King's College London · FACULTY OF ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE

7SSGN172 Chap.7 Macroinvertebrates, BMWP and ASPT

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
5 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 7 of 8 · 7SSGN172

Macroinvertebrates, BMWP and ASPT

Build indices from the family list

BMWP adds one tolerance score for each scoring family present, while ASPT divides the total by the number of scoring taxa. Abundance does not multiply a family score in this method.

The worked example keeps the family list and divisor visible so the arithmetic can be audited.

Interpret with habitat and effort

The source warns that unsuitable habitat can distort the index. Standardised kick sampling, family identification and comparable effort therefore sit beside the score.

Chemical snapshots and the biological assemblage cover different timescales, making disagreement a question to investigate rather than a reason to discard one result.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Kick sampling

  • 02

    Family tolerance scores

  • 03

    BMWP totals

  • 04

    ASPT averages

  • 05

    Habitat suitability

Worked example · free

Calculate BMWP and ASPT

Q [8 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Five scoring families have values 10, 7, 6, 4 and 2. Calculate both indices and distinguish their meanings. This mark allocation is not an official marking scheme.
The index sequence moves from identification to arithmetic.The index sequence moves from identification to arithmetic. BMWP sums family scores, while ASPT divides that sum by the number of scoring taxa.identified familiessum tolerance scoresdivide by taxa count
The index sequence moves from identification to arithmetic. BMWP sums family scores, while ASPT divides that sum by the number of scoring taxa.
  • 3Sum family scores to obtain BMWP 29.
  • 2Count five scoring taxa.
  • 3Divide to obtain ASPT 5.8 and interpret.
BMWP is 29 and ASPT is 29 divided by 5, or 5.8. The total reflects richness plus scores, while ASPT is the average score among recorded scoring taxa. Habitat and sampling effort remain part of interpretation.
Sia tip — Count each scoring family once, even when many individuals are present.
Glossary

Key terms

Kick Sample
Kick Sample collects macroinvertebrates dislodged from the streambed into a downstream net under a defined effort.
Tolerance Score
Tolerance Score is the family-level value used in the BMWP sum.
Scoring Taxon
Scoring Taxon is an identified family included in both the BMWP total and ASPT divisor.
FAQ

Macroinvertebrates, BMWP and ASPT FAQ

Does abundance multiply a BMWP family score?

No. The method sums the score once for each scoring family present. Abundance can support a separate ecological analysis, but multiplying a family score by individual count changes the index and its interpretation.

Why can BMWP and ASPT move differently?

BMWP rises when additional scoring families are recorded, while ASPT depends on their average score. More families near the existing average can raise BMWP without changing ASPT, so report taxa count with both indices.

What habitat issue can distort interpretation?

A method designed for riffle macroinvertebrates can be misleading in silty or lentic habitat. Substrate, flow, sampling duration and accessible area influence which families are collected and must be comparable across sites.

Why is the family list more informative than a final score alone?

The list shows which tolerance values entered BMWP, which taxa determined the ASPT divisor and where identification uncertainty remains. It permits recalculation after a taxonomic correction. A standalone score conceals whether two sites differ through richness, family sensitivity or a spreadsheet counting error.

Which taxa belong in the ASPT divisor?

Count the distinct scoring taxa whose values were included in the BMWP total. Do not use total individuals, all specimens or an uncertain taxon omitted from the sum. The divisor should be auditable directly from the same family-by-score table used for BMWP.

How can BMWP rise while ASPT stays unchanged?

Additional scoring families increase the BMWP total. If their scores are close to the existing average, the mean score per taxon may remain similar. This pattern suggests a richness difference without a changed average tolerance and makes comparable sampling effort especially important.

Why avoid treating an index threshold as a sharp ecological boundary?

Sampling variability, identification and habitat can move a score across a category edge without a sudden environmental change. Report the raw BMWP, scoring-taxa count and ASPT, then use categories as summaries alongside chemistry, physical habitat and method context rather than as certain diagnoses.

How should uncertain family identification be handled?

Record the finest level supported by visible features, retain the specimen or image reference and flag whether the taxon enters scoring. Forcing an uncertain family can change both the sum and divisor. A visible uncertainty allows review and sensitivity analysis before the environmental interpretation is fixed.

What does disagreement with a chemical grab sample mean?

It does not automatically invalidate either result. Chemistry captures conditions at collection, whereas the assemblage reflects exposure, colonisation and habitat over a longer period. Examine rainfall, flow, substrate, sampling effort and earlier stress, then propose a timed repeat or habitat-matched comparison that separates the leading explanation.

What should be reported with BMWP and ASPT?

Provide the scoring family list, taxa count, sampling effort, habitat description and identification procedure alongside both indices. Add relevant chemistry and physical context without collapsing them into the score. These details let a reader determine whether a difference reflects sensitivity, richness, method effort, habitat suitability or a genuine change in environmental conditions.

How should abundance be used without changing the index?

Keep organism counts in a separate abundance or community table while calculating BMWP from family presence as specified. Abundance can reveal dominance and sampling patterns, but it should not multiply tolerance scores. Reporting both layers preserves useful ecological detail without silently redefining the module index.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Write the family list before any total, mark each family once, count the exact taxa entering the sum and divide only after BMWP is checked. Compare score patterns with habitat, effort, chemistry and flow in a separate interpretation step.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 18 of your subjects at King's College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 7SSGN172 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
7SSGN172 · Environmental Field and Lab Techniques for Sustainability - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More King's College London subjects · Microeconomics across all universities