38010 Chap.11 Disruptive Innovation in Cars and Streaming
Disruptive Innovation in Cars and Streaming
Policy built the electric car market
The practice cases presented in Week 4 show regulation and technology moving together. California's 1990 low-emission programme pushed carmakers into electric models, later tax benefits and research funding revived the market, and a plug-in car's 77% energy efficiency against 12% to 30% for petrol gave buyers their own reason to switch.
Between 2015 and 2019 the US electric car share rose from 0.7% to 2%.
Two strategies, one market
Nissan's Leaf was sized as a second household car and sold through dealers, while Tesla moved from a low-volume Roadster to the mass-market Model 3, sold directly and built much of its own software and batteries.
Integration speeded learning but made output depend on a few plants.
Disruptors become targets
Netflix overtook Blockbuster, then faced well-funded streaming rivals, a subscriber loss in 2022 and rising churn of 3.3%, still below a 7% industry average. Net neutrality rules, tariffs on Chinese electric cars and a Chinese car plant in Hungary show how policy shapes each contest.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Mandates and the first electric cars
- 02
Efficiency and running costs
- 03
Nissan Leaf as a second car
- 04
Tesla's volume plan
- 05
Vertical integration and bottlenecks
- 06
Netflix churn and retention
- 07
Net neutrality and streaming
- 08
China's electric vehicle exports
Worked example · free
Read Netflix churn against the industry average
- 1Rise in churn: 3.3% - 2.4% = 0.9 percentage points.
- 1Extra leavers: 223 million x 0.009 = about 2.0 million in a period.
- 1At the industry rate: 223 million x 0.07 = about 15.6 million, against about 7.4 million at 3.3%.
- 1Interpret: an extra subscriber costs almost nothing to serve, so each departure removes nearly pure profit.
Key terms
- Vertical Integration
- Vertical integration means a firm makes key inputs and services itself, as Tesla did with batteries, powertrains, charging and software, instead of buying them in.
- Net Neutrality
- Net neutrality is the rule that internet providers must treat all data traffic alike, adopted by the US communications regulator in 2015.
- Churn Rate
- The churn rate measures the share of subscribers who cancel in a period, the key retention figure for a streaming service.
- Plug-in Electric Vehicle
- A plug-in electric vehicle runs only on a battery charged from the grid, unlike a hybrid, which also carries a petrol engine.
- Direct-to-Consumer Selling
- Direct-to-consumer selling cuts out dealers so that the manufacturer handles orders, pricing and delivery itself, as Tesla chose to do.
Disruptive Innovation in Cars and Streaming FAQ
How did government policy start the electric car market?
California's Air Resources Board launched a low-emission vehicle programme in 1990 that required big carmakers to develop alternative fuels, and General Motors responded with the EV1 in 1996. Later, tighter emission rules, research funding and buyer tax benefits revived electric cars, and countries such as the Netherlands now plan bans on new petrol cars.
Why did Nissan design the Leaf as a second car?
Nissan matched the Leaf's 73-mile range to an average US daily commute of 31.5 miles and noted that households averaged 1.9 cars. Selling it as the local second vehicle made the short range acceptable and let the firm use its existing dealer network to reach buyers.
What are the risks of Tesla's vertical integration?
Owning batteries, powertrains, charging and software lets Tesla learn and improve quickly, but output then depends on a few plants and systems. Heavy early automation caused breakdowns, the 2012 delivery estimate fell from 5,000 to 3,000 cars, and any delay at its battery or powertrain plants slows the whole business.
Why is Netflix now described as being disrupted?
Netflix once displaced video rental, but rivals such as Amazon Prime and Disney now compete with deep budgets. It lost 1.2 million subscribers in early 2022 and its market value collapsed, so it added an advertising tier, staggered some releases and began restricting password sharing to defend its base.
How does policy affect streaming firms?
Streaming depends on internet providers carrying huge volumes of traffic. Netflix paid Comcast a carriage fee in 2014, and the 2015 US decision to regulate broadband and adopt net neutrality required providers to treat all data traffic similarly, a decision the case says Netflix benefited from.
Assessment move
Make a two-column sheet for cars and streaming. In each column list the policy that shaped the market, the incumbent's response and the entrant's advantage, with one number for each. Practise the four-step routine from the method page on an invented firm of your own: locate the advantage, find the bottleneck, check the policy dependency and price the fallback.
Convert one percentage into people or units, as with churn, so you are used to showing what a rate means in practice. Finally, write a short paragraph on whether disruption in cars and streaming was driven more by technology or by rules, because that judgement is the kind of argument a policy report has to support with evidence.
Working through Disruptive Innovation in Cars and Streaming in 38010? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any 38010 Disruptive Innovation in Cars and Streaming question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 38010 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.