about LAWS70271
1 · Exam Mapcourse data · brief
Formative assessment: 0%. Attempt three questions from six, mixing problem and essay questions.
Permitted-materials truth“24 -hour on-line examination, open book.”
— LAWS70271 Course unit information 2026/27
2 · Answer Enginecourse strategy
| Move | What the paragraph must do |
|---|---|
| Issue | Frame the legal question from the exact claim, date, act or disclosure. |
| Rule | Name the section/Article, the authority and the legal test. |
| Apply | Work each element against the facts; expose uncertainty and the opponent's best answer. |
| Conclude | Give advice on that issue before moving on. |
Exam move Put the statutory provision, European equivalent, leading authority and one application sentence under every topic heading.
3 · Patent SystemC1
| Route | PCT international application; EPO European application; UKIPO national filing. |
|---|---|
| Right | A negative right: stop exploitation; it does not authorise use. s 60 acts; s 30 assignment/licence; maximum term s 25 / Art 63 EPC. |
| After grant | EPO opposition Art 99 within nine months; UK revocation s 72; validity in issue under s 74 if sued. |
Application. Filing requires the request, description, claims and abstract; claims define the monopoly and disclosure supplies the public return. Under s 7 PA 77 anyone may apply, but grant goes primarily to the inventor, subject to s 39.
Forum. Keep central EPO procedure distinct from UK litigation. The Unitary Patent system does not extend to the UK, so disputes over the UK designation run nationally.
4 · Why Patent?C1 · Actavis v ICOS
| Rationale | Use in an essay |
|---|---|
| Natural rights | Lockean labour account. |
| Incentive | Exclusive rights may reward innovation; test empirical criticism. |
| Disclosure | Lord Hodge in Actavis v ICOS: reward now, disclosure and later dedication to the public. |
Liardet v Johnson also appears in the bargain account. A strong essay takes a position, answers the strongest objection and connects rationale to doctrine.
5 · Invention TestC2 · s 1 · Art 52
TRIPS Art 27(1) leaves “invention” undefined. Art 52(1)–(3) EPC and s 1(1)–(2) PA 77 instead list exclusions and confine them to matter claimed as such.
Technical teachinginstruction to the skilled person to solve a particular technical problem with particular technical means
T 154/04 DUNS Licensing: mixed claims may pass, even if non-technical features dominate; only technical features can establish novelty and inventive step. Emotional Perception AI Ltd v Comptroller [2026] UKSC 3 [67] adopted DUNS and overruled Aerotel.
DUNS memory: four independent requirements → technicality → “as such” → construe the claim → mixed claims permitted → non-technical features cannot solve the technical problem.
6 · Exclusions ChecklistC2
| Excluded matter | Question to ask |
|---|---|
| Discovery / mathematical method | Is this the abstract thing itself, or a technical teaching? |
| Aesthetic creation | Which claimed feature solves a technical problem? |
| Business method | Does ordinary hardware supply character only, leaving no inventive technical feature? |
| Computer program | Is there technical means / a further technical effect? |
| Presentation of information | Does the feature contribute technically? |
Trap Do not run the former four Aerotel steps as current law. Under DUNS, technical character clears the invention hurdle; patentability may still fail later.
7 · Software & AIC3 · COMVIK
Programs are excluded as such under Art 52(2)(c) EPC / s 1(2) PA 77; TRIPS Art 10 protects source and object code as literary works. A further technical effect goes beyond ordinary software–hardware interaction.
| Claim | Route |
|---|---|
| Program on storage medium | Medium is technical; still test inventive step (G 3/08 example). |
| Computer-implemented method | Technical means clears invention; under COMVIK, only technical features support inventive step. |
| Image processing / encryption / boot integrity | Examples of effects beyond normal interaction in the EPO material. |
Emotional Perception [80]–[96]: an artificial neural network is a set of instructions and therefore a program; hardware gives the claim technical character. Then identify its inventive technical contribution.
8 · InventorshipC3 · s 7
s 7 PA 77 is exhaustive: grant to inventor, person entitled to the whole property, or successor. Rhone-Poulenc v Yeda [2007] UKHL 43 identifies the inventor as the human deviser of the inventive concept. The UK Supreme Court rejected Dr Thaler's AI-inventor applications in 2023; EPO and US reached the same result.
9 · Novelty & PriorityC4 · ss 2, 5
s 2(1) PA 77 / Art 54 EPC: new unless already in the state of the art. s 2(2): everything made available to the public anywhere before the priority date, by description, use or any other way. s 5(1): filing date unless a valid earlier filing is claimed.
| Provision | Condition | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| s 2(2) | Public before priority, anywhere | State of art |
| s 2(3) | Other application published on/after priority; same matter as filed and published; earlier priority | Deemed state of art |
| s 2(4) | Breach of confidence within six months before filing | Disregard |
Art 87 EPC: twelve-month priority right. Unwired Planet v Huawei: judge the 24-hour day in the filing office's time zone; novelty is assessed at the start of the priority date, so a disclosure later that day does not anticipate.
10 · Made AvailableC4
Information must reach at least one person outside any duty of secrecy who could acquire and understand it. A skilled reader uses common general knowledge: Idenix v Gilead [2016] EWCA Civ 1089 = what most in the field treat as a sound footing, including matter looked up as a matter of course; Regen Lab v Estar Medical [2019] EWHC 63 = territorial.
| T 2/09 Philips: internet transmission alone was not public; ask who received every element without secrecy. | |
| Document | Potentially available and directly accessible may suffice. |
| Product/use | Counts only for information the public can derive. |
T 381/87 treats receipt by a person free of secrecy as a question of fact. Separate access from comprehension: identify the recipient, duty of secrecy and what the skilled addressee could derive.
Exam move Write the priority date at the top, place every item before/on/after it, assign the subsection, then ask what it teaches.
11 · AnticipationC5 · Synthon
Under Dyson v Samsung [129], one item of prior art must (1) disclose subject matter which, if performed, would necessarily infringe, and (2) enable the skilled person to perform it. Synthon v SmithKline Beecham keeps the requirements separate.
| Disclosure | Enablement |
|---|---|
| Clear directions; performance must inevitably fall within the claim. The skilled person cannot invent missing matter. | Once matter is disclosed, routine trial and error is allowed; no inventive effort or prolonged research. |
General Tire and Flour Oxidising v Carr support clear and unmistakable directions. Do not use experiments to fill a disclosure gap.
12 · Prior Use & PublicationC5
Merrell Dow v Norton: an invention is information; prior use anticipates only what it communicates. Secret use never enters the state of the art. Lux Traffic Controls: a public-library book anticipates whether or not anyone read it. Windsurfing v Tabur Marine: potentially available and directly accessible.
Sealed prototype Public display does not disclose an internal valve arrangement that visitors cannot see or derive.
13 · Inventive StepC6 · s 1(1)
Synthon [25], citing General Tire: if prior art would not itself infringe but makes an infringing adaptation obvious, the objection is inventive step, not novelty.
| Novelty | Obviousness |
|---|---|
| Test each disclosure alone: would performance necessarily infringe? | Ask whether the skilled person at priority would find the adaptation obvious. |
| Do not mosaic separate documents into one disclosure. | The problem is framed from prior art, technical difference and technical effect; only technical features count after COMVIK. |
Problem–solution: identify closest prior art → technical difference → technical problem/effect → would solution be obvious? Actavis v ICOS supplies approved approaches in the seminar reading; state the approach used rather than announcing “obvious”.
14 · Exceptions & AttackC7 · Arts 53, 99, 100
| Medical/veterinary methods | Read what the steps do to the body. “Non-therapeutic” is an argument, not a conclusion. |
|---|---|
| Morality / ordre public | Art 53(a) EPC; biotechnology also engages Schedule A2 PA 77 and Directive 98/44. |
| Procedure | Anyone may oppose within nine months; Art 100 reaches non-patentability under Arts 52–57. Faith groups and ethicists may intervene as opponents. |
Fallback Plead novelty and inventive step if the exception argument fails; after the window use s 72 or s 74.