King's College London · FACULTY OF ARTS & HUMANITIES

7AAVIN01 Chap.7 Evaluating Markup Projects

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 7 of 11 · 7AAVIN01

Evaluating Markup Projects

Evaluating Markup Projects prepares you for the critique option of the report. In Week 2 each student assesses one XML project, allocated by surname, and the chapter turns the preparation questions into evidence: research objectives, why markup is used, other methods, documentation and the quality of the project summary.

It uses the single source, multiple outputs principle to ask what an encoding actually enables, lists the further case studies the module offers, and shows how to move from one strength and one improvement to specific, actionable proposals. The chapter connects the seminar exercise directly to the report.

Option 1 asks you to summarise a project, state its aims in one sentence, set out strengths, then discuss limitations with suggestions you can illustrate through initial results, methods, plans or designs. The best critiques name the field to change, the standard to use and the gain for users, and they discuss what the proposed method itself cannot do.

The case study list, from the Van Gogh letters and the Shelley Godwin Archive to Menota, the Gascon Rolls and the IPM encoding model, offers projects of different sizes for that purpose. A worked example drafts a strength and an improvement for an invented online edition of letters, showing how to argue for published encoding guidelines and downloadable TEI files.

A short note on re-use explains where class work may inform a report and where it may not, and practice items rehearse the questions an examiner may ask about your choice of project.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The four allocated projects

  • 02

    Preparation questions for any project

  • 03

    What the XML enables

  • 04

    Documentation and encoding guidelines

  • 05

    Further case studies

  • 06

    From seminar notes to a critique

  • 07

    Re-use of class work

Worked example · free

Turn a vague criticism into a proposal

Q [3 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. A draft critique of an invented archive says only that its metadata could be better. Rewrite this as a specific, assessable proposal. The marks shown are an AskSia practice allocation, not an official University marking scheme.
One XML repository in the centre feeds seven outputs, from web and mobile to print and a database, so a strong evaluation asks which of these the project actualOne XML repository in the centre feeds seven outputs, from web and mobile to print and a database, so a strong evaluation asks which of these the project actually delivers and which its encoding could support but does not.XML sourceone repositoryWebMobileTabletBookJournalPDFDatabase
One XML repository in the centre feeds seven outputs, from web and mobile to print and a database, so a strong evaluation asks which of these the project actually delivers and which its encoding could support but does not.
  • 1Name the field: subject terms are free text typed by different contributors.
  • 1Name the standard: replace them with terms from a controlled vocabulary such as LCSH.
  • 1Name the gain: consistent subjects allow reliable search and joining with other collections.
Replace free-text subject terms with LCSH headings so that search results are consistent and records can be combined with other collections.
Sia tip — Every improvement should name a field, a standard and a gain; if one is missing, the proposal is still vague.
Glossary

Key terms

Encoding guidelines
Project documentation that explains which elements are used and how decisions were made.
Digital edition
A scholarly presentation of a text in digital form, often built from encoded source files.
Project summary
The short description in which a project explains its aims and the value of its approach.
Critique
A reasoned evaluation of an existing project that weighs strengths and limitations and proposes improvements.
FAQ

Evaluating Markup Projects FAQ

Which projects are assessed in the Week 2 preparation?

Students are allocated by surname to an edition of the Wilde manuscript of Dorian Gray, the guidelines for Edvard Munch's writings, a TAPAS drama sample or the Mark Twain project, and assess its use of XML.

What should I look for when evaluating a markup project?

Look at its research objectives, why it uses markup, what other methods it combines, what sample XML shows about elements and structure, what outputs the encoding enables and how well its documentation explains the approach.

Can I reuse a class project in my report?

The brief allows you to draw on collaborative class work in a general sense, but says you should not directly re-use it, for example by re-implementing an in-class project.

What makes a strong suggestion for improving a project?

It is specific enough to act on and test. Name the field or feature to change, the module method or standard you would use, and the gain for users, then admit what your proposed method would still leave unsolved.

Why compare a project's XML with its output?

The comparison shows which encoded features reach readers and which stay hidden. If the files mark people and places but the site offers no way to search them, the encoding supports more than the interface delivers, which is a fair point for a critique.

How many strengths and weaknesses should a critique list?

The seminar asks for one of each so that you choose carefully. A report can discuss more, but each point should be supported by evidence from the project and linked to a method from the module rather than listed briefly.

Which case studies does the module suggest beyond the four allocated projects?

The preparation page lists Injured Islanders, whose underlying TEI file is available, the Van Gogh letters, the Shelley Godwin Archive and its guidelines, Menota for medieval Nordic sources, the Gascon Rolls project, the IPM encoding model and a large catalogue of digital editions.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Pick two projects from the case study list and evaluate both with the same five questions. Write one paragraph comparing them, then decide which you could critique in 2,800 words with specific improvements. Choose the one where your improvements can name fields and standards from the module. Draft your strength and improvement as two short paragraphs, each with evidence from the project and a reference to a module reading.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 18 of your subjects at King's College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 7AAVIN01 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works