5AAVC300 Chap.7 The Hidden Costs of Digital Devices
The Hidden Costs of Digital Devices
Against the costless image
The Week 8 page asks you to interrogate Big Tech's tendency to represent the digital as immaterial, virtual and costless.
It lists the hidden systems: the labour of making devices, the data storage they require, the logistics that move materials and the minerals needed to manufacture them.
The core and suggested readings
The core reading and viewing is Kate Crawford and Vladan Joler's Anatomy of an AI System, an essay and visual map.
The highly recommended suggested reading is the first chapter of Jonathan Crary's Scorched Earth, which argues that any livable shared future will be offline.
Crary's evidence
Crary describes data centres with enormous energy and water needs and open-pit mining on a vast scale, using the Grasberg mine in Papua as a case.
He links copper, lithium, neodymium and coltan to wiring, batteries, turbines and drones, and argues that the internet cannot simply change hands in a fairer society.
Human costs
He also rejects 1990s hopes for creative immaterial labour, describing low-wage digital work under surveillance and the spread of work into every waking hour.
Essay angles for Week 8
This week supports questions about whether the digital is immaterial, who pays for everyday devices, and whether green technology escapes the problem.
Build the essay on one traced supply chain, attribute every figure, and evaluate Crary's offline conclusion instead of adopting it wholesale.
What this chapter covers
- 01
The dematerialised image of the digital
- 02
Data centres, energy and water
- 03
Open-pit mining and the Grasberg case
- 04
Minerals linked to devices and green technology
- 05
Why the internet cannot change hands
- 06
Immaterial labour and digital work
Worked example · free
Trace one device to its materials
- 2Name the categories of hidden cost the week page lists.
- 2Select two and support each with evidence from Crary.
- 2Explain what the costs reveal about the cloud image.
Key terms
- Dematerialised Imaginary
- The Dematerialised Imaginary is Crary's term for the belief that digital technology has no physical substance or cost.
- Scorched Earth Capitalism
- Scorched Earth Capitalism is Crary's name for a terminal phase of capitalism that destroys the conditions for subsistence and self-government.
- Sociocidal Extraction
- Sociocidal Extraction is Crary's description of mining that destroys communities as well as landscapes.
- Open-Pit Mining
- Open-Pit Mining is surface extraction of minerals from a large excavated crater, the method Crary describes at Grasberg.
- Paleotechnic Paradigm
- The Paleotechnic Paradigm is Mumford's term, used by Crary, for an economy resting on mining, drilling and laying waste to land.
The Hidden Costs of Digital Devices FAQ
Is the cloud really physical?
Yes, according to the readings. Crary points to data centres with staggering energy requirements that must be cooled with millions of gallons of water daily, and argues that words like virtual and cloud veil those material realities.
What is Anatomy of an AI System?
It is the week's core reading and viewing by Kate Crawford and Vladan Joler, offered both as an essay and as an artwork or visual map. Read it alongside Crary's chapter, which supplies figures on mining and data centres.
Does Crary think green technology solves the problem?
No. He ties copper and other minerals to solar panels, wind turbines and electric vehicles, and he dismisses assurances that extraction can be made harmless. An essay can accept his evidence while questioning that certainty.
Why is Crary's chapter only suggested reading?
The week page lists Crawford and Joler's Anatomy of an AI System as the core reading and viewing and marks Crary's first chapter as highly recommended suggested reading. Use Crary for evidence and argument, but anchor the essay in the core text.
Assessment move
Draw the material stack from memory, from the cloud down to the mines, and attach one piece of evidence from Crary to each layer. Choose one device you own and write a short paragraph tracing two hidden costs with attributed figures. Then write one sentence that evaluates Crary's offline conclusion, naming a strength and a weakness, so you can use him critically rather than simply adopt his position.
Revisit the Week 8 core artwork after reading Crary and note one connection it makes that his chapter does not.
Working through The Hidden Costs of Digital Devices in 5AAVC300? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 5AAVC300 The Hidden Costs of Digital Devices question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 5AAVC300 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.