33283 Chap.3 The Cyber Defence Exercise: Budgets and Scores
The Cyber Defence Exercise: Budgets and Scores
A role play with real constraints
The cybersecurity workshop runs a 90-minute team exercise in which groups protect a railway organisation over three years. One or two decision makers split a fixed budget across the years, while cybersecurity engineers decide which protections or recovery measures to buy.
Prices rise after the start, money unspent in a year is lost, and each purchase stays active until the end of Year 3.
Scoring that rewards relevance
Each year brings a scenario, from a compromised signalling system to ransomware and a denial-of-service attack. The team scores points by how many relevant protections it already has, or takes a fixed point by using a recovery measure.
This chapter works through the budget rules, the scoring ladder and the habit of matching each purchase to a step in an attack chain.
Why the rules are built this way
Cheap early protections, a use-it-or-lose-it budget and a capped recovery measure push teams to plan rather than react.
The decision maker must commit to a split before talking to the engineers, so the first annual review is where communication between roles is tested. Recording each decision in the guideline tables turns the game into evidence you can write about.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Groups, roles and the 90-minute timetable
- 02
The £2,000 budget across the start and three years
- 03
Protection and recovery measure prices
- 04
Use it or lose it and the annual review
- 05
The scoring ladder and the recovery measure
- 06
Matching protections to attack chains
Worked example · free
Score a team across three scenarios
- 1Year 1: a used recovery measure scores 1 point whatever the protection count.
- 1Year 2: three relevant protections score 2 points.
- 1Year 3: four or more relevant protections score 3 points.
- 1Total: 1 + 2 + 3 = 6 points.
Key terms
- Decision Maker
- The role that distributes the three-year budget and reviews it each year with the engineers.
- Recovery Measure
- A hypothetical safety net in the exercise that mitigates any scenario and scores one point when used.
- Attack Chain
- The ordered steps an attacker takes in a scenario, each of which a protection may interrupt.
- Network Segmentation
- Dividing a network into smaller isolated segments to limit the spread of malware and restrict access.
- Business Continuity Management
- A framework for keeping critical business functions running during and after a disruptive event.
- Annual Budget Review
- The meeting at the start of each exercise year where the decision maker and engineers confirm or move the remaining money.
The Cyber Defence Exercise: Budgets and Scores FAQ
How much does a protection cost in the cyber exercise?
At the start of the game a protection costs £200. In Years 1 to 3 each protection costs £400 and a recovery measure costs £600. Recovery measures cannot be bought at the start, and any budget not used in a year is lost rather than carried forward.
How are points scored in each year?
Points depend on how many relevant protections are in place for that year's scenario: none scores minus three, one scores minus one, two scores zero, three scores plus two and four or more score plus three. A recovery measure, if used, scores one point instead.
Who decides how the budget is split?
The decision maker sets the initial allocation alone, without talking to the engineers. From Year 1 onwards the decision maker and the cybersecurity engineers meet at the start of each year to confirm or redistribute the remaining money, and the engineers decide what to buy.
What is a recovery measure in the exercise?
It is a virtual, hypothetical measure that mitigates any kind of scenario. It costs £600, can only be bought from Year 1 onwards, and is not used automatically: if the team chooses to use it in a year, that year scores one point regardless of how many protections are in place.
Assessment move
Write the price list and the scoring ladder on a card before the workshop and keep it in front of you. For any budget plan, check that every year's allocation is a multiple of something you can actually buy at that year's price. For scoring, list the protections you own beside each scenario's list of possible measures and count matches.
Afterwards, write two sentences on which purchase earned the most points and why; that note becomes evidence for the formative group report. If your team had a weak year, rerun it on paper with one different purchase and see how many points it would have changed.
Working through The Cyber Defence Exercise: Budgets and Scores in 33283? Sia is AskSia’s AI Engineering tutor — ask any 33283 The Cyber Defence Exercise: Budgets and Scores question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 33283 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.