01 · Exam map BRIEF · COURSE.JSON
Final: comprehension and practical use across the complete topic set. Allocate revision by the published 60% weight, then practise integrated tender-purpose analysis rather than isolated labels.
02 · Master admissibility method FRONT + FAQ
One item, several uses: analyse truth, notice, credibility and state of mind on separate lines. A successful route for one use does not authorise the others.
Exam tip End every item with the court action: admit, exclude, redact, limit, direct, grant leave, conduct a voir dire, or require another proof source.
02A · Opening-question index ALL TOPICS
| Trigger | Open with |
|---|---|
| Any item | What fact, proponent, purpose and rational effect? |
| Witness | Competent for this question; then compellable by status? |
| Confidential material | Which privilege, holder, material and controlling purpose? |
| Questioning | Which examination stage and permitted function? |
| Attack on witness | Fact in issue or credibility only; which exception? |
| Silence | Pre-trial or at trial; what adverse inference? |
| Other conduct/events | Tendency or coincidence inference? |
| Prior words | Representation, maker, asserted fact and truth need? |
03 · Relevance → control CH 1 · ss 55–56
| Control | Choose it by | Exam move |
|---|---|---|
| s 135 | General discretion | Probative value substantially outweighed by listed dangers; name the danger. |
| s 136 | Proper use exists; misuse risk | Limit the use and say what the tribunal may not do. |
| s 137 | Prosecution evidence in criminal proceeding | Apply its distinct mandatory balance; identify unfair-prejudice reasoning. |
Probative value is strength for the stated purpose. Unfair prejudice is danger of improper, emotional or irrational use against an accused—not simply damage to the case.
Trap Never merge ss 135–137 into “fairness”. Select by proceeding, tendering party, proposed use, statutory verb and remedy.
04 · Competence then compulsion CH 2 · s 13
| Question | Fact checklist |
|---|---|
| Competence | Which proposed topic? Can this witness understand the question and give an answer that can be understood, with available communication support? |
| Sworn route | Separate competence for the fact from understanding the obligation to give truthful evidence; follow s 13 for unsworn evidence where applicable. |
| Compellability | Identify accused/co-accused/family/ordinary status, relationship, proceeding and party seeking the evidence. |
05 · Privilege audit CH 3
| Route | Controlling question | Frequent error |
|---|---|---|
| Self-incrimination | What precise answer creates what specified liability or penalty risk? | Treating embarrassment as enough. |
| Client legal privilege | Which client-held confidential communication/document meets the legal advice or litigation purpose? | Possession = ownership; sending an old record to counsel changes its creation purpose. |
| Protected communication | Does the distinct Victorian statutory category apply? | Importing the client-lawyer dominant-purpose test. |
Object to the smallest defensible unit. If facts omit creation purpose, authority or disclosure circumstances, give a conditional result and name the missing evidence. If protection fails, ordinary relevance, hearsay, opinion and control questions remain.
06 · Witness examination CH 4 · s 38
| Stage | Control |
|---|---|
| Chief | Elicit the calling party’s account; leading form restricted. Distinguish refreshing memory from tendering a previous representation. |
| s 38 | Identify the exact unfavourable evidence, prior inconsistency or failure to make a genuine attempt to recollect; unhelpful ≠ automatically unfavourable. |
| Cross | Test issues and credibility; put the substance of a contradictory version before later inviting rejection—Browne v Dunn. |
| Re-exam | Clarify or qualify matters raised in cross; do not rebuild chief or introduce an unrelated topic. |
07 · Credibility or character? CH 5 · Pt 3.8
| Gate | What must be shown |
|---|---|
| s 102 | Is the evidence relevant only because it affects whether the witness or maker should be believed? If yes, the credibility rule engages. |
| s 103 | For cross-examination, capacity to substantially affect credibility: nature, importance and circumstances of the inconsistency in the proceeding as a whole. |
| s 106 | Evidence from another source: prior challenge plus the specified pathway; denial does not unlock every collateral document or witness. |
| ss 104, 108 | Accused-witness leave and additional protection; re-examination matter arising or qualifying exception. |
Character: use Part 3.8 and any required leave. Do not convert moral judgment into proof of the charged act or bypass separate tendency controls. For complainants or accused witnesses, apply the specific safeguard; do not reason from confidence, emotion, delay or demeanour stereotypes.
08 · Silence: fix the time CH 6 · s 89
A later account may contain a proved express inconsistency that follows witness and credibility rules. Counsel cannot disguise prohibited silence reasoning as “common sense”, “late explanation” or conduct. The prosecution must prove its case with evidence, not fill a gap from failure to answer or testify.
09 · Tendency ≠ coincidence CH 7 · Pt 3.6
| Route | State before threshold | Application facts |
|---|---|---|
| Tendency | Other conduct/circumstances → precise tendency to act or possess state of mind → fact in issue. | Specificity, frequency, context and differences; no universal identical-incidents rule. |
| Coincidence | Number and features of events → improbability of chance → fact in issue. | Number, distinctiveness and combination of similarities; not a visual impression of pattern. |
Trap Counting incidents is not analysis. Build a feature ledger: conduct, circumstances, time, participants, shared features and differences.
10 · Hearsay purpose test CH 8 · ss 59–60
s 59: evidence of a previous representation adduced to prove an asserted fact the maker intended to assert. Ask whether the fact-finder must accept the assertion as true for the proposed use to work.
| Purpose | Truth? | Next move |
|---|---|---|
| Prove asserted event | Yes | Hearsay rule → named exception. |
| Notice/effect on listener | Not necessarily | Name relevant knowledge/conduct fact; prove why receipt matters even if false. |
11 · Exception router CH 9 · Pt 3.2
Rule Name the exception before praising trustworthiness; plausible, prompt or apparently reliable is not itself a statutory exception.
12 · Opinion bridge CH 10 · Pt 3.3
| Path | Required basis | Diagnostic |
|---|---|---|
| Lay | Personal perception | Is the inference necessary to communicate adequately what was perceived? |
| Expert · s 79 | Specialised knowledge from training, study or experience | Is the opinion wholly or substantially based on that knowledge? |
Credentials are not reasoning. A defect may affect admissibility, probative value or weight; say which and why.