6QQMN331 Chap.4 Ethics, Governance and Organisational Politics
Ethics, Governance and Organisational Politics
Compare reasons, then govern action
This chapter uses duties, consequences and character as distinct ethical lenses. Their value is not a longer list of concerns but a clearer account of why a use should be supported, restricted or rejected.
The governance section turns principles into recording, review, authority, monitoring and remedy.
Keep politics visible
Infrastructure, thresholds and access distribute power even when described as technical choices.
Worked practice therefore connects affected groups and contested values to specific organisational controls and a named decision owner.
Preserve genuine disagreement
Ethical lenses should not collapse into three versions of the same risk list. Duty reasoning may establish a constraint, outcome reasoning compares likely benefits and harms, and virtue reasoning tests the judgement an organisation cultivates.
Their conflict can reveal the decisive premise in a recommendation. A strong conclusion states which reason governs, acknowledges the best counterargument and shows what safeguard follows from that choice.
Give governance authority
Recording and review matter only when a responsible role can require evidence, delay release, narrow use or stop deployment.
The chapter maps that authority beside the people who supply technical, operational and affected-user knowledge. Monitoring is treated as a fresh decision rather than passive observation: an incident, performance change or repeated appeal triggers a stated response. The same map keeps politics visible by showing who sets thresholds, controls infrastructure, bears errors and can challenge the arrangement.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Deontology
- 02
Consequentialism
- 03
Virtue Ethics
- 04
Model Alignment
- 05
AI Governance
- 06
Technological Sovereignty
Worked example · free
A decision test for high-impact AI
- 3Compare duties, outcomes and professional character.
- 3Identify evidence, affected people and decision ownership.
- 3Set review, appeal and monitoring controls.
Key terms
- Deontology
- Deontology judges action through duties, rules and constraints.
- Consequentialism
- Consequentialism evaluates action through expected benefits and harms.
- Virtue Ethics
- Virtue Ethics asks what good character and practical judgement require.
- AI Governance
- AI Governance structures ownership, review, approval, monitoring and remedy.
Ethics, Governance and Organisational Politics FAQ
Why use more than one ethical lens?
Different lenses reveal different reasons. Duties may constrain an action even when benefits look attractive, consequence analysis compares affected outcomes, and virtue ethics tests the judgement an organisation cultivates. Disagreement exposes the value or premise driving the recommendation.
What turns an ethical principle into governance?
The organisation must attach the principle to an owner, evidence requirement, decision gate, possible action and review trigger. Recording a use case, evaluating effectiveness and rights, limiting deployment and monitoring incidents turns an aspiration into an accountable process.
Why are infrastructure choices political?
Choices about models, compute, data and suppliers distribute control, dependence and access. Analyse who can set rules, who benefits, who bears disruption and who can challenge the arrangement. Calling a choice technical does not remove its organisational or geopolitical consequences.
How should conflicting ethical reasons be resolved?
State the proposition from each lens, identify where they disagree and make the prioritising judgement explicit. A duty may operate as a boundary that anticipated benefits cannot trade away, while uncertainty may weaken an outcome claim. The answer should explain why one reason is decisive in this case and recognise the strongest objection.
What makes monitoring actionable?
Monitoring needs a signal, threshold, owner and response. Repeated appeals, changed users, performance drift or unauthorised use may reopen the decision. Specify who receives the evidence and whether the system continues, narrows, pauses or withdraws. Without that route, observation records a problem but does not govern it.
Why is a human reviewer insufficient by itself?
A reviewer may lack time, context, authority or a defensible way to disagree. Meaningful oversight states which evidence the person sees, which cases require deeper review and what is recorded when the person departs from the output. It also protects challenge from becoming an empty approval ritual.
Assessment move
Apply all three ethical lenses to one case and write a separate proposition from each. Identify the strongest conflict, make a judgement and turn it into a governance gate with a named owner and review trigger. Repair any paragraph that uses only broad nouns such as fairness or accountability. Draw the authority path from evidence supplier to final approver and label who can pause the use.
Add one monitoring signal, threshold and response, then explain whose interests or dependence are changed by the chosen infrastructure.
Working through Ethics, Governance and Organisational Politics in 6QQMN331? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any 6QQMN331 Ethics, Governance and Organisational Politics question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 6QQMN331 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.