0 · Exam Map course.json · brief
| Assessment | Wt | What it rewards |
|---|---|---|
| Assessment 1 — Scenario: urgent advice (online assignment) | 20% | 1,000 words; Topics 1–5; primary law |
| Assessment 2 — Problem-solving task (Turnitin assignment) | 20% | 1,000 words; ILAC report |
| Assessment 3 — Final Exam | 60% | MCQ + short answer + problems; all topics |
permitted-materials truth“The final exam is open book” (Assessments overview, AYB230 (Semester 1 2026 page; same unit assessment))
Paper or book material only; no electronic devices is the final format recorded in the course data. Use this printed sheet as an index to the rule, authority, elements and remedy.
1 · ILAC Answer Rail course overview
I: frame the legal question narrowly. L: state each element and pinpoint the section + leading authority. A: apply each element to named facts; argue the plausible counter-position. C: answer the issue and state consequence or remedy.
Exam move → Allocate time in proportion to marks. Before writing, make a margin checklist of issues; stop each ILAC when its conclusion is defensible and move on.
2 · First Classification all problems
| Who? | company · member · director/officer · outsider · creditor |
|---|---|
| Act? | debt · share issue · meeting · contract · disclosure · disposition |
| Stage? | formation · governance · financing · distress · winding up |
| Relief? | validity · liability · injunction · profits · compensation · priority |
| MCQ/short answer | state the decisive threshold, section and one-line reason |
|---|---|
| Problem | use a heading for every plausible issue, not one global ILAC |
| Remedy | match claimant and breach: company, ASIC, member, creditor or outsider |
3 · Company Personality T1 · s124 · Salomon
Separate legal entity: registration makes the company a distinct legal person with most capacities of a natural person: s124; Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd. Its property, contracts and debts are its own—even with one owner.
Limited liability: a member’s exposure is capped at the unpaid amount on shares: s516. A personal guarantee voluntarily gives up that protection for the guaranteed debt.
Apply → Start with separation. Treat lifting as exceptional; test every pleaded flag before making the owner personally liable.
4 · Type → Register → Contract T2 · s112–140
| Gate | Rule | Application cue |
|---|---|---|
| Type | s112: shares / guarantee / unlimited / no liability | Pty: ≤50 non-employee members; no public fundraising (s113) |
| Small Pty | s45A: at least 2 of 3 | revenue <$50m; assets <$25m; <100 employees |
| Register | s117 application → s119 existence → s124 powers | identify when legal person began |
| Pre-reg | s131: behalf + later registered + timely ratification | no ratification/performance → promoter liability (s131(2)) |
Promoter: owes fiduciary good faith; disclose interest, disclose profit, obtain consent. For a pre-registration promise, do not call the company bound until all s131 limbs are applied.
corporate group · s46Subsidiary if holding company controls board composition, >50% meeting votes, >50% issued share capital, or it is a subsidiary of that company’s subsidiary. Any one limb suffices.
5 · Internal Rulebook T2 · s136 · s140
Use replaceable rules, a constitution, or both. No-liability companies, ASX-listed companies and a limited-by-guarantee company omitting “Limited” must have a constitution; replaceable rules do not apply to a sole director/shareholder company.
Change: special resolution ≥75% (s136). Even if passed, it does not bind a member without consent where it forces more shares, increases capital liability, or restricts share transfer: s140(2).
6 · Members & Meetings T3 · s231 · s249
Membership: written consent + entry on register: s231. Directors manage under s198A; members cannot direct daily management: Automatic Self-Cleansing Filter Syndicate v Cunninghame.
Oppression
s232: conduct contrary to members’ interests as a whole, or oppressive, unfairly prejudicial or unfairly discriminatory. Standing: s234. Ask what a reasonable director would do: Wade v NSW Rugby League; test defeated reasonable expectations: Boyd v Feeney.
Trap → Resolve authority to call, notice/proper purpose, then the correct majority. Do not use ≥75% merely because the decision is important.
| Member issue | Rule / response |
|---|---|
| Dividend demanded | s254T–W; paid from profits at directors’ discretion |
| Excluded / fees diverted | plead oppression s232; applicant standing s234 |
| Company wrong not pursued | consider statutory derivative action |
| Relationship irretrievable | winding up may be a member remedy |
7 · Who Owes the Duties? T4 · s9
| Status | Test on the facts |
|---|---|
| Appointed | valid formal appointment |
| De facto | acts in the director role without valid appointment |
| Shadow | board accustomed to follow the person’s instructions/wishes |
| Officer | makes/participates in substantial decisions or significantly affects financial standing |
| Secretary | administration/compliance; also an officer |
Function beats label. A dominant creditor, parent company or unappointed participant may fall within s9. Then apply the same statutory duties.
Governance: directors manage under s198A; members use meeting powers. Board resolutions pass by >50%. The separation creates agency costs, which duties and monitoring constrain.
8 · Statutory Duties Map T4–6
Consequence menu
| Company | damages/compensation · account of profits · constructive trust · rescission · injunction · return of property |
|---|---|
| ASIC | civil penalty up to $1.11m · compensation · disqualification (s206C) |
| Dishonesty | criminal liability; ASIC v Adler |
Disqualification s206B: source-listed automatic grounds include qualifying convictions, undischarged bankruptcy, personal insolvency agreement or relevant foreign order.
Decision authority & removal
Board decisions ordinarily pass by >50%; a circulating written resolution is an alternative board mechanism. Members of a public company remove a director by ordinary resolution under s203D, after proper meeting notice—not by directing the board under s198A.
| Quinn | attends board, signs, held out → de facto director |
|---|---|
| Royston | board habitually follows instructions → shadow director |
| Result | both fall within s9 and owe statutory duties |
Exam move → Quote conduct showing the function. Formal appointment is only one route into s9.
9 · Loyalty: s181–183 T5 · Equiticorp
s181: good faith in the company’s best interests + proper purpose. Good faith = genuine, honest, reasonable conduct: Equiticorp. Company interests are primarily members as a whole: Greenhalgh; creditors matter when insolvent.
s182 / s183: no improper use of position/information to gain advantage or cause company detriment. A corporate opportunity taken secretly supplies both the gain and detriment. Avoid breach by full disclosure and required approval; material interest disclosure: s191; public-company related benefits: Ch 2E.
Apply → Name the power, infer its real purpose from timing and surrounding facts, run “but for”, then address disclosure/approval and profit-stripping relief.
10 · Care: s180 T6 · AWA / Daniels
Objective reasonable-person standard in that director’s position and circumstances; rises with office. Minimum: understand business, stay informed, review financials, enquire, delegate only to capable people, and do not ignore misconduct: AWA Ltd v Daniels / Daniels v Anderson.
| s180(2) BJR: all four | Fact question |
|---|---|
| good faith + proper purpose | why decide? |
| no material personal interest | conflict? |
| reasonably informed | what was reviewed? |
| rational best-interests belief | reasoned basis? |
Safe harbour for s180 only—not s181–183 or s588G.
Conflict approval & remedy
| s191 | disclose nature and extent of material personal interest to other directors |
|---|---|
| s194 / s195 | after disclosure, proprietary/public voting treatment differs |
| Ch 2E | public-company financial benefit to related party generally needs member approval unless exception |
| No loss? | account of profits and constructive trust target the director’s gain |
Raj pattern: undisclosed corporate opportunity + personal profit → fiduciary conflict and s182/s183; strip the gain.
11 · Insolvent Trading T6 · s588G/H
Insolvent: cannot pay debts as they fall due. ASIC v Plymin indicators: dishonoured cheques, COD demands, unpaid PAYG/super, missing timely audited accounts, bank demands, unsatisfied statutory demand. Failure to meet a s459E demand within 21 days triggers s459C presumption.
s588H defencesreasonable expectation of solvency · reasonable reliance on competent responsible information · absence from management for illness/other good reason · all reasonable steps to prevent debt.
s588GAB: creditor-defeating disposition for less than value while insolvent or entering external administration within 12 months, with required knowledge/reasonableness.
12 · Remaining Issue Classifiers T7–11
| Facts point to | Open with |
|---|---|
| climate claim / data | s1041H/E; s12DA; Privacy Act >$3m; APPs; s26WK–WL |
| crime/tort/contract | directing mind; vicarious; s127 execution; s129 assumptions |
| capital / security | equity v debt; s254A/B; PPSA perfection and priority |
| fundraising statement | s706 need; s708 exemption; s728 omission |
| distress / claims | receiver v VA/DOCA v winding up; s555/s556 order |
Privacy gate: turnover >$3m (plus listed smaller handlers). Eligible breach likely to cause serious harm → notify OAIC + affected people as soon as practicable: s26WK–WL. APP6 use/disclosure; APP7 direct marketing.
Greenwashing: misleading conduct under s1041H/E and s12DA ASIC Act; analyse as truthful disclosure plus foreseeable risk management, without inventing a direct Australian climate-duty case.
Carry to Side 2 → The later-topic diagrams convert each classifier into a short, applied answer.