQuestionNot the same as
timelinesswhen does news enter earnings?duration of the component
persistencehow long does it continue?speed of first recognition

W4 · Valuation ledgerC6/C7 worked

Given: opening BV = 200; required return = 8%; reported earnings = 26.

Abnormal earnings worked calculationBV₀=200×r=8%=Norm=16E=26− 16 =Abn E=10
The capital charge uses opening book value; abnormal earnings is not total firm value.
  1. Normal earnings = 200 × 0.08 = 16.
  2. Abnormal earnings = 26 − 16 = 10.
  3. Interpret 10 as performance above the period's required return. If expected to persist, its discounted future stream contributes value above the current book-value anchor.
Keep the two lines separateBV closing = BV opening + earnings − dividends
Abnormal E = earnings − r × BV opening
CheckCorrect answer
Which BV in charge?opening BV for that period
Dividends?reduce closing BV; do not deduct twice
AE = 0?earned normal required return, not zero profit
AE = 10?one-period excess performance, not V

Adaptation cross-check

Two firms each have BV 100. Sustainable earnings are 4 and 18. E/BV is 4% versus 18%: the 4 firm is closer to the adaptation region; the 18 firm to recursion. This is a relative-anchor judgement, not a complete price formula.

Negative abnormal earnings check

Opening BV = 150; required return = 10%; earnings = 12
Normal earnings = 150 × .10 = 15
Abnormal earnings = 12 − 15 = −3

The firm made positive accounting profit of 12 but fell 3 below the required capital charge. Do not call −3 total value or deduct a dividend from earnings again. Current value still begins with book value; expected future abnormal earnings adjust that anchor.

Forecast and identity audit

ComponentStatusExam implication
clean surplusaccounting identityroll BV with E and dividends
capital chargerequired-return calculationuse opening equity
persistence ruleforecast assumptionchanges PV of future AE
other informationforecast inputcaptures news not yet in accounting variables

W5 · Tone & disclosure curveC8/C9 worked

A · Abnormal tone residual

Observed tone decomposed into normal and abnormal toneObs. .13−Normal .08=Abn. .05response → correction?
Abnormal tone is the residual from a fitted normal-tone model, not automatic evidence of intent.
Abnormal tone = observed net tone − predicted normal tone
= 0.13 − 0.08 = 0.05

Interpret 0.05 as unexplained positive tone under the fitted model. Legitimate omitted drivers can enter the residual. Stronger evidence joins a favourable immediate response with weaker later returns/performance or another correction pattern.

Four-stage check: measure raw wording; predict normal tone from fundamentals; call the remainder a model-dependent residual; then compare immediate and later outcomes. Positive wording alone does not establish manipulation, and one market window does not establish correction.

B · Quadratic turning point

U-shaped disclosure cost relationinfo benefitclutter costD*=1cost of equity
A negative linear and positive squared term imply a U-shape only when read jointly.
Fitted component = −0.24D + 0.12D²
Derivative = −0.24 + 0.24D
Set to 0 ⇒ D* = 1
0.12>0 ⇒ stationary point is a minimum.

State the disclosure scale and check D*=1 lies within the observed range. It is model- and sample-specific, not a universal report length; incentives may drive both narrative volume and financing cost.

Turning-point checklist

  1. Read linear and squared coefficients jointly; differentiate.
  2. Set the marginal effect to zero and solve in the stated units.
  3. Use the squared-term sign to classify the point.
  4. Check it lies inside the observed range; outside is not an observed optimum.

Controls do not by themselves remove the possibility that higher-risk firms choose longer narratives.

10 · Interim substitutionC10

Interim statement moves information before annual releaseinterim updateannual releaseearlier news → less later surprise↑↓
Claim substitution only from the joint early-and-late pattern and incremental content.
Observed patternInterpretation
strong update responseincremental information moved forward
smaller annual responseless surprise remained later
little update responsestatement may be repetitive
return movementprice revision
trading activityprocessing/disagreement, not the same construct

Withdrawal of informative statements may remove timely firm-specific news and increase later surprise; withdrawal of repetitive statements need not. Evaluate content classification, other disclosures, and selection into voluntary reporting.

11 · Method chooserC1–C10

Method chooser for BMAN30071WHAT CHANGES?Val./priceTiming/recog.Disc./resp.R; adapt.Abnorm ELead–lagAntic./cons.Tone; UInterim
Choose the model by the economic question, then identify its dependent variable and comparison.
TopicRememberMain caveat
price relevancesurprise + persistencebenchmark/timing noise
regressionbase + interactionunits; association
conservatismreverse regressionnews proxy/coding
adaptationupper value envelopeBV and E are proxies
abnormal earningsBV + PV future AEforecast dynamics
toneobserved − normalomitted drivers
narrative volumelinear + squared jointlyrange/endogeneity
interim reportingearly + late windowscontent/selection
Final pass Claim only what the coefficient, timing window and design can support.
https://www.asksia.ai/cheatsheet/manchester-bman30071 · Full BMAN30071 study guide → · side 2/2
Shared by
AskSiaForward this to your tutorial group
v2 · 2026-10-16 · January 2027 examination period, 14–29 January 2027
open-book desk reference

Want one for YOUR exact syllabus?

Sia is your free desktop study agent. Drop your The University of Manchester BMAN30071 slides — Sia builds a sheet tailored to YOUR exam. Better than this library because it knows YOUR materials.

↓ Download Sia · Free