The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ACCOUNTING

BMAN30030 Chap.9 Fair Value and Alternative Measurement Bases

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 9 of 13 · BMAN30030

Fair Value and Alternative Measurement Bases

Fair Value and Alternative Measurement Bases asks what a number on the balance sheet is supposed to measure. IFRS 13 gives fair value a precise meaning: an exit price between market participants, ranked by how observable its inputs are. The chapter sets that definition beside the older alternatives that resurface whenever inflation returns: historical cost, current purchasing power and replacement cost.

Each base protects a different idea of capital, so the same year of trading can produce three different profits and three different answers on whether a dividend is safe. The history matters as much as the arithmetic.

UK standard setters experimented with supplementary purchasing power statements and then current cost accounting in the 1970s and 1980s before abandoning both, and the crisis of 2008 reopened the argument over whether marking to market amplifies downturns. Laux and Leuz examine that charge against bank evidence and conclude that relaxing fair value rules in a crisis carries its own dangers.

Expect to calculate, interpret and then defend a position on which base serves users best.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    IFRS 13 exit price and market participant assumptions

  • 02

    Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3 inputs and the discretion each allows

  • 03

    Current purchasing power restatement with index ratios

  • 04

    Replacement cost profit and operating capital maintenance

  • 05

    Dividend advice when profits differ by base

  • 06

    The UK inflation accounting episode from SSAP 7 to SSAP 16

  • 07

    Fair value and the 2008 crisis: claims, evidence and caution

Worked example · free

Test a dividend against replacement cost profit

Q [6 marks]. Marks used below follow this guide's own split and are not the official assessment scheme. Ashby plc reports sales of £800m, historical cost of goods sold of £520m, depreciation of £40m and other costs of £120m. At replacement cost, goods sold would cost £575m and depreciation would be £52m. The board proposes a £75m dividend. Compute both profits and advise whether the payout maintains operating capital.
Each bar is Calder plc's profit under one measurement base and the dashed red line is the £70m dividend.Each bar is Calder plc's profit under one measurement base and the dashed red line is the £70m dividend. Only the replacement cost bar finishes below the line, which is the signal that the payout would erode operating capital. £100m £89.9m £64m Historical cost CPP Replacement cost Dividend £70m Profit for the year
Each bar is Calder plc's profit under one measurement base and the dashed red line is the £70m dividend. Only the replacement cost bar finishes below the line, which is the signal that the payout would erode operating capital.
  • 2Historical cost profit is 800 less 520, 40 and 120, which equals £120m.
  • 2Replacement cost profit is 800 less 575, 52 and 120, which equals £53m, because current input costs replace the historical charges.
  • 2The £75m dividend exceeds replacement cost profit by £22m, so paying it in full would run down the capacity the business must replace, even though historical cost profit appears to cover it.
Historical cost profit is £120m and replacement cost profit is £53m, so the £75m dividend is covered only on the historical base and erodes operating capital by £22m. The mark allocation shown is an original practice allocation, not a university marking scheme.
Sia tip — Write the capital concept beside each profit figure before you advise, for example nominal money capital or operating capacity.
Glossary

Key terms

Exit Price
The amount market participants would pay to buy an asset, or would charge to take over a liability; IFRS 13 frames fair value in these terms.
Fair Value Hierarchy
The three-level ranking of valuation inputs from quoted prices for identical items down to unobservable estimates.
Current Purchasing Power
A measurement base that restates historical amounts into pounds of a common date using a general price index.
Replacement Cost
The current cost of replacing the specific assets a business holds or has consumed.
Capital Maintenance
The concept of capital that must be preserved before any surplus is treated as distributable profit.
FAQ

Fair Value and Alternative Measurement Bases FAQ

What does IFRS 13 mean by fair value?

It is the price that market participants would agree in an orderly sale of an asset, or transfer of a liability, at the measurement date. Because it is market based, the reporting entity's intention to hold or settle does not change the figure, and inputs are graded by observability from Level 1 to Level 3.

Why might a profitable firm still be unable to afford its dividend?

Historical cost profit charges goods and depreciation at old prices. When the firm's own inputs have risen in price, replacement cost profit is lower, and paying dividends above it reduces the physical capacity the business needs to continue trading at its current scale.

Did fair value accounting cause the 2008 banking crisis?

Laux and Leuz find little support for that claim among US banks: most assets were not measured at fair value, rules already allowed departures from distorted prices and reported values tended towards overstatement. They warn that suspending the rules in a crisis would reduce reliability and delay loss recognition.

Study strategy

Exam move

Treat this chapter as two linked skills: calculating under several bases and arguing about which base is fit for purpose. Start by building a one-page restatement template with columns for the historical amount, the index or replacement figure used, and the restated amount.

Practise filling it from different data sets until you choose the right index date automatically: averages for even flows, the purchase quarter for closing inventory and the acquisition index for fixed assets. Then add the interpretive layer. For every set of results write two sentences, one naming the capital concept each base maintains and one advising on distributions.

Past papers pair a calculation of this kind with a discussion of why standard setters rejected these bases decades ago, so read the account of the UK experience with supplementary purchasing power statements and current cost accounting, and list the reasons for withdrawal in your own words.

For the fair value material, learn the exit price definition and the three input levels precisely, then connect Level 3 to discretion and to the extra disclosure it triggers. Finish by preparing a balanced paragraph on the crisis debate using the bank evidence: state the critics' mechanism, the empirical findings and the authors' caution against relaxing the rules.

In a forty-eight hour open-book paper, the time you save comes from having these templates and arguments ready, so your effort goes into applying them to the question's own facts. Finally, rehearse a short closing judgement that names the base you would recommend for dividend decisions in an inflationary year and explains, with your own figures, why the other two bases would mislead the board.

Working through Fair Value and Alternative Measurement Bases in BMAN30030? Sia is AskSia’s AI Accounting tutor — ask any BMAN30030 Fair Value and Alternative Measurement Bases question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how BMAN30030 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your BMAN30030 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works