The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ACCOUNTING

BMAN30030 Chap.5 Ethics and Accountability in the Profession

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 5 of 13 · BMAN30030

Ethics and Accountability in the Profession

Ethics and Accountability in the Profession moves the question of ethics from the individual accountant to the institutions that set professional expectations. Its core reading analyses a governance crisis at CPA Australia using Robert Michels's iron law of oligarchy, the idea that large organisations concentrate power in leaders who drift away from their members.

The evidence is specific: an extension of director tenure from six to nine years, sharp growth in key management pay, and termination terms for the chief executive that were raised against independent advice and not disclosed to members. Member dissent in 2017 removed the leadership, yet the reforms that followed left much of its authority in place.

The chapter sets this case beside the public-interest commitments professional bodies make in their charters and value statements, and beside contested allegations that a Big Four firm's post-Wirecard reforms stalled under commercial pressure. The aim is to help you judge whether a profession that claims to regulate itself in the public interest is itself accountable.

You will also learn to avoid the common weakness of treating ethics as personal virtue rather than as a question of governance design.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Professional bodies as gatekeepers and trade associations

  • 02

    Michels's iron law of oligarchy applied to accounting

  • 03

    Tenure, pay and disclosure at CPA Australia

  • 04

    Democratic deficit and member dissent

  • 05

    Public-interest claims compared with observed conduct

  • 06

    Commercial pressure and ethics inside audit firm networks

Worked example · free

Spot the governance issues in a members' institute

Q [6 marks]. Marks here are set by this guide for practice and are not drawn from any University paper. A national accounting institute's board extends the maximum term for directors, approves a larger termination payment for its chief executive than an external adviser recommends, and reports neither change to members until a year later. Identify the accountability issues and explain why they matter for a body that claims to serve the public interest.
Each bar shows total key management remuneration at CPA Australia in thousands of Australian dollars, with the red bars marking the period after 2014 when tenurEach bar shows total key management remuneration at CPA Australia in thousands of Australian dollars, with the red bars marking the period after 2014 when tenure and payout terms were widened without members being told.Key management pay, AUD 000s2,77020083,44020103,93820123,82020145,2802016
Each bar shows total key management remuneration at CPA Australia in thousands of Australian dollars, with the red bars marking the period after 2014 when tenure and payout terms were widened without members being told.
  • 1Longer director terms reduce the frequency with which members can renew or replace their leadership.
  • 1Overriding independent advice on executive pay suggests leaders are serving their own interests over those of the membership.
  • 2Delayed disclosure prevents members from questioning decisions while they can still be reversed, creating the core of a democratic deficit.
  • 1Connect to the iron law of oligarchy: governance rules let power concentrate in a detached leadership.
  • 1Explain the public-interest stake: a body that cannot hold its own leaders to account weakens its claim to regulate others.
The changes reduce member control, favour leaders over members and hide decisions from scrutiny, which undermines the institute's claim to regulate in the public interest. The mark allocation shown is an original practice allocation, not a university marking scheme.
Sia tip — For each issue, write the governance rule that allowed it before naming the person who benefited.
Glossary

Key terms

Iron Law of Oligarchy
The proposition that large organisations tend to concentrate power in a leadership that becomes detached from its members.
Democratic Deficit
A gap between members' formal right to govern an organisation and their practical ability to question and influence its leaders.
Public Interest Duty
An obligation a professional body accepts to regulate conduct for the benefit of society, in return for professional privileges.
FAQ

Ethics and Accountability in the Profession FAQ

Why study governance at a professional body in an ethics topic?

Professional bodies set the ethical expectations accountants must meet, and they justify their privileges by claiming to act in the public interest. If such a body cannot hold its own leaders to account, its authority to judge members' conduct is weakened. The CPA Australia case lets you test that claim with concrete evidence on tenure, pay and disclosure.

Does the CPA Australia case prove oligarchy is inevitable?

No. Researchers following Michels treat oligarchy as a common tendency of large organisations rather than a fixed law. In this case member dissent forced the leadership out in 2017, although the later reforms preserved much leadership authority. A strong essay names the conditions that made concentration of power likely instead of claiming it always happens.

How can I make an ethics answer critical rather than descriptive?

Move from mechanism to consequence to limit. Explain which governance rule allowed the conduct, show whose interests suffered, and then state what evidence suggests the pattern is not universal. The published marking criteria reward identifying issues and interpreting them, so each scandal you mention needs an explanation tied to accountability theory.

Study strategy

Exam move

Treat this week as practice in turning a case into an argument about accountability. Start by reading the CPA Australia paper for its structure: background to dissent, escalation, leadership departure and the reforms that followed. Build a short evidence table in your notes with three columns, one for each governance change, one for the date and source page, and one for the accountability problem it created.

Then learn the theory well enough to explain the iron law of oligarchy in two sentences without notes, including the modern reading that treats it as a tendency rather than a certainty.

Next, collect one example from the audit firms, such as the contested claims about reform after Wirecard, and note carefully which statements are allegations and which are findings, because overstating a contested claim is an easy way to lose credibility. Practise answering a short question that asks you to identify issues, since the marking criteria give marks for each correctly identified issue and its interpretation.

Then try a longer essay plan on whether members can hold their institute to account, giving a full paragraph to the strongest counter-argument. Finish each practice answer by checking that every paragraph names a governance mechanism, a consequence and a limit. Link the topic to the oversight chapter, which asks whether outside regulators should take over the policing role.

Keep a running list of the public-interest statements made by the major institutes, quoted accurately with their source, so that you can set a stated value beside observed conduct in a single sentence. Revisit the list near the examination and add any recent governance news you have read.

Working through Ethics and Accountability in the Profession in BMAN30030? Sia is AskSia’s AI Accounting tutor — ask any BMAN30030 Ethics and Accountability in the Profession question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how BMAN30030 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your BMAN30030 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works