The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

ECON2113 Chap.11 Indifference Curves, Price and Income Effects

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
8 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 11 of 11 · ECON2113

Indifference Curves, Price and Income Effects

Drawing what a consumer likes

The second consumer choice lecture replaces utility numbers with a picture. An indifference curve joins the baskets a consumer likes equally, and a family of them makes a preference map. Once more is assumed to be better, the curves must slope downward, cannot cross, and rank higher the further they sit from the origin.

Perfect substitutes give straight lines and perfect complements give L-shapes, and the lecture uses phones of two colours and pairs of shoes to show each.

The best affordable basket on a diagram

The best basket uses up the whole budget and reaches the highest indifference curve available. For perfect complements it sits at a corner, and changing one price and recording the new corner traces a demand curve.

The lecture runs that exercise for left shoes at four different prices.

Splitting a price change into two effects

A price change moves the consumer to a new basket, the price effect. The lecture divides it into a substitution effect, the move along the original indifference curve, and an income effect, the move caused by the change in purchasing power, and applies the split to a tax on sugary drinks.

It closes with behavioural economics, asking whether real consumers optimize the way the model assumes.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Indifference curves and the preference map

  • 02

    Why more is better makes curves slope down

  • 03

    Why indifference curves cannot cross

  • 04

    Perfect substitutes and perfect complements

  • 05

    The best affordable basket

  • 06

    From price changes to a demand curve

  • 07

    Substitution effect and income effect

  • 08

    Behavioural economics and rational choice

Worked example · free

Find the best basket when goods are perfect complements

Q [6 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. A buyer always has exactly one croissant with each coffee. Income is $60, croissants cost $6 and coffee costs $4. Find the best affordable basket, then find it again after coffee rises to $6, and say how the change in coffee bought divides between the substitution and income effects. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation and are not the University marking scheme.
With perfect complements the best basket is a corner.With perfect complements the best basket is a corner. A buyer who has one croissant with each coffee spends $60, with croissants at $6. At $4 a coffee, budget line B1 reaches the corner at 6 of each; at $6 a coffee, B2 reaches the corner at 5 of each. The curve cornered at 9 of each lies beyond both lines.CoffeesCroissantsB1B2best at $4best at $6out of reach56101510
With perfect complements the best basket is a corner. A buyer who has one croissant with each coffee spends $60, with croissants at $6. At $4 a coffee, budget line B1 reaches the corner at 6 of each; at $6 a coffee, B2 reaches the corner at 5 of each. The curve cornered at 9 of each lies beyond both lines.
  • 2Price one set of a coffee and a croissant and find the best basket.
  • 2Repeat at the new coffee price.
  • 2Split the change into substitution and income effects.
A set costs $10, so the buyer reaches the corner at 6 coffees and 6 croissants, spending exactly $60. At $6 a coffee a set costs $12 and the best basket falls to 5 of each. With perfect complements the indifference curves are L-shaped, so staying on the original curve at the new prices still means buying the goods one for one: the substitution effect is zero and the whole fall of one coffee is income effect.
Sia tip — For perfect complements, price a complete set before doing anything else; the number of affordable sets is the whole answer, and the substitution effect is always zero.
Glossary

Key terms

Preference Map
The whole family of a consumer's indifference curves, with higher curves showing higher satisfaction.
Perfect Substitutes
Goods the consumer will swap one for one at a fixed rate, giving straight-line indifference curves.
Perfect Complements
Goods the consumer only values in fixed proportions, giving L-shaped indifference curves.
Price Effect
The total change in the quantity of a good bought when its price changes.
Substitution Effect
The part of a price effect that would occur if the consumer stayed on the original indifference curve.
Income Effect
The part of a price effect caused by the change in the consumer's purchasing power.
FAQ

Indifference Curves, Price and Income Effects FAQ

Why must indifference curves slope downward?

Because of the assumption that more is better. If a basket has less of one good, the consumer can only be equally satisfied if it has more of the other, so moving along a curve trades one good for the other. An upward-sloping curve would put a basket with more of both goods on the same level of satisfaction, which more is better rules out.

Where is the best affordable basket on an indifference curve diagram?

On the budget line, so that all income is spent, and on the highest indifference curve the budget line reaches. Any basket on a higher curve is unaffordable, and any affordable basket on a lower curve leaves satisfaction unclaimed. For ordinary goods the line just touches the best curve; for perfect complements the best basket is at the corner of an L.

Do the substitution and income effects always work in the same direction?

For a normal good they do: a price rise makes the good relatively dearer and also makes the consumer poorer, and both lower the quantity bought. The lecture's sugary drink tax case shows this. Their sizes vary, though, from all substitution effect for perfect substitutes to all income effect for perfect complements.

Study strategy

Exam move

Sketch the three preference shapes, ordinary, perfect substitutes and perfect complements, each with one budget line, and mark the best basket on each. Then raise one price on each sketch and write which effect does the work. Twenty minutes of this covers most of what the topic can ask.

Working through Indifference Curves, Price and Income Effects in ECON2113? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON2113 Indifference Curves, Price and Income Effects question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON2113 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 13 of your subjects at The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your ECON2113 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works