The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

ECON2113 Chap.1 Scarcity, Opportunity Cost and Optimization

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
8 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 1 of 11 · ECON2113

Scarcity, Opportunity Cost and Optimization

Why every question in the course starts from a constraint

The opening lectures treat economics as the study of choice when resources are scarce, and of what those choices mean for everyone else. Scarcity forces a choice, the choice responds to incentives, and an incentive can be a reward or a penalty.

Consumers, firms and governments are all agents in this sense, which is why the same reasoning later explains a shopper, a factory and a trade ministry.

Positive claims, normative claims and the five-part method

A positive claim describes how the economy works and can be tested; a normative claim recommends what ought to happen.

The course then sets out a method in five parts: simplify with assumptions, isolate one variable with ceteris paribus, treat a choice as a trade-off, think at the margin, and expect people to respond to incentives.

London's daily charge for driving into the city centre is the lecture's running illustration of all five.

Opportunity cost and two routes to the best option

Opportunity cost is the best alternative given up, and it applies to time and owned assets as much as to cash.

With costs and benefits in common units, the best feasible option can be found either by comparing totals or by comparing the change from one option to the next. The second lecture shows that the two routes always reach the same answer, and the problem sets ask for both. The chapter closes with equilibrium, the free rider problem and the gap between self-interest and the social interest.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Scarcity, choice and incentives

  • 02

    Positive and normative statements

  • 03

    The five elements of the economic way of thinking

  • 04

    Opportunity cost of time and of owned assets

  • 05

    Optimization by comparing totals

  • 06

    Optimization by marginal analysis

  • 07

    Equilibrium and the free rider problem

  • 08

    Self-interest against the social interest

Worked example · free

Pick the cheapest study desk once time has a price

Q [6 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Four study desks differ only in monthly fee and commuting time: Desk A costs HK$2,600 with 4 hours of travel a month, Desk B HK$2,250 with 8 hours, Desk C HK$1,980 with 12 hours and Desk D HK$1,790 with 16 hours. Your time is worth HK$70 an hour. Find the best desk by total cost and confirm it with marginal analysis. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation and are not the University marking scheme.
Four study desks, one cheapest choice.Four study desks, one cheapest choice. Each point is the desk fee plus commuting hours valued at HK$70 an hour; the labels between points are the change in total cost from one desk to the next. The vertical axis starts at HK$2,750 so the differences can be seen. Desk B is cheapest because it is where that change switches from negative to positive.2,7502,8502,950Desk ADesk BDesk CDesk D−70+10+90Total cost per month (HK$)
Four study desks, one cheapest choice. Each point is the desk fee plus commuting hours valued at HK$70 an hour; the labels between points are the change in total cost from one desk to the next. The vertical axis starts at HK$2,750 so the differences can be seen. Desk B is cheapest because it is where that change switches from negative to positive.
  • 2Value each desk's travel time at HK$70 an hour and add the fee.
  • 1Pick the lowest total.
  • 2Compute the change in total cost for each move to a farther desk.
  • 1Stop at the last move that lowers the total.
Travel time costs HK$280, HK$560, HK$840 and HK$1,120, so the totals are HK$2,880 for A, HK$2,810 for B, HK$2,820 for C and HK$2,910 for D. Desk B is cheapest. At the margin, moving from A to B saves HK$350 of fee for HK$280 of time, a net saving of HK$70; moving from B to C saves HK$270 of fee but costs HK$280 of time, a net loss of HK$10; moving from C to D loses a further HK$90. Desk B is the option you gain by reaching and lose by leaving.
Sia tip — Write the marginal result with its sign next to each move. The best option sits exactly where the sign changes from a saving to a loss, so a misplaced minus sign shows up immediately.
Glossary

Key terms

Scarcity
The inability to satisfy all wants with the resources available, which forces every economic agent to choose.
Incentive
Anything that makes one choice more rewarding or more costly than another, such as a price, a fine or a bonus, and so steers what people decide.
Positive Statement
A claim about how the economy works that answers what is and can be checked against evidence.
Normative Statement
A claim that recommends a policy or outcome, answering what ought to be rather than what is.
Free Rider
Someone who enjoys the benefit of a shared effort without contributing to its cost.
Economic Agent
Any individual or group that makes choices, such as a consumer, a firm or a government.
FAQ

Scarcity, Opportunity Cost and Optimization FAQ

Is the opportunity cost of a choice the sum of every alternative I gave up?

No. It is the value of the single best alternative you gave up. A graduate turning down offers of HK$23,000 and HK$15,000 to accept a HK$35,000 job forgoes HK$23,000, not HK$38,000. Adding all the alternatives counts options you could never have taken at the same time, which is why that answer appears as a distractor in the course's discussion questions.

Do the total value method and marginal analysis ever disagree?

They should not. The lecture states that optimization by total value and by marginal analysis give identical answers, because each marginal comparison is just the difference between two totals. If your two methods disagree, a subtraction has gone the wrong way, usually by treating a fee saving as a cost or by comparing non-adjacent options.

How do I tell a positive statement from a normative one quickly?

Ask whether evidence alone could settle the claim. If it could, even if the claim turns out false, it is positive. If it needs a view about what society should want, it is normative. Words such as should and ought are clues, but a sentence like keeping inflation at zero is normative without either word.

Study strategy

Exam move

Take any decision you made this week, list the realistic options in order, put money values on time and fees, and run both techniques. Then change the value of your time and see which option wins. Being able to say why the answer moved is exactly the marginal reasoning the later chapters assume.

Working through Scarcity, Opportunity Cost and Optimization in ECON2113? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON2113 Scarcity, Opportunity Cost and Optimization question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON2113 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 13 of your subjects at The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your ECON2113 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works