7AAVDM32 Chap.5 Selection, Appraisal and Preservation
Selection, Appraisal and Preservation
Value becomes a decision
This chapter turns organisational mission, community significance, rights, cost and preservation feasibility into explicit appraisal criteria.
It distinguishes selection, deferment and disposal so temporary constraints do not become hidden judgments of worth.
Selection defines managed scope
Selection decides which assets an organisation will accept responsibility for, under stated conditions and for a stated period.
The decision should connect to mission, user need, evidential or cultural significance, uniqueness, rights, technical condition and available resources. No single criterion settles every case. A defensible decision shows how the factors were weighed, who had authority, and what evidence would trigger reconsideration.
Appraisal is documented judgment
Appraisal translates broad values into a reasoned outcome.
Separate the significance of content from the feasibility of current action. An important asset may require deferment while consent or technical capacity is secured; a cheap asset may still fall outside collecting purpose.
Recording these distinctions prevents operational convenience from masquerading as a judgment that an asset lacks value.
Risk is not only technical
Format obsolescence, media failure and missing dependencies matter, but so do undocumented provenance, unclear rights, harmful description and loss of community context. Assess likelihood and consequence for a named asset and user.
Then identify which risks can be reduced, which must be accepted, and which make access inappropriate until further review. A preservation plan that protects bits while discarding authority or meaning is incomplete.
Significant properties guide action
Before choosing a strategy, state which characteristics must remain for the asset to fulfil its purpose.
These may include visual appearance, behaviour, sequence, functionality, evidential relationships or the ability to inspect original structure. Migration, emulation, documentation and retention each protect different properties and introduce different changes.
The choice should follow the significance analysis rather than begin with a preferred technology.
Disposal needs governance
Disposal is an accountable lifecycle decision, not a silent deletion. Confirm authority, contractual or legal constraints, duplicate and relationship status, required documentation, and the effect on communities or users. Keep enough evidence to explain what was decided and why.
Where uncertainty is resolvable, deferment with a review date is more transparent than either indefinite unmanaged retention or irreversible removal.
Preserve the reasoning
An original community-archive case shows how technical urgency and cultural significance can point in different directions.
The preservation exercise identifies significant properties before choosing migration, emulation, documentation or controlled retention. A strong answer joins the strategy to a risk, names the property protected, records expected change, assigns responsibility and sets a review trigger. This preserves the decision context as well as the digital object.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Selection
- 02
Appraisal criteria
- 03
Organisational value
- 04
Community authority
- 05
Preservation target
- 06
Documented disposal
Worked example · free
Prioritise an archive backlog
- 2Define mission and participating authority.
- 2Separate significance from urgency.
- 2Choose select, defer or dispose.
- 2Record criteria and a review trigger.
Key terms
- Selection
- Selection chooses material for a defined scope or continuing management purpose.
- Appraisal
- Appraisal evaluates value, responsibility and feasibility against explicit criteria.
- Significant Properties
- Significant Properties are characteristics that preservation should maintain for an object to retain its intended meaning or function.
Selection, Appraisal and Preservation FAQ
Why is download count a weak disposal rule?
Low use may reflect poor description, restricted access, a specialist audience or long-term evidential value. Usage can inform review, but disposal should also examine mission, uniqueness, rights, obligations, preservation condition and realistic future purpose under an authorised policy.
How does preservation begin at appraisal?
Selection establishes what the organisation commits to manage and which properties, relationships and evidence matter. Without that reasoning, later migration or retention may preserve readable files while losing authenticity, context or the experience considered significant.
What is the difference between deferment and rejection?
Deferment records that evidence, rights, capacity or technology may change and assigns a trigger for review. Rejection places the item outside the defined scope under current policy. Keeping the reasons distinct supports accountability and prevents forgotten queues.
How do significant properties affect preservation strategy?
Identify the characteristics an asset must retain to serve its intended evidential, cultural or functional purpose. Then compare which strategy protects those characteristics and what each strategy changes. Migration may preserve accessible content while altering behaviour; emulation may retain behaviour while increasing dependency; documentation may preserve context without reproducing experience.
Record the trade-off, authority and review trigger. The strategy follows the value analysis, rather than a preferred technology deciding what counts as significant.
Assessment move
For one collection, write separate columns for significance, urgency, rights and feasibility. Choose an outcome only after explaining how those criteria interact. Name the significant property protected by the proposed preservation action and its review trigger.