LAWS70271 Cheatsheet · Patent Law and Policy

The University of Manchester · open-book exam sheet for the final exam. 24-hour online open-book examination, Semester 1 2026/27 (check the date in your exam timetable). Full LAWS70271 study guide →

A4 landscape · two sides · six columns · print at 100%LAWS70271 · Patent Law and Policy
LAWS70271
Patent Law and Policy
The University of Manchester · Postgraduate · 1st Semester 2026/27
LAWS70271 cheatsheet QR code – open the full LAWS70271 study guide
Full guide + ask Sia
about LAWS70271
SIDE 1/2   ISSUE ORDER · authority → rule → application → conclusionOPEN-BOOK EXAM SHEETValidity first · then exceptions · then infringement

1 · Exam Mapcourse data · brief

24-hour online examination · 100%

Formative assessment: 0%. Attempt three questions from six, mixing problem and essay questions.

Permitted-materials truth“24 -hour on-line examination, open book.”
— LAWS70271 Course unit information 2026/27

Three questions selected from sixQ1Q2Q3Q4Q5Q6choose any 3
Six are set; three are answered. Prepare enough problem and essay topics to preserve choice.

2 · Answer Enginecourse strategy

MoveWhat the paragraph must do
IssueFrame the legal question from the exact claim, date, act or disclosure.
RuleName the section/Article, the authority and the legal test.
ApplyWork each element against the facts; expose uncertainty and the opponent's best answer.
ConcludeGive advice on that issue before moving on.
Validity issue orderinventionnoveltyinventivestepexcep-tionsscope
For validity: keep the tests separate and run them in this order.

Exam move Put the statutory provision, European equivalent, leading authority and one application sentence under every topic heading.

3 · Patent SystemC1

RoutePCT international application; EPO European application; UKIPO national filing.
RightA negative right: stop exploitation; it does not authorise use. s 60 acts; s 30 assignment/licence; maximum term s 25 / Art 63 EPC.
After grantEPO opposition Art 99 within nine months; UK revocation s 72; validity in issue under s 74 if sued.

Application. Filing requires the request, description, claims and abstract; claims define the monopoly and disclosure supplies the public return. Under s 7 PA 77 anyone may apply, but grant goes primarily to the inventor, subject to s 39.

Forum. Keep central EPO procedure distinct from UK litigation. The Unitary Patent system does not extend to the UK, so disputes over the UK designation run nationally.

4 · Why Patent?C1 · Actavis v ICOS

The patent bargaininventordisclosespublicreceivesfull disclosuretime-limited right
The disclosure bargain explains both reward and the public return.
RationaleUse in an essay
Natural rightsLockean labour account.
IncentiveExclusive rights may reward innovation; test empirical criticism.
DisclosureLord Hodge in Actavis v ICOS: reward now, disclosure and later dedication to the public.

Liardet v Johnson also appears in the bargain account. A strong essay takes a position, answers the strongest objection and connects rationale to doctrine.

5 · Invention TestC2 · s 1 · Art 52

TRIPS Art 27(1) leaves “invention” undefined. Art 52(1)–(3) EPC and s 1(1)–(2) PA 77 instead list exclusions and confine them to matter claimed as such.

DUNS invention decision treeconstrue claimtechnical character /technical teaching?noyesnot inventioninvention; filterlater features
DUNS: invention is separate from novelty, inventive step and industrial application.

Technical teachinginstruction to the skilled person to solve a particular technical problem with particular technical means

T 154/04 DUNS Licensing: mixed claims may pass, even if non-technical features dominate; only technical features can establish novelty and inventive step. Emotional Perception AI Ltd v Comptroller [2026] UKSC 3 [67] adopted DUNS and overruled Aerotel.

DUNS memory: four independent requirements → technicality → “as such” → construe the claim → mixed claims permitted → non-technical features cannot solve the technical problem.

6 · Exclusions ChecklistC2

Excluded matterQuestion to ask
Discovery / mathematical methodIs this the abstract thing itself, or a technical teaching?
Aesthetic creationWhich claimed feature solves a technical problem?
Business methodDoes ordinary hardware supply character only, leaving no inventive technical feature?
Computer programIs there technical means / a further technical effect?
Presentation of informationDoes the feature contribute technically?

Trap Do not run the former four Aerotel steps as current law. Under DUNS, technical character clears the invention hurdle; patentability may still fail later.

7 · Software & AIC3 · COMVIK

Programs are excluded as such under Art 52(2)(c) EPC / s 1(2) PA 77; TRIPS Art 10 protects source and object code as literary works. A further technical effect goes beyond ordinary software–hardware interaction.

Software hurdlesArt 52Art 56hardwareinventivetechnicalfeature?low bar ≠ patentability
A computer may clear Art 52; COMVIK leaves Art 56 to do the real filtering.
ClaimRoute
Program on storage mediumMedium is technical; still test inventive step (G 3/08 example).
Computer-implemented methodTechnical means clears invention; under COMVIK, only technical features support inventive step.
Image processing / encryption / boot integrityExamples of effects beyond normal interaction in the EPO material.

Emotional Perception [80]–[96]: an artificial neural network is a set of instructions and therefore a program; hardware gives the claim technical character. Then identify its inventive technical contribution.

8 · InventorshipC3 · s 7

s 7 PA 77 is exhaustive: grant to inventor, person entitled to the whole property, or successor. Rhone-Poulenc v Yeda [2007] UKHL 43 identifies the inventor as the human deviser of the inventive concept. The UK Supreme Court rejected Dr Thaler's AI-inventor applications in 2023; EPO and US reached the same result.

9 · Novelty & PriorityC4 · ss 2, 5

s 2(1) PA 77 / Art 54 EPC: new unless already in the state of the art. s 2(2): everything made available to the public anywhere before the priority date, by description, use or any other way. s 5(1): filing date unless a valid earlier filing is claimed.

Novelty and priority timelines 2(4)6 mo bandfile / 0mpriority yr12mpublish18mPCT30/31m
Sort dates first. The priority right lasts twelve months; publication is shown at eighteen months.
ProvisionConditionEffect
s 2(2)Public before priority, anywhereState of art
s 2(3)Other application published on/after priority; same matter as filed and published; earlier priorityDeemed state of art
s 2(4)Breach of confidence within six months before filingDisregard

Art 87 EPC: twelve-month priority right. Unwired Planet v Huawei: judge the 24-hour day in the filing office's time zone; novelty is assessed at the start of the priority date, so a disclosure later that day does not anticipate.

10 · Made AvailableC4

Information must reach at least one person outside any duty of secrecy who could acquire and understand it. A skilled reader uses common general knowledge: Idenix v Gilead [2016] EWCA Civ 1089 = what most in the field treat as a sound footing, including matter looked up as a matter of course; Regen Lab v Estar Medical [2019] EWHC 63 = territorial.

EmailT 2/09 Philips: internet transmission alone was not public; ask who received every element without secrecy.
DocumentPotentially available and directly accessible may suffice.
Product/useCounts only for information the public can derive.

T 381/87 treats receipt by a person free of secrecy as a question of fact. Separate access from comprehension: identify the recipient, duty of secrecy and what the skilled addressee could derive.

Exam move Write the priority date at the top, place every item before/on/after it, assign the subsection, then ask what it teaches.

11 · AnticipationC5 · Synthon

Under Dyson v Samsung [129], one item of prior art must (1) disclose subject matter which, if performed, would necessarily infringe, and (2) enable the skilled person to perform it. Synthon v SmithKline Beecham keeps the requirements separate.

Disclosure and enablement gatesprior artdiscloses?necessaryenables?performyesboth → anticipates
Failure at either gate defeats anticipation; the art may still support obviousness.
DisclosureEnablement
Clear directions; performance must inevitably fall within the claim. The skilled person cannot invent missing matter.Once matter is disclosed, routine trial and error is allowed; no inventive effort or prolonged research.

General Tire and Flour Oxidising v Carr support clear and unmistakable directions. Do not use experiments to fill a disclosure gap.

12 · Prior Use & PublicationC5

Prior-use matrixcommunicates invention?yesnopublic?yesnopossibleanticipationno disclosuresecret use:not prior artneither gateis met
Public access and informative content are separate questions.

Merrell Dow v Norton: an invention is information; prior use anticipates only what it communicates. Secret use never enters the state of the art. Lux Traffic Controls: a public-library book anticipates whether or not anyone read it. Windsurfing v Tabur Marine: potentially available and directly accessible.

Sealed prototype Public display does not disclose an internal valve arrangement that visitors cannot see or derive.

13 · Inventive StepC6 · s 1(1)

Synthon [25], citing General Tire: if prior art would not itself infringe but makes an infringing adaptation obvious, the objection is inventive step, not novelty.

NoveltyObviousness
Test each disclosure alone: would performance necessarily infringe?Ask whether the skilled person at priority would find the adaptation obvious.
Do not mosaic separate documents into one disclosure.The problem is framed from prior art, technical difference and technical effect; only technical features count after COMVIK.
Dirrige and Samaria feature comparisonfeatureSamariaDirrigestage 1yesyesstage 2yesyesstage 3requiredoptional
Dirrige's optional third stage is the gap: option is not automatically a clear direction.

Problem–solution: identify closest prior art → technical difference → technical problem/effect → would solution be obvious? Actavis v ICOS supplies approved approaches in the seminar reading; state the approach used rather than announcing “obvious”.

14 · Exceptions & AttackC7 · Arts 53, 99, 100

Medical/veterinary methodsRead what the steps do to the body. “Non-therapeutic” is an argument, not a conclusion.
Morality / ordre publicArt 53(a) EPC; biotechnology also engages Schedule A2 PA 77 and Directive 98/44.
ProcedureAnyone may oppose within nine months; Art 100 reaches non-patentability under Arts 52–57. Faith groups and ethicists may intervene as opponents.
EPO opposition windowgrant6 months9 mo limit3 left
At six months after grant, three months remain for a central EPO attack.

Fallback Plead novelty and inventive step if the exception argument fails; after the window use s 72 or s 74.

https://www.asksia.ai/cheatsheet/manchester-laws70271
Forward this to your tutorial group · Shared by
AskSiav2 · 2026-10-19
24-hour online open-book examination, Semester 1 2026/27 (check the date in your exam timetable).
side 1/2 →
LAWS70271
Patent Law and Policy · Drills & Fast Recall
The University of Manchester · problem questions + policy essays
LAWS70271 cheatsheet QR code – open the full LAWS70271 study guide
Full guide + ask Sia
about LAWS70271
SIDE 2/2   DRILL → rule → facts → counterargument → adviceOPEN-BOOK EXAM SHEETFast recall: dates · gates · scope · policy

Drill A · Server ClaimC2 worked example

Facts. Retail-demand method: collect sales figures, apply statistical weighting, run it on a networked server.

IssueRule + application
Invention?DUNS (b): technical character is implicit. Server and transmission are technical means, so not a business method as such.
Which features survive?DUNS (f): weighting and demand estimate do not solve a technical problem with claimed technical means.
ResultPass Art 52; novelty and inventive step stand or fall on the server arrangement.
Mixed claim feature filtersales +weightingserver +transmissionnovelty / steptechnical onlyset aside
Mixed claim: the server gets through; the commercial idea gives no later advantage.

Answer line “An invention, but not necessarily patentable.” Separate the threshold from the later merits.

Neural-Network VariantC3 worked example

Crop-image grading by a trained neural network on a server. Concede that the network is a set of instructions and therefore a program (Emotional Perception [80]–[96]). Hardware supplies technical character; then under COMVIK ask what the image processing contributes technically against prior art.

Counterargument. The exclusion is engaged, but that is not the conclusion. Ask whether the hardware and processing supply a new and inventive technical contribution.

Inventorship trapDo not confuse patentable AI-related subject matter with naming AI as inventor. s 7 + Yeda + Thaler require a natural person.

Software RecallArt 52 → Art 56

Computer claim sequencehardware?charactertechnicalfeaturesinventivestepnever stop at “computer”
The claim clears invention before technical features are tested for inventive step.

Drill B · Three Disclosurescourse worked example

Facts. UK filing 14 June. April conference poster; rival application with earlier priority published in September; supplier disclosure in breach of confidence in February.

Three disclosures around 14 JuneFeb breachApr poster14 Jun fileSep publish
Dates choose the subsection before content is tested.
ItemRouteAdvice
April posters 2(2)Public before priority if no secrecy: state of art.
Rival applications 2(3)Earlier priority + later publication; same matter as filed/published: deemed state of art.
February breachs 2(4)Within six months and breach of confidence: disregard.

ConclusionPoster + rival application may be cited; supplier disclosure must be disregarded. Then test disclosure and enablement.

Same-Day VariantUnwired Planet

UK filing 3 May at 15:00; rival publishes online at 09:00 UK time. With no earlier claim, priority is 3 May under s 5(1). Novelty is assessed from the start of that day in the filing office's time zone. Same-day publication does not anticipate, although it may matter to later filings.

Always writeoffice/time zone → priority date → beginning of day → before/on/after.
AvoidComparing clock times before identifying the legal date.

Priority Recalls 5 · Art 87

First to file, not first to invent. A later application may claim a valid first filing in a Paris Convention state or WTO Member within twelve months. s 2(3) is not ordinary public art; s 2(4) is narrow, date-bound relief, not permission to disclose freely.

Fact cueImmediate response
Poster / talk / saleBefore priority, public and free of secrecy? Route to s 2(2).
Earlier filing, later publicationCheck earlier priority and identical matter as filed and published: s 2(3).
Leak by confidantUnlawful or in breach, within six months before filing? s 2(4).

Knowledge. Common general knowledge interprets one disclosure; it does not fuse several into one novelty citation. Record the territory and the field's reliable footing.

Drill C · Old JournalC5 worked example

Facts. Claim: solvent blend at a stated ratio. Ten-year-old journal gives the same blend and ratio but no preparation detail; a chemist can make it by routine mixing.

Old journal anticipation analysissame blend+ rationecessaryinfringementroutinemixingdiscloses + enables → anticipated
The missing preparation detail is supplied by routine skill at enablement, not by invention.
RuleDyson [129]: necessary infringement + enablement; keep separate under Synthon.
DisclosureSame blend and ratio: performance necessarily infringes.
AvailabilityPublic journal is available whether anyone read it (Lux).
EnablementRoutine mixing; trial and error is permissible here and requires no invention or prolonged research.
ConclusionBoth gates met: claim lacks novelty.

Near Miss → ObviousnessC6 worked example

Kettle claim has a whistle in the lid. A shows the kettle without whistle; B, from another field, shows a whistle on a pressure valve.

Novelty versus obviousness with two documentsA: kettleB: whistleclaimedcombinationnot novelty; ask obviousness
No single disclosure anticipates; combining the teachings belongs to inventive step.

Advice. Novelty attack fails. Redirect under Synthon [25]: would the skilled person look to pressure valves and find the adaptation obvious? The patentee argues why the fields would not be combined.

Prior-use variant. A sealed pump is shown publicly, but visitors cannot open it and the claim concerns its internal valve. Under Merrell Dow, use reveals only what it communicates: no valve disclosure means no necessary infringement. Secret use is not prior art.

Marker signal Test A alone, then B alone, before discussing any combination.

Drill D · Variant ChairC8 worked example

Facts. Claim: chair legs joined by a steel bar. Competitor makes and sells a chair using aluminium that performs the same job.

Actavis claim scope ringsnormalmeaningequivalentsoutside ring = free
Actavis step one is the inner area; step two may catch a variant beyond ordinary meaning.
TaskApplication
1 · ActMatch making and selling to the relevant s 60 category.
2a · ScopeOn normal interpretation, does “steel” cover aluminium, read with the inventive concept?
2b · EquivalentIf not, apply Lord Neuberger's three questions from the handout; same job supports the argument but does not replace the test.
3 · DefenceTest any defence on the facts.
4 · RemedyChoose relief fitting the patentee's commercial position.

AdviceCredible case: aluminium may be an equivalent if “steel” is not met on normal interpretation, subject to defences.

Infringement PipelineSeminar 4 tips

Four infringement taskss 60 actscopedefenceremedyrun separately for every activity
Classify before construing; do not jump from similarity straight to liability.

s 125(3) PA 77 brings Art 69 EPC + Protocol into UK law: fair protection for the patentee versus reasonable certainty for third parties. Actavis UK v Eli Lilly [2017] UKSC 48 [53]–[66]; IceScape illustrates normal interpretation.

Fairness essay. Step one protects the public's ability to read the claim; step two may stop an immaterial variant escaping. Decide whether that improves fair protection without sacrificing reasonable certainty.

Wording coversEquivalents is unnecessary.
Wording missesName the variant; run all three questions.

Exceptions ProblemC7 worked example

Facts. European patent granted seven months ago claims a “non-therapeutic” method reducing skin redness by applying plant extract and waiting two minutes.

Remaining opposition period7 months elapsed2 leftgrantArt 99 limit
Two months remain to oppose centrally at the EPO.
ProcedureArt 99 window open; Art 100 allows non-patentability under Arts 52–57.
SubstanceDo not accept the label. Ask what each step does to the body and whether reducing redness is inseparable from therapy.
FallbackAdd novelty and inventive-step grounds.
ConclusionOppose within two months; argue the exception and alternatives.

Chica / Revine SplitC8 seminar problem

Salon use. Revine applies Hairbond during colouring. Claim 2 requires bleaching and maleoli formulations applied simultaneously. Identify process use under s 60; on normal interpretation test the form of maleoli, bleaching formulation and simultaneity; if outside, consider equivalents.

Home kit. Revine supplies Hairbond Stepwise; the consumer mixes it with a colouring formulation before use. Treat supply separately. Mixing before application may satisfy simultaneity; if normal interpretation covers it, the equivalents stage is unnecessary.

ActivityActScope fact
SalonRevine performs processform + bleach + simultaneity
Home kitsupply; consumer performspre-mixing may meet simultaneity

Post-Grant RoutesC1 + C7

≤9 monthsArt 99 EPO opposition; anyone; central reach; Art 100 grounds.
Later / UKs 72 revocation on stipulated grounds.
If sueds 74 lets validity be put in issue as a defence.

Date first Calculate from mention of grant before choosing forum or remedy.

Morality Essay FrameC7 readings

Issue: should faith groups and ethicists have a formal EPO role? For: life-science patenting benefits from moral and rights perspectives. Against: examination is technical; regulation may handle morality better. Use Rennie-Smith, Pila, and Liddell & Ravenscroft; opposition is open to anyone.

Policy Drill · MedicinesC9 · TRIPS

Facts. A country without vaccine manufacturing capacity faces an epidemic; the effective vaccine is patented.

TRIPS access-to-medicines layersTRIPS minimum standardsflexibilitiesDoha Declarationlicence
Build advice upwards from the treaty baseline to the particular compulsory licence.
ParagraphWhat to do
ObjectiveLawful vaccine supply during the emergency.
FrameworkTRIPS Art 1: minimum standards, with more extensive protection permitted if consistent. Art 27(1): patent availability.
FlexibilityFollow the Doha Declaration procedure from the lectures; identify the document each step requires.
ReplyMeet the patentee's incentive rationale using the Chapter 1 bargain and the public-health objective.
AdviceGive a recommendation and identify the documentation to complete.

Essay move A survey is not enough: thesis → legal framework → strongest counterargument → reasoned conclusion.

Fast Recall Gridall chapters

InventionDUNS; technical character; Emotional Perception.
Noveltypriority; ss 2(2)/(3)/(4); one disclosure.
Anticipationnecessary infringement + enablement.
Stepprior art; technical difference/effect; obvious?
Infringements 60 → scope → defence → remedy.

24-Hour Answer Cycleassessment + strategy

Answer cycle for each selected questionchooseplanwriteverifyrulefactsanswer
For each of the three chosen questions: select, plan by issues, write, then check the actual question and authorities.

Problem: advise. Essay: take a position. Both: use claim language, separate tests, state the fallback.

https://www.asksia.ai/cheatsheet/manchester-laws70271
Forward this to your tutorial group · Shared by
AskSiav2 · 2026-10-19
24-hour online open-book examination, Semester 1 2026/27 (check the date in your exam timetable).
check the exam instructions on the LMS

Want one for YOUR exact syllabus?

Sia is your free desktop study agent. Drop your The University of Manchester LAWS70271 slides — Sia builds a sheet tailored to YOUR exam. Better than this library because it knows YOUR materials.

↓ Download Sia · Free