7AAVMAR2 Chap.8 Group Research Proposal and Practical Experiment
Group Research Proposal and Practical Experiment
The proposal and its test
Assessment 001 asks a group to propose a digital heritage project in response to one of the published briefs, supported by a small practical experiment shown as captioned evidence.
This chapter sets out the four required headings and their guide word counts, and models an experiment that tests one decision.
Criteria, roles and scope
It explains the five marking criteria, the roles in the teamwork agreement, choosing a manageable sample and the resit route.
How to use this chapter
Read it alongside the project brief on KEATS.
Start with the experiment, because the brief says it should test a decision central to the approach and that marks go to the proposal and to how well you analyse the test. Then use the criteria weights to plan effort: methodology carries the largest share, while ethics and collaboration together carry as much as knowledge and argument combined.
The team roles and scope advice help the group deliver a manageable, coherent proposal.
The four commissions
The brief offers protective objects across three museums, Lisht objects at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the FO 84 series at The National Archives, and Hawaiian kapa at the British Museum, plus an independent option.
Each supplies a spreadsheet; the seminar notes they need different amounts of data cleaning and differ in how ready they are for a user-facing experience.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Four required headings
- 02
Designing the experiment
- 03
Evidence and screenshots
- 04
Marking criteria
- 05
Team roles
- 06
Manageable scope
Worked example · free
Choose the decision your experiment tests
- 2Select a manageable sample of records and keep their original values and identifiers.
- 2Add a normalised search term or context note for each, clearly marked as the group's addition.
- 2Compare searches before and after, report what changed and state the limits of the test.
Key terms
- Proof of Concept
- A proof of concept is a small practical test that shows whether a proposed approach could work, without being a finished product.
- Teamwork Learning Agreement
- The teamwork learning agreement is the signed group document setting roles, meetings, communication and shared responsibilities.
- Working Spreadsheet
- A working spreadsheet is the group's own copy of selected records, keeping source identifiers and original wording beside any additions.
- Decision Record
- A decision record is a short log of the curatorial choices a group made, kept with the source and working files.
Group Research Proposal and Practical Experiment FAQ
Is the prototype marked?
The experiment tests the proposal and is not assessed as a finished product. Technical complexity or polish earns nothing in itself; credit comes from explaining why the methods suit the material, audience and problem.
Do external links count as evidence of the experiment?
No. The brief asks for captioned images or screenshots in the proposal or a concise appendix, and states that external links count only as reference material.
How many records should a group work with?
The brief says no project requires processing every supplied record. Pick a sample small enough to test properly within the word limit, and explain why that amount of work is manageable.
What are the five marking criteria for the proposal?
Knowledge and research, 20%; conceptualisation and argument, 20%; curatorial and technical methodology, 30%; ethical and responsible practice, 15%; and collaboration and communication, 15%. All sit within the Faculty of Arts and Humanities Postgraduate Marking Criteria.
Can our group propose its own project?
Yes, with the convenor's agreement before the experiment starts. The independent brief still needs accessible data, a clear heritage question and a practical test of selecting, describing, organising or presenting material, and it follows the same four headings.
What happens if a group's proposal fails?
The resit uses the same assignment type through a different project. If the group's work is insufficient to pass, the convenor sets a new group project; a student who did not engage with the group is reassessed individually under the same criteria.
Assessment move
Draft the four headings early with placeholder word counts, then write the experiment section first, because it shapes the others. Keep a shared decision log and assign the five roles from the teamwork agreement in the first meeting. Before submission, check each criterion against a paragraph that addresses it.
In the final week, read the proposal aloud as a group to check that sections written by different members form one coherent argument with consistent referencing. Save the final shared folder, including the signed agreement, as the group's record.