University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

29194 Chap.5 Income and Substitution Effects

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 5 of 11 · 29194

Income and Substitution Effects

Where the demand curve comes from

Changing income shifts the budget line and classifies goods as normal or inferior. Changing one price pivots it, and tracing the chosen quantity at each price produces the individual demand curve.

Splitting a price change

A price change has a substitution effect and an income effect.

Hicks holds utility constant and Slutsky holds purchasing power constant; the split differs but the total does not, and the sign of the income effect separates normal, inferior and Giffen goods.

Why the split matters

Separating the two effects is what lets the theory explain an upward-sloping demand curve, and it is the same tool that later explains why a wage rise can reduce hours of work.

Learning to draw the compensated budget line cleanly is therefore an investment in two chapters, not one.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Income changes and normal goods

  • 02

    Inferior goods as an income response

  • 03

    Deriving individual demand

  • 04

    Substitution effect

  • 05

    Income effect

  • 06

    Hicks and Slutsky compensation

  • 07

    Giffen goods

Worked example · free

Decompose a fall in the price of cinema trips

Q [5 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. With U = B x T, income 120 pounds and books at 4 pounds, the price of a cinema trip falls from 10 pounds to 5 pounds. Use Hicks compensation to split the change in trips. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not a University marking scheme.
A fall in the price of cinema trips from £10 to £5.A fall in the price of cinema trips from £10 to £5. The black line is the old budget and the blue line the new one; the dashed compensated line keeps the new slope but touches the old curve U = 90 at H, so A to H is the substitution effect and H to B the income effect.Cinema tripsBooksU = 90U = 180AHB68.512
A fall in the price of cinema trips from £10 to £5. The black line is the old budget and the blue line the new one; the dashed compensated line keeps the new slope but touches the old curve U = 90 at H, so A to H is the substitution effect and H to B the income effect.
  • 1Old optimum: T = 120/(2 x 10) = 6 with B = 15, so utility is 90.
  • 1New optimum: T = 120/(2 x 5) = 12 with B = 15, a total effect of +6 trips.
  • 1Hicks point: on U = 90 at the new prices, T = 0.8B and 0.8B squared = 90, so B = 10.61 and T = 8.49.
  • 1Substitution effect = 8.49 - 6 = +2.49 trips.
  • 1Income effect = 12 - 8.49 = +3.51 trips; both positive, so trips are a normal good.
Of the six extra trips, about 2.49 come from trips becoming relatively cheaper and about 3.51 from the gain in purchasing power. Slutsky compensation would split the same six as three and three.
Sia tip — Compute the total from the two actual optima first; the two effects must add back to it.
Glossary

Key terms

Substitution Effect
Substitution Effect is the change in consumption caused by a change in relative prices with wellbeing held constant.
Income Effect
Income Effect is the change in consumption caused by the change in purchasing power that follows a price change.
Giffen Good
Giffen Good is a heavily inferior good of which people buy more after its price goes up.
Normal Good
Normal Good is a good whose consumption rises when income rises, prices held constant.
FAQ

Income and Substitution Effects FAQ

What is the difference between Hicks and Slutsky compensation?

Hicks takes away just enough income to put the consumer back on the old indifference curve, so utility is fixed. Slutsky removes enough for the original bundle to stay just affordable, holding purchasing power constant. They split the change differently but agree on the total.

Can both goods be inferior?

No. If income rose and the consumer bought less of every good, some income would be left unspent, which contradicts the assumption that more is preferred to less. At least one good must be normal.

Is every inferior good a Giffen good?

No. For most inferior goods the substitution effect still outweighs the income effect, so demand slopes down. A Giffen good needs a heavily inferior good that absorbs much of the budget, so that the income effect is the larger. Every Giffen good is inferior, but few inferior goods are Giffen.

How is a demand curve derived from indifference curves?

Hold income and the other price fixed and change the price of one good. Each price gives a new budget line and a new best bundle. Plotting the chosen quantity of the good against each price, one point at a time, traces out that consumer's demand curve.

Why is the substitution effect always negative for its own price?

Holding wellbeing fixed, a rise in a good's price makes it dearer relative to everything else, so a consumer on the same indifference curve moves to a bundle with less of it. Convex preferences guarantee that move, so the substitution effect never raises consumption of a good whose price has gone up.

Study strategy

Exam move

Draw the Hicks decomposition for a normal good until you can do it in under two minutes, labelling the compensated line and both effects. Then redraw it for an inferior good and a Giffen good, changing only where the final bundle lands. Work one numerical decomposition with a Cobb-Douglas utility function each week and check that the two effects sum to the total.

Explain each diagram aloud in one minute, naming both effects and the type of good, as if answering an oral question.

Working through Income and Substitution Effects in 29194? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any 29194 Income and Substitution Effects question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 29194 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 29194 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works