0 · Exam Mapcourse.json · syllabus
| Component | Wt | Signal |
|---|---|---|
| Surveys, peer reviews & practice exam | 5% | non differentiating |
| Tutorial engagement tasks | 15% | non differentiating |
| Group discussion summaries | 20% | less differentiating |
| Final project | 30% | differentiating |
| Final exam | 30% | differentiating |
Permitted materials · verbatim“The final exam will consist of approximately 30 MCQs (likely of the 4 option per question kind), open book (students may bring in material), but no internet or AI access.” (HSH1000 syllabus, Semester 1 AY2026/27)
What it rewards: lecture comprehension, careful reading of the essential texts, and accurate identification + application of critical reading and thinking concepts, possibly in new contexts.
1 · Two-Pass ReadingC1 · map + FAQ
| Pass | Notice | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Orienting | genre, register, purpose, surprise, gap | 3 observations + ≥1 open question; never a verdict |
| Close | repetition, unexpected wording, order, naming/absence | a claim another reader can check in the same lines |
Reliability testIf the claim would survive completely different wording, it is summary, not close reading.
1.1 · Discussion RecordC1 · strategy
2 · What a Sentence DoesC2 · map + FAQ
| Kind | Claim | What settles it? |
|---|---|---|
| Description | world is this way | observation, count, document |
| Prediction | world will be this way | later outcome |
| Prescription | something ought to be done/valued | argument about worth |
| Definition | word will be used this way | useful/misleading, not true/false |
Mixed sentence? Split at the connective; test each half. A true count does not by itself support a recommendation: the missing bridge is a premise about what is worth doing.
3 · Definitions + GenreC2 · worked
Genre is a claim: it supplies expectations and changes what counts as achievement or fault. “Report” makes sparse characterisation apt; “story” can make the same absence thin. If a text straddles genres, state which reading serves which claim; do not switch labels when one becomes inconvenient.
| Call it a… | Then test… |
|---|---|
| report | accuracy, evidence, completeness |
| story | selection, character, ordering, effect |
| thought experiment | isolated variable and hidden assumption |
The Oxford English Dictionary is descriptive: it records dated usage. It can settle a dispute about established use, not decide where an essay ought to draw a boundary.
Definition decisionEstablished usage disputed? → lexical. Blurred boundary? → precising. Technical/local sense needed? → stipulate, announce it, then remain consistent.
4 · Metaphor MappingC4 · topic map
- Name the target: what is actually discussed.
- Name the source: where the borrowed vocabulary is literal.
- Give 2–3 crossings and the inference each licenses.
- Find one prominent blocked feature; explain what the metaphor cannot express.
Worked line · city wallTarget = settled society/wild. Source = masonry. Crossings: boundedness → inside/outside is maintained; cumulative work → boundary is a project; “holding back” → wild becomes an opposing force. Block: exchange crosses real boundaries. Hidden claim: the relation is adversarial by construction.
Dead metaphor = absorbed into ordinary vocabulary; its entailments work unnoticed. Revive “foundations of belief” and ask whether beliefs really rest on a few basics and collapse without them.
5 · AnachronismC6 · worked
Conceptual anachronism imports a later category, value or distinction into a world that lacked it, inventing agreement and blocking surprise.
| Test | Ask |
|---|---|
| Availability | Could the person see this option/distinction/value? |
| Evidence | Is the presupposition visible in the text? |
| Repair | Replace the later label with what the text shows. |
Allowed: later analytical vocabulary naming a visible structure, e.g. liminal. Risky: vocabulary attributing a stance, e.g. individualist, without textual support.
6 · Argument ReconstructionC7 · map + FAQ
- Ask what the passage wants accepted; write the conclusion first.
- Strip examples, restatements and rhetorical questions; number one premise per line.
- Add the assumption needed to close the gap and mark it [supplied].
- Apply charity: would the author accept this strongest reconstruction?
- Test premise truth, then support, separately.
| Failure | Proper reply |
|---|---|
| False premise; support otherwise holds | counterexample/evidence against that premise |
| True premises; conclusion not established | alternative explanation/case where P holds and C fails |
Worked reconstructionC: stop treating decency as natural; ask what produces it. P1: without rules, people take more than their share. P2: loud fairness advocates may take most. [Supplied] behaviour without constraint reveals nature better. Attack the supplied bridge, not merely add examples.
Mark supplied premises because you added them. An unmarked bridge can turn a charitable reconstruction into a position the author would reject.
7 · Words Inside ArgumentsC7 · body
If both sides cite the same evidence but sort it into different categories, diagnose semantic drift. Fix a precising definition for this discussion, then restate the remaining disagreement. A community’s convention may be arbitrary in origin yet binding in use; silently changing a shared term can mislead.
Finding an implicit conclusion: test candidate sentences by removal—without this sentence, does the rest still have a point? Indicator words help but are not required. Treat examples as evidence for a general premise, not as extra premises; delete restatements before numbering.
8 · Three Inference TypesC8 · clinic
| Type | Move | Promise / failure |
|---|---|---|
| Deductive | premises contain conclusion | cannot fail if premises hold / false premise or invalid form |
| Inductive | observed → unobserved cases | likelihood / small, biased or unrepresentative sample |
| Abductive | observation → explanatory account | best available, tentative / rivals omitted |
Abduction build1 neutral observation → 2 ≥2 rivals, including the boring one → 3 criteria stated before winner → 4 prediction/check → 5 what result would overturn the ranking.
Scope covers more of what is observed without special pleading. Economy adds less machinery. Testability is most useful: it names an observation on which rivals differ. Criteria invented after picking the winner are post-hoc justification.
9 · Xunzi as AbductionC8–9 · FAQ
Shared observation: people can be good, and goodness takes work. Mengzi: an innate capacity is cultivated. Xunzi: appetites come first; goodness is produced by deliberate effort, learning and inherited forms. Xunzi’s account explains why teachers, correction and practice are extensive and why removing them predicts conflict.
Do not flatten the claimNot “people are evil”. Nature names what comes before cultivation; goodness is relocated to achievement, not denied. Mengzi can reply that the apparatus removes obstruction rather than producing what was absent.
| Account | Effort means | Prediction |
|---|---|---|
| Mengzi | cultivate/release an innate capacity | forms protect growth from obstruction |
| Xunzi | produce a shaped disposition | without forms, appetites generate conflict |
The comparison is abductive, not a refutation: a rival returns if it explains the necessity and success of the shaping apparatus equally well.
10 · Fast Distinction MatrixC1–12 · glossary
| Do not merge | Deciding question |
|---|---|
| orienting pass / close reading | questions & reactions, or word-anchored claim? |
| description / prescription | could observation settle it? |
| lexical / precising / stipulative | record, sharpen or propose? |
| source / target domain | where is the vocabulary literal? |
| later term / anachronism | does it merely describe, or impute an unavailable stance? |
| premise truth / support | is P true, or does P reach C? |
| induction / abduction | further case, or hidden cause/mechanism? |
| primary / reliable | close to this question, or accurate? |
| past / history | everything that happened, or a shaped account? |
| contingency / randomness | could differ, or lacks explanation? |
| formation / etiquette | reshaping desire, or surface manners? |
| comparison / two summaries | is one axis of disagreement named? |
11 · Universal Apply Routineexam strategy
Fast eliminationWrong category → wrong evidence → overclaim beyond passage → treats a relation as a permanent label → ignores the stated terms → criticises an inference for promising more than its kind promises.
12 · Four Essential Textscourse overview
| Text | Fast retrieval hook |
|---|---|
| Omelas | aggregation; concentrated cost; separateness; staying/walking |
| Gilgamesh | mortality; liminality; boundary crossings; composite text |
| Xunzi | nature; deliberate effort; ritual/music; best explanation |
| A Vietcong Memoir | selection; emplotment; contingency; competing identities; sources |