1 · Exam map course.json · brief
| Assessment | Weight / format |
|---|---|
| Research Knowledge Quiz | 20% · online; generative AI prohibited |
| Equitable Principles and Remedies Quiz | 30% · online doctrinal quiz; generative AI prohibited |
| Final Examination | 50% · two-hour online ProctorU exam; generative AI prohibited |
Permitted materials: not confirmed for this offering in the course materials we hold — check the exam instructions on the LMS. BRIEF.md; course data directs verification
Separate the thresholdsEligibility: submit ≥9 of 12 tutorial writing tasks.
Final minimum: ≥20 marks out of 50.
Neither alone proves the overall subject pass.
2 · Master answer route C1 · course overview
| Move | What earns space |
|---|---|
| I | Exact equitable relationship, property interest or wrong. |
| R | Element-by-element rule; authority belongs at the disputed step. |
| A | Allocate each fact; expose the counter-reading and any defence. |
| C | Conditional result + remedy purpose, discretion, bars and property. |
Issue router
| Question turns on… | Start here; finish here |
|---|---|
| Promise / assumption | Estoppel: inducement → reliance/detriment → departure → minimum equity. |
| Disadvantage / influence | Separate unconscionable dealing from actual or presumed influence and their consequences. |
| Loyalty / outsider | Scope fiduciary undertaking; then conflict/profit, consent, or receipt/assistance. |
| Property held / transferred | Classify interest and assignment; or test express, resulting or constructive trust. |
| Response requested | Establish liability first; then discretion, bars, tracing and available property. |
3 · Equity, maxims, assignment C2–C3
Maxim controlA maxim guides equitable reasoning but is not a self-executing cause of action. State the doctrine and authority first; use the maxim only to explain direction or discretion.
Assignment classifier
| Question | Analysis |
|---|---|
| What is held? | Classify legal and equitable interests before selecting the route. |
| What was done? | List the assignment acts actually completed; do not treat intention as completion. |
| Legal route failed? | Failure at law does not settle equitable effect. Test whether completed acts suffice in equity. |
| Then? | Explain priority consequences produced by that classification. |
Boundary: a failed legal assignment may or may not be effective in equity depending on completed acts. The answer therefore needs a route, completed-act analysis and priority consequence—not a bare “failed/valid”.
4 · Evidence control C1–C3 worked method
| Scenario fact | Element | Inference | Counter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quote / act / transfer | One rule only | Verb-led link | Fact that changes it |
Separate published rule, scenario fact, student inference and decision. A familiar label is not evidence. Test the scale of each claim and narrow the conclusion when the facts do not establish every element.
| Control question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| What exact claim does this fact support? | Prevents a definition floating above the scenario. |
5 · Unconscionability v influence C4
| Route | Required analytical jobs | Trap |
|---|---|---|
| Unconscionable dealing | Special disadvantage → other party's knowledge → exploitation → remedial consequence. | Unfairness alone is insufficient. |
| Undue influence | Identify actual or presumed influence; keep its elements and remedial consequence distinct. | Do not collapse influence into disadvantage. |
Recitable limitMoral unfairness alone does not establish doctrinal unconscionability.
6 · Equitable estoppel C5 topic map · FAQ
Application: state the induced assumption precisely; link conduct to reliance; identify detriment; explain why departure would be unconscionable; then justify the minimum equity. Ask whether a narrower response cures the departure before claiming expectation relief.
| Missing link | Consequence |
|---|---|
| No induced assumption | No foundation for reliance analysis. |
| No reliance / detriment | Do not jump to unconscionability. |
| Relief unexplained | Conclusion exceeds the equity shown. |
Doctrinal separation
7 · Fiduciary obligations C6
| Step | Question |
|---|---|
| 1 Relationship | What precise undertaking makes loyalty relevant? |
| 2 Scope | Is the alleged conduct inside that undertaking? |
| 3 Rule | Conflict? Profit? Keep the two analytical routes visible. |
| 4 Consent | Was there informed consent? If so, how does it change liability? |
| 5 Response | Match remedy to the established breach and its purpose. |
BoundaryFiduciary duties are duties of loyalty, not a general duty to act reasonably.
8 · Third-party liability C7 glossary · FAQ
| Knowing receipt | Knowing assistance |
|---|---|
| Receipt of trust property; knowledge makes retention of the benefit unconscionable. | Dishonest assistance to trustee/fiduciary in a dishonest and fraudulent design. |
| Focus: property received, benefit retained, third party's knowledge. | Focus: assistance given, dishonest design, third party's conduct and knowledge. |
Relationship-to-response audit
| Actor / route | Question to prove | Boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Fiduciary | What undertaking and scope? Conflict or unauthorised profit? Informed consent? | Loyalty, not general reasonableness. |
| Recipient | What trust property and benefit were received and retained with what knowledge? | Do not substitute assistance facts. |
| Assistant | What help was given to what dishonest and fraudulent design, with what knowledge? | Do not substitute receipt facts. |
9 · Express trusts C8
| Certainty | Fact / defect | Conclusion job |
|---|---|---|
| Intention | Precatory language. | Does language establish a trust intention? |
| Subject matter | Incomplete property identification. | Is trust property sufficiently certain? |
| Objects | Indeterminate beneficiary class. | Are objects or beneficiaries sufficiently certain? |
Do not let one label conceal three failures. Test intention, property and objects in turn, and identify the consequence of the specific uncertainty found.
10 · Trustee decision C9
| Authority | Proper exercise | Enforcement |
|---|---|---|
| Locate the duty or power. | Test actual purpose and process; existence alone is insufficient. | Identify beneficiary right, failed assumption and fitting response. |
ReciteA power's existence does not prove it was exercised for a proper purpose.
Trust problem checklist
| Stage | Question | Failure path |
|---|---|---|
| Creation | Intention, subject matter and objects each sufficiently certain? | Name the exact uncertainty and its consequence. |
| Administration | What is the source of the duty/power; was purpose and process proper? | Authority alone does not validate exercise. |
| Beneficiary | What right supports enforcement? | Connect the right to a fitting remedy. |
11 · Resulting / constructive trusts C10–C11
| Route | Question that decides it |
|---|---|
| Automatic resulting trust | Why does beneficial ownership return after the relevant disposition fails? |
| Presumed resulting trust | What fact supports the evidential presumption that ownership remains? |
| Restricted-purpose transfer | What limited purpose controls the transfer and its failure? |
| Institutional constructive trust | What recognised event generates the proprietary consequence? |
| Remedial constructive trust | Does Australian authority support it in this third-party or relationship context? |
Two boundariesLabels follow facts and authority. Not every fairness concern becomes a remedial constructive trust.
12 · Remedies + tracing C12
| Response | Purpose / control question |
|---|---|
| Injunction / specific performance | What established liability and discretionary conditions justify prospective or performance relief? |
| Rescission | Does unwinding fit the wrong, subject to bars? |
| Account of profits | Is a gain-based response fitted to the established wrong? |
| Compensation | Is a personal compensatory response justified? |
| Tracing | Can value be identified through substitution or mixture? Tracing identifies value; it is not an independent wrong. |
Selection sentenceBecause ___ establishes ___, the purpose of ___ fits; however, discretion, ___ and the property still available may narrow it.