BMAN23000A Chap.3 Investment Decision Rules
Investment Decision Rules
Investment Decision Rules follows Lecture 3, which compares three ways of judging a project and ranks them before teaching them: NPV is always correct, IRR can be incorrect and payback is incorrect. For a standalone project, accept when NPV at the cost of capital is positive.
The IRR is the discount rate that makes NPV zero, where the NPV profile crosses the axis, and the IRR rule accepts when it exceeds the cost of capital. The two rules agree for conventional projects but the IRR fails in three situations the lecture names: delayed investments, where money arrives first and costs follow; cash flows that change sign more than once and give multiple IRRs; and streams with no IRR at all.
Payback ignores the time value of money, the cost of capital and every cash flow after the cutoff. The second half turns to choices between projects. For mutually exclusive projects, comparing IRRs can pick the wrong one because IRR ignores scale, timing and risk; the incremental IRR on the difference in cash flows repairs part of the problem but cannot confirm that either project has positive NPV.
When a resource such as budget or space is limited, the profitability index, NPV per unit of the scarce resource, ranks projects, though it fails if projects do not use the resource fully or several constraints bind.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Standalone projects and the NPV rule
- 02
The IRR rule and the NPV profile
- 03
IRR pitfalls: delayed investment, multiple IRRs, no IRR
- 04
Payback and its four weaknesses
- 05
Mutually exclusive projects and incremental IRR
- 06
Scale, timing and risk differences
- 07
Resource constraints and the profitability index
Worked example · free
Rank two exclusive projects and check the IRR
- 2NPV of S = −400 + 180 × (1 − 1.09^−3)/0.09 = £55.6k; NPV of L = −900 + 380 × (1 − 1.09^−3)/0.09 = £61.9k.
- 1IRRs: S about 16.65%, L about 12.82%, so the IRR comparison favours S.
- 2The incremental cash flows L minus S are −500 now and +200 a year for three years, with an IRR of about 9.7%, above 9%.
- 1Choose L, the higher-NPV project; the incremental IRR agrees because it exceeds the cost of capital.
Key terms
- Payback period
- The time needed for a project's cumulative cash inflows to recover its initial investment.
- Incremental IRR
- The internal rate of return on the difference between two projects' cash flows.
- Profitability index
- A project's NPV divided by the amount of the constrained resource it uses.
- Mutually exclusive projects
- Alternatives where choosing one rules out the others.
Investment Decision Rules FAQ
When can the IRR rule give the wrong answer?
The lecture names three cases: delayed investments, where the inflow comes first and costs follow; cash flows with several sign changes, which can give more than one IRR; and streams that never cross zero, which have no IRR. In each case the NPV rule still works.
Why is payback called incorrect?
Payback ignores the time value of money and the cost of capital, disregards every cash flow after the cutoff and depends on an arbitrary cutoff date. It can reject a project with the highest NPV simply because its largest receipts arrive just after the deadline.
Will I have to solve a difficult IRR in the exam?
The workshop solutions note that an exam will not ask you to solve an IRR that needs a quadratic. Expect to compute simple IRRs, verify a stated IRR by checking that NPV is zero, or explain whether an IRR decision agrees with NPV.
Exam move
Learn the rules through their failures. Start by computing NPV and IRR for a conventional project and plotting NPV against the discount rate: the curve slopes down and crosses the axis at the IRR, which is why the two rules agree. Then reverse the signs of the same cash flows so that money arrives first; the curve now slopes up, and the IRR rule gives the wrong advice. Write both cases on one page.
Next, construct a stream with two sign changes and confirm that it has two IRRs, then one that is positive at every rate and has none. That small set of examples answers most theory questions on IRR. For payback, take a project with a large final cash flow and show that a short cutoff rejects it despite a positive NPV.
Move on to mutually exclusive choices: practise pairs that differ in scale and pairs that differ in timing, compute both NPVs and both IRRs, then the incremental IRR, and state which rule decides and why. Finish with budget problems: rank by profitability index, check whether the chosen set uses the budget fully, and compare feasible combinations by total NPV when it does not.
In written answers, always name the rule you applied and the condition that makes it valid for the case, because that sentence carries much of the explanation.
Working through Investment Decision Rules in BMAN23000A? Sia is AskSia’s AI Finance tutor — ask any BMAN23000A Investment Decision Rules question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how BMAN23000A is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.