13339 Chap.1 Defining Mental Health and Mental Disorder
Defining Mental Health and Mental Disorder
Why definitions come first
The module opens by asking what illness means in medicine and why each of four common definitions fails on its own.
The answer explains why the manuals prefer the word disorder, which sits between biological facts and social values.
Two manual definitions
ICD-10 and DSM-5 both define mental disorder through symptoms, distress and dysfunction, and DSM-5 explicitly excludes expectable reactions to common stressors.
Health as more than absence
Mental health is treated as a resource, linked to disorder on a continuum that is not linear, and set against social suffering rooted in inequality.
Using the definitions in your writing
Both assessments reward precise vocabulary.
The blog must say whether cannabis affects mental illness or wider mental health, and the essay must justify calling moderate to severe depression a disorder at all. Wakefield's two conditions give a compact test for each claim: is a mechanism failing, and is the result harmful by the standards of the person's society?
What this chapter covers
- 01
Four ways of defining illness
- 02
Szasz and the pathology argument
- 03
Wakefield's harmful dysfunction
- 04
ICD-10 and DSM-5 definitions
- 05
Impairment, disability and handicap
- 06
Wellbeing, quality of life and social suffering
Worked example · free
Test mania against the suffering definition of illness
- 2Name the presence-of-suffering definition: illness is identified by the suffering that leads people to seek help.
- 2Apply it: the person reports no suffering, so on this definition alone the episode would not count as illness.
- 1Note the teaching's point that mania is usually seen as illness by everyone except the person experiencing it.
- 1Conclude that suffering alone cannot define illness, which is one reason the manuals add dysfunction and impairment.
Key terms
- Psychosocial Disability
- Psychosocial Disability is disability arising when impairments linked to mental disorder meet social barriers to full participation.
- Social Suffering
- Social Suffering is distress whose subjective side is rooted in social situations and shaped by culture.
- Handicap
- Handicap is the social disadvantage that follows when a disability limits a person's roles, such as work.
- Impairment
- Impairment is the underlying pathological defect from which disability and handicap may follow.
Defining Mental Health and Mental Disorder FAQ
Why does psychiatry use the word disorder instead of disease?
Diagnosis in medicine usually implies a known underlying cause, but for most psychiatric conditions the cause is unknown and no clear disease categories exist. The more general term disorder covers clinically recognisable patterns of symptoms and dysfunction without claiming a specific pathology, and Wakefield places it on the boundary between biological fact and social value.
What did Thomas Szasz argue about mental illness?
In his 1960 book The Myth of Mental Illness, Szasz held that illness can only be defined by physical pathology. Because most mental disorders have no demonstrable pathology, unlike tuberculosis or coronary artery disease, he concluded they are not illnesses and that most mental disturbance therefore lay outside the proper business of doctors.
Can someone have a mental disorder and good mental health at once?
Yes. The teaching describes mental health and mental disorder as linked on a continuum, with gains in population mental health predicting fewer disorders, but the relationship is not linear. A person can experience symptoms, distress and disability while still being satisfied with life and achieving much of their potential.
What is the difference between wellbeing and quality of life?
In the Lancet Commission wording used in week 1, wellbeing is a person's subjective evaluation of how satisfied they are with life, sometimes widened to include their social and personal circumstances. Quality of life is narrower and comparative: a person's view of their position in life measured against their own goals, expectations, standards and concerns, within their culture and values.
Assessment move
Write your own one-sentence definitions of wellbeing, quality of life, happiness, illness, mental disorder, psychosocial disability and recovery before the first seminar, as the week asks, then compare them with the Lancet Commission definitions in the teaching. Test each definition of illness against two awkward cases, mania and recent bereavement, and keep a note of which ones fail.
These notes become a ready opening paragraph for any essay that needs to define its terms. Add one line to each note saying how the term would change if you adopted the Power Threat Meaning view from week 4, because the module returns to these definitions when it questions the medical model.
Working through Defining Mental Health and Mental Disorder in 13339? Sia is AskSia’s AI Psychology tutor — ask any 13339 Defining Mental Health and Mental Disorder question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 13339 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.