7AAVIN01 Chap.1 What Digital Humanities Is and Does
What Digital Humanities Is and Does
What Digital Humanities Is and Does starts where the module starts: with disagreement. Published verdicts range from a major expansion of the humanities to a political warning about funding and the university, and one scholar calls the term a free-floating signifier.
Rather than choosing a slogan, the chapter equips you with frameworks that let you place any project: Drucker's sequence of materials, processing and presentation, Davidson's Humanities 1.0 and 2.0, and Berry's three waves of quantitative, interpretive and computational work. It ends with how DH work is organised, in teams rather than by lone scholars, and with the trading zone where interpretation and data meet.
The chapter matters for assessment because both components ask you to position a project. A report introduction that states which framework it uses, and why, reads as an argument rather than a summary, and an examiner in the viva may ask what kind of digital humanities your project represents.
You will also meet Berry and Fagerjord's warning against using tools such as the Google Ngram Viewer uncritically, and Svensson's list of changes in the humanities ecosystem, from funding and rewards to infrastructure. Treat each framework as a lens with blind spots: the waves describe emphases, not sealed periods, and a single project can show features of more than one.
Practice items at the end ask you to classify invented projects and to answer the kind of question an examiner might put about why a project needs a digital method at all.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Competing definitions of the field
- 02
Drucker's materials, processing and presentation
- 03
Davidson's Humanities 1.0 and 2.0
- 04
Berry's three waves
- 05
The DH project versus the lone scholar
- 06
Trading zones between disciplines
Worked example · free
Describe a project with Drucker's three stages
- 1Materials: the scanned registers; choosing which parishes and years to scan already shapes what the map can show.
- 1Processing: automatic extraction of names and dates; decisions about spelling variants and unreadable entries change the counts.
- 1Presentation: the interactive map; its colours, scale and default view guide what a reader notices first.
Key terms
- Digital humanities
- A discipline that brings computing to bear on culture while questioning what computing does to the evidence.
- Trading zone
- A collaborative arrangement in which specialists from different fields develop a shared way to exchange ideas.
- Iteracy
- Berry's term combining iteration and literacy, used for the computational turn of the third wave.
- Humanities 2.0
- Davidson's label for interactive, open and participatory work that decentres knowledge and authority.
What Digital Humanities Is and Does FAQ
Is there one accepted definition of digital humanities?
No single definition settles the debate. The lecture sets enthusiastic, sceptical and political verdicts side by side, and Kirschenbaum's phrase about a free-floating signifier captures why. A report should state a working definition and show how it shapes the analysis.
What are Berry's three waves of digital humanities?
The first wave is quantitative, built on database search and corpus linguistics. The second is qualitative and interpretive, with more born-digital material. The third is a computational turn that studies platforms and code themselves.
How is a DH project different from traditional humanities research?
Traditional work is often a lone scholar producing an article or monograph. A DH project usually involves a team, attention to process, outputs that can be remixed, several roles needing credit, and tension between computational precision and interpretive nuance.
Why does Drucker's model include presentation choices such as font and colour?
Because the interface is part of the argument. Drucker's third stage covers web or offline delivery, rhetorical choices and graphics, so the way results are shown shapes what readers believe. A critique that ignores presentation misses one of the three places where interpretation enters a project.
What is the trading zone idea and why use it in a report?
McCarty takes Galison's term for a meeting place where specialists with different vocabularies agree local terms of exchange. In a report it lets you describe collaboration precisely: who brought interpretation, who brought data or models, and where the partners negotiated meaning.
Why does the module quote critics of digital humanities?
Because the module wants critical commentary, not advocacy. Allington and colleagues link the field's funding to a neoliberal takeover of the university, and Kirsch questions its advocates' claims. Engaging such critiques shows an examiner you can weigh a method's costs as well as its promise.
Assessment move
Make a one-page sheet with three columns: framework, its stages, and one invented project that fits each stage. Then take a real project from the module case studies and place it on all three frameworks, noting where it refuses to fit. Practise saying aloud why a definition matters for your own report topic.
In the viva, be ready to define the field in your own words in two sentences and then to name one scholar who would disagree with you.