5AAVC300 Chap.2 Selling the Internet as Freedom
Selling the Internet as Freedom
The paradox of Week 2
The week page describes the early internet as a medium inseparable from social control that nonetheless came to be seen as a revolutionary medium of freedom. It asks what kind of freedom that was and how the largest technology companies used it to gain influence.
The required reading is Wendy Hui Kyong Chun on control and freedom.
Engagement as the business model
Zala Volcic and Mark Andrejevic argue that social media algorithms select whatever provokes the most reaction, whether or not it is accurate or useful to citizens.
Platforms that sort other people's content behave like logistical media, managing flow for profit, and outrage serves that goal as well as agreement does.
Commercial populism
Their term for the political result is commercial populism: populism used as a sales tool, joined to politics that treats the citizen as a consumer of taste.
They develop it through the political rise of Donald Trump and the merchandising of political commentary.
Freedom without interdependence
The deepest claim is that automated curation makes a social process look like personal choice.
Freedom then appears as absolute independence, and any reminder of interdependence feels like a threat, which weakens the shared public a democracy needs.
Essay angles for Week 2
Useful questions include whether personal choice online is real choice, whether platforms are neutral when they rank by engagement, and how the idea of freedom was used to sell a medium of control.
Pair the week framing with the article's case material, and keep your claims about effects as cautious as the authors keep theirs.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Control and freedom on the early internet
- 02
Engagement ranking regardless of accuracy
- 03
Platforms as logistical media
- 04
Commercial populism and the citizen as consumer
- 05
Networked solipsism and the end of a shared feed
- 06
Freedom imagined as absolute independence
Worked example · free
Is the feed a filter bubble?
- 2State the filter bubble claim and what it says narrows.
- 2Explain the authors' shift from content to the form and rhythm of reception.
- 2Rewrite the claim in a sharper, qualified form.
Key terms
- Logistical Media
- Logistical Media are institutions concerned with organising people and things in time and space, a description the authors apply to platforms.
- Networked Solipsism
- Networked Solipsism is the condition in which every user's feed is unique and available only to them.
- Un-Civic Discourse
- Un-Civic Discourse is an unwillingness to accept the interdependence on which a shared public interest depends.
- Rhythmedia
- Rhythmedia is Elinor Carmi's term, used by Volcic and Andrejevic, for media that order people and relations as rhythms for profit.
Selling the Internet as Freedom FAQ
Why does outrage spread so well on platforms?
According to Volcic and Andrejevic, ranking systems reward whatever draws a response, and angry reactions count as engagement. Their example is a hoax video about a school shooting that reached the top trending position partly because people reposted their disgust at it.
Is commercial populism only about one politician?
No. The authors use Trump as their main case, but the concept describes a wider fit between selling strategies and automated media, including commentators who sell supplements or merchandise through political content.
How does this week connect to Barlow?
Barlow wanted freedom from imposed order. Volcic and Andrejevic describe a later form of that ideal, freedom as personal taste and absolute independence, which they argue cannot recognise the interdependence that a common good requires.
Assessment move
Draw the engagement loop from memory and label each step with a line from the article. Then collect one current example of a post that spread through angry sharing and test whether the loop explains it. Write one paragraph that applies commercial populism to a case of your own and ends with a limit the concept cannot settle.
Finally, compare the filter bubble and disposition critiques in two sentences, so you can choose deliberately between them in an essay. Keep a short list of the article's hedged claims, such as payments reportedly made, so your own citations carry the same caution.
Working through Selling the Internet as Freedom in 5AAVC300? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 5AAVC300 Selling the Internet as Freedom question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 5AAVC300 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.