29194 Chap.11 Externalities, Public Goods and Common Resources
Externalities, Public Goods and Common Resources
When prices miss a consequence
An externality drives a wedge between private and social cost or benefit, so a competitive market over- or under-produces and loses a triangle of surplus.
A Pigovian tax equal to the external cost restores efficiency, and a cap can reach the same quantity.
Public goods and commons
Nobody can be shut out of a public good and one person's use leaves no less for others, so people free ride and too little is supplied; marginal benefits are summed vertically.
Common resources are rival but not excludable and tend to be overused.
Reading a market failure question
Identify who imposes the cost or benefit, who bears it and which curve, cost or benefit, carries the wedge. Then find the market and efficient quantities and shade the triangle between them. Only after that should you choose a remedy and say why it fits the case.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Marginal social cost and benefit
- 02
Negative and positive externalities
- 03
The efficient level of pollution
- 04
Pigovian taxes and caps
- 05
The Coase theorem
- 06
Public goods and free riding
- 07
The tragedy of the commons
Worked example · free
Correct the external cost of a ferry service
- 1Market: 30 - Q = 6 + Q gives Q = 12 at a price of 18.
- 1Marginal social cost is 10 + Q.
- 1Efficient: 30 - Q = 10 + Q gives Q = 10 at a price of 20.
- 1Deadweight loss = 1/2 x (12 - 10) x 4 = 4 pounds a day.
- 1A Pigovian tax of 4 pounds per crossing lifts private cost onto social cost and gives Q = 10.
Key terms
- Externality
- Externality is a cost or benefit that falls on someone not directly involved in a transaction.
- Pigovian Tax
- Pigovian Tax is a charge per unit equal to the damage one more unit does to third parties.
- Public Good
- Public Good is a good that is both non-rival and non-excludable.
- Free Rider
- Free Rider is someone who enjoys a good while leaving others to pay for it.
- Coase Theorem
- Coase Theorem states that with low transaction costs private bargaining reaches the efficient outcome whoever holds the right.
- Common Resource
- Common Resource is a good that is rival in use but from which nobody can be excluded.
Externalities, Public Goods and Common Resources FAQ
Why would cutting pollution to zero be inefficient?
Abating the last units of pollution costs more than the damage they cause. Efficiency is where the marginal damage of pollution equals the marginal cost of abating it, which is usually at a positive level of emissions.
When is a cap better than a tax?
When the regulator is unsure of abatement costs, compare the slopes. If damage rises steeply past some level, fixing the quantity with a cap avoids the costly error; if abatement cost is steep, fixing the price with a tax is the cheaper mistake.
Why are public goods summed vertically?
Everyone consumes the same quantity of a public good, so the value of one more unit is the sum of everyone's marginal benefit at that quantity. The efficient quantity sets that sum equal to marginal cost.
Why does the Coase theorem rarely solve real externalities?
It needs low transaction costs. When the affected people number in thousands, ownership is unclear or some refuse to settle, bargaining breaks down, so taxes, caps or regulation are usually needed instead.
How does a positive externality affect the market outcome?
When an activity benefits people outside the transaction, such as a vaccination or a beehive near orchards, buyers or sellers ignore that benefit. The market produces less than the efficient amount, and a subsidy equal to the external benefit can raise output to the efficient level.
What is the tragedy of the commons?
It describes a shared resource that nobody can be kept out of, such as a fishery. Each user takes what is privately worthwhile and ignores the cost of depleting the stock for everyone else, so the resource is overused even though every user behaves sensibly from their own point of view.
Exam move
Draw the four externality cases on one sheet: negative and positive, in production and in consumption, each with the market and efficient quantities and the triangle. Then solve one Pigovian tax problem and one public good problem with two consumers. Finish by classifying ten goods by rivalry and excludability.
Link each remedy to the failure it fixes: tax or cap for external cost, subsidy for external benefit, rights for commons.
Working through Externalities, Public Goods and Common Resources in 29194? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any 29194 Externalities, Public Goods and Common Resources question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 29194 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.