The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE

EART60061 Chap.5 Error Propagation and Metal Flux Through an Estuary

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
8 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 5 of 10 · EART60061

Error Propagation and Metal Flux Through an Estuary

Error Propagation carries the quality of each measurement through the calculations that combine them. Errors are assumed random and uncorrelated, and they combine in quadrature: absolute errors for sums and differences, fractional errors for products and quotients, and a fractional error multiplied by the exponent for a power. Simple addition would overstate the error at the stated confidence.

The chapter applies the rules to discharge and pollutant loads, carrying units through every step, and then turns to flux through a tidal estuary. Concentration is easy to measure but flux is what predicts concentrations elsewhere, and estuaries make it highly variable through dilution, pH change, adsorption, flocculation, settling, tides, storms and stored metal.

The sampling strategy follows the predictable tidal variation, and the discussion must address the variation it could not sample. A worked consent check shows why a result must be compared with a limit as an interval, and why the confidence level chosen for the error bars can decide the verdict.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Why errors add in quadrature

  • 02

    Absolute errors for sums and differences

  • 03

    Fractional errors for products and powers

  • 04

    Units from discharge to daily load

  • 05

    Concentration versus flux

  • 06

    Processes that make estuary flux variable

  • 07

    Sampling across spring and neap tides

  • 08

    Judging a load against a discharge consent

Worked example · free

Propagate errors from discharge and concentration to a daily load

Q [6 marks]. A river discharges 2.40 plus or minus 0.12 m3/s with a dissolved nickel concentration of 0.050 plus or minus 0.006 mg/L. Find the nickel flux in g/s and the daily load in kg with its error. The weighting is AskSia's practice choice, not a published scheme.
Discharge through an estuary over one tidal cycle, positive when water moves seaward and negative when the flood tide pushes it landward; the spring tide swingsDischarge through an estuary over one tidal cycle, positive when water moves seaward and negative when the flood tide pushes it landward; the spring tide swings far further than the neap, so the same river input produces very different fluxes on the two days.spring tideneap tideabove zero: ebb, seawardbelow zero: flood, landward+40-400612Hours into tidal cycleDischarge (m³/s)
Discharge through an estuary over one tidal cycle, positive when water moves seaward and negative when the flood tide pushes it landward; the spring tide swings far further than the neap, so the same river input produces very different fluxes on the two days.
  • 2Units: m3/s times mg/L gives g/s, because a cubic metre is 1,000 litres and a gram is 1,000 milligrams. Flux = 2.40 times 0.050 = 0.120 g/s.
  • 2Fractional error = square root of (0.12/2.40 squared + 0.006/0.050 squared) = square root of (0.0025 + 0.0144) = 0.130.
  • 1Daily load = 0.120 g/s times 86,400 s = 10,368 g = 10.37 kg; the exact constant keeps the fractional error at 0.130.
  • 1Absolute error = 0.130 times 10.37 = 1.35 kg, so the load is 10.37 plus or minus 1.35 kg per day.
The nickel flux is 0.120 plus or minus 0.016 g/s and the daily load 10.37 plus or minus 1.35 kg. The concentration error dominates, so better analysis would tighten the result more than better flow gauging.
Sia tip — Find which fractional error is largest before you finish; it tells you which measurement to improve and is a quick check on the arithmetic.
Glossary

Key terms

Fractional error
An error divided by the quantity it belongs to, the form in which errors are combined for products and quotients.
Hysteresis
Dependence of a system's response on its history, such as metal flux that depends on how much metal the estuary has stored.
Flocculation
The joining of fine particles into larger aggregates in water of high ionic strength, which makes them more likely to settle.
Conservative behaviour
Transport of a substance that stays in solution, so that its movement simply follows the movement of the water.
Discharge consent
A permitted limit on the mass of a pollutant that may be released, against which a measured load and its error are judged.
Quadrature
Combining independent errors as the square root of the sum of their squares, which keeps the stated confidence level.
FAQ

Error Propagation and Metal Flux Through an Estuary FAQ

Why do errors add in quadrature rather than directly?

Errors have a probability as well as a size. Two independent errors sometimes cancel, so the combined error at the same confidence is smaller than their sum. Adding two 95% errors directly gives a band nearer 97%. Squaring, adding and square rooting keeps the stated confidence.

What happens to the error when I multiply by an exact number?

An exact number such as 86,400 seconds in a day has no error, so the fractional error is unchanged and the absolute error simply scales with the result. A relative error that changes after multiplying by a constant is a sign of an arithmetic mistake.

Why is a negative metal flux not a mistake?

On the sampled spring tide more particulate metal entered the estuary than left it. Because the metal source lies inland, this cannot be the average state; it shows that export happens rarely in large events after stored metal is resuspended, which is evidence of how variable the flux is.

How do I convert discharge and concentration into a mass per day?

Multiply discharge in cubic metres per second by concentration in milligrams per litre to get grams per second, because a cubic metre holds a thousand litres. Multiply by the 86,400 seconds in a day and divide by a thousand for kilograms. Carry the units on every line to catch slips.

Study strategy

Exam move

Work every flux question in two passes: first the numbers with units only, then the errors. Keep a short table of quantity, value, error and fractional error so the quadrature sums are visible. For the estuary material, write the chain of processes from river to sea in your own words and link each one to a sampling decision, ending with the variability that a tidal-cycle design still leaves unsampled.

For practice, recompute a load with one input's error doubled and see how much the final error changes; the input that matters most is the one to measure better.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EART60061 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works