The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

ECON2113 Chap.6 Taxes, Tax Incidence and Subsidies

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
9 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 6 of 11 · ECON2113

Taxes, Tax Incidence and Subsidies

Two rates and three kinds of tax system

The chapter opens with the arithmetic of income tax. The average rate divides total tax by total income; the marginal rate is the rate on the last dollar. A progressive system raises both as income rises, a proportional one charges everyone the same share, and a regressive one takes a falling share.

The lecture classifies Hong Kong's own taxes this way, from the banded salaries tax and the two-tier profits tax to the flat property tax and the capped MPF contribution.

Who really bears a tax

Tax incidence asks how the burden of a per-unit tax is shared between buyers and sellers.

The tax opens a wedge between the price paid and the price received, quantity falls, and total surplus becomes consumer surplus plus producer surplus plus tax revenue, with a deadweight loss for the trades that no longer happen.

The lecture shows that the result is identical whether the law charges the tax to buyers or to sellers, and that elasticity decides the split.

Subsidies, luxury taxes and food taxes

A subsidy runs the same machinery in reverse and is subtracted when total surplus is counted.

Two policy cases test the elasticity rule: a luxury tax whose burden landed on producers because buyers could walk away, and a proposed food tax whose burden would land on consumers because they cannot.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Average and marginal tax rates

  • 02

    Progressive, proportional and regressive taxes

  • 03

    Hong Kong taxes classified

  • 04

    Income inequality and the Gini coefficient

  • 05

    The tax wedge and tax incidence

  • 06

    Surplus, revenue and deadweight loss under a tax

  • 07

    Subsidies in the welfare accounts

  • 08

    Why the less elastic side pays more

  • 09

    Marriage penalties and marriage subsidies

Worked example · free

Split a per-unit tax between buyers and sellers

Q [8 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Demand is P = 60 − Q and supply is P = 15 + 0.5Q. The government levies a tax of $12 per unit on sellers. Find the new quantity, the price buyers pay, the price sellers keep, each side's share of the tax, the revenue and the deadweight loss. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation and are not the University marking scheme.
A $12 tax on sellers splits $8 to buyers and $4 to sellers.A $12 tax on sellers splits $8 to buyers and $4 to sellers. Demand is P = 60 − Q and supply P = 15 + 0.5Q, clearing at 30 units and $30. The tax lifts supply by $12, quantity falls to 22, buyers pay $38 and sellers keep $26. The shaded rectangle is $264 of revenue and the red triangle a $48 deadweight loss.QuantityPrice ($)DSS + taxrevenue2230263038
A $12 tax on sellers splits $8 to buyers and $4 to sellers. Demand is P = 60 − Q and supply P = 15 + 0.5Q, clearing at 30 units and $30. The tax lifts supply by $12, quantity falls to 22, buyers pay $38 and sellers keep $26. The shaded rectangle is $264 of revenue and the red triangle a $48 deadweight loss.
  • 1Find the equilibrium without the tax.
  • 2Add the tax to supply and solve for the new quantity.
  • 2Find the buyer price, the seller price and each side's burden.
  • 2Compute the revenue and the deadweight loss.
  • 1Name the less elastic side.
Without the tax, 60 − Q = 15 + 0.5Q gives Q = 30 and P = 30. With the tax, supply becomes P = 27 + 0.5Q, and 60 − Q = 27 + 0.5Q gives Q = 22. Buyers pay $38 and sellers keep $26, so buyers bear $8 of the $12 and sellers $4. Revenue is 12 × 22 = $264 and the deadweight loss is 0.5 × 8 × 12 = $48. Demand is the steeper, less elastic side here, so buyers carry two thirds of the tax.
Sia tip — Measure each side's burden from the old equilibrium price, not from each other: buyer burden is new buyer price minus old price, seller burden is old price minus new seller price, and the two must add up to the tax.
Glossary

Key terms

Average Tax Rate
The share of income paid in tax, found by dividing the tax bill by income.
Marginal Tax Rate
The rate applied to one more dollar of income, which is the rate of the band the last dollar falls in.
Progressive Tax
A tax system in which average and marginal rates are higher for households with higher incomes.
Regressive Tax
A tax system in which the share of income paid falls as income rises, as with a contribution capped at a fixed amount.
Gini Coefficient
A measure of how unevenly income is distributed across a population, where a higher value means more inequality.
Subsidy
A payment by government to producers or consumers per unit, which raises output above the efficient level and is subtracted when total surplus is counted.
FAQ

Taxes, Tax Incidence and Subsidies FAQ

Does it matter whether a tax is charged to buyers or to sellers?

Not for the outcome. The lecture works the same market both ways and gets the same quantity, the same price paid and received, the same split of the burden and the same deadweight loss. Charging buyers shifts the demand curve down by the tax; charging sellers shifts supply up by it. The split depends only on the elasticities of demand and supply.

Why is the MPF contribution regressive when the rate is five per cent?

Because the contribution is capped at HK$1,500 a month. Up to the cap, workers pay five per cent of income, but anyone earning more pays the same fixed amount, which is a smaller share of a larger income. At HK$60,000 a month the share is 2.5 per cent and at HK$120,000 it is 1.25 per cent, so the share of income falls as income rises.

Is tax revenue part of the deadweight loss?

No. Revenue is a transfer from buyers and sellers to the government and is counted inside total surplus, because the government spends it. The deadweight loss is only the surplus from trades that no longer take place, the triangle between the demand and supply curves over the lost quantity.

Who pays a tax when demand is perfectly inelastic?

Buyers pay all of it. If quantity demanded does not respond to price at all, sellers can pass the whole tax on: the price buyers pay rises by the full amount of the tax, the price sellers keep is unchanged and the quantity traded does not fall. Because no trades are lost, there is no deadweight loss, which is the opposite extreme to a seat tax on a fixed number of concert seats.

Study strategy

Exam move

For any tax question, write the old price, the buyer price and the seller price in a column before drawing anything. The two differences from the old price are the burdens, they must sum to the tax, and the larger one tells you which side is less elastic. That ten-second check catches most errors in this topic.

Working through Taxes, Tax Incidence and Subsidies in ECON2113? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON2113 Taxes, Tax Incidence and Subsidies question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON2113 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 13 of your subjects at The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your ECON2113 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works