15889 Chap.2 Fast and Slow Thinking, Bias and Defensive Practice
Fast and Slow Thinking, Bias and Defensive Practice
Two systems of thinking
The lecture cites Croskerry on dual process theory: fast, unconscious thinking that is usually effective, and slow, analytical thinking that is resource intensive. The Jones chapter adds the biases that distort both, from priming to stickiness.
From bias to reflection
The chapter shows how to audit your own case for named errors and how to write them as critical reflection.
It ends with the 2022 paper on defensive medicine, which links over-investigation to uncertainty and offers safety netting and watchful waiting instead.
Using it in your essay
Name one or two biases that genuinely shaped your case, quote the moment each one operated and say what it caused you to miss.
Use the error audit names, such as premature closure, so that your reflection connects your case to the reasoning literature.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Type 1 and Type 2 thinking
- 02
What you see is all there is
- 03
Priming, confirmation and memory bias
- 04
Representativeness and stickiness
- 05
Premature anchoring and premature closure
- 06
Outcome bias in follow-up notes
- 07
Defensive medicine and its drivers
- 08
Three principles for requesting investigations
Worked example · free
Spot the bias in a physiotherapist's progress note
- 2Name the bias: crediting the treatment for improvement that was already under way is outcome bias.
- 1Explain the evidence needed: the trajectory before treatment, so that any change can be compared with it.
- 1Rewrite: record the pre-treatment trend and state that the improvement is consistent with natural recovery or with the taping.
Key terms
- Dual Process Theory
- Dual Process Theory is the account of reasoning as fast intuitive thinking checked by slower analytical thinking.
- Confirmation Bias
- Confirmation Bias is the tendency to collect only the information that supports an existing hypothesis.
- Premature Closure
- Premature Closure is the error of stopping the search for alternatives once a first explanation seems to fit.
- Defensive Medicine
- Defensive Medicine is over-cautious management that produces excess investigation and intervention without adding value for the patient.
- Outcome Bias
- Outcome Bias is crediting a treatment for a change that the patient's existing trajectory would have produced anyway.
Fast and Slow Thinking, Bias and Defensive Practice FAQ
What is the difference between Type 1 and Type 2 thinking?
Type 1 thinking is unconscious, fast, autonomous and usually effective. Type 2 thinking is conscious, analytical, slow and resource intensive, and logically sound. The lecture cites Croskerry for this distinction. In practice Type 2 is recruited when something seems unclear or contradictory, which is why a case that feels easy can slip through unchecked.
How do I write about my own bias without sounding vague?
Name the specific bias, quote the moment in your assessment where it operated, and state what it caused you to miss. For example, say that an imaging report primed a lateral ligament hypothesis and that you therefore never screened the syndesmosis. Then say what you would do differently and which finding would have changed your mind.
Why does the reading list include a paper on defensive medicine?
Because over-investigation is a reasoning problem as much as a practice one. The 2022 paper argues that uncertainty drives clinicians to order tests that add little value, and offers safety netting, watchful waiting, debriefing and peer support instead. An assessment essay can use it when reflecting on a scan you ordered or wanted.
What is outcome bias?
Outcome bias is crediting a treatment for a change that would have happened anyway. The reasoning development reading gives the example of a patient already improving by about ten percent a week who improves by the same amount after treatment while the clinician credits the treatment. Knowing the earlier trajectory is the only protection against it.
What is premature closure?
Premature closure is stopping the search for alternatives once a first explanation seems to fit. The reasoning development reading lists it among the diagnostic errors in an error audit, alongside gravitating to a readily available heuristic and premature anchoring. In an essay it often explains why a test that would have refuted the favourite was never performed.
Assessment move
Print the list of named biases and keep it beside your case notes. For each stage of your assessment, ask which bias was most likely to act there and whether there is a trace of it in what you wrote. Choose the one or two that genuinely shaped your case and draft a short paragraph on each, naming the bias, the evidence and the consequence. Discard the rest; depth on a few is what the brief asks for.
Keep a short record of any investigation you requested or wished for, and test it against the three principles from the defensive medicine paper.
Working through Fast and Slow Thinking, Bias and Defensive Practice in 15889? Sia is AskSia’s AI Health and Medicine tutor — ask any 15889 Fast and Slow Thinking, Bias and Defensive Practice question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 15889 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.