The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE

EART62051 Chap.7 Genetically Modified Crops and the Environment

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 7 of 10 · EART62051

Genetically Modified Crops and the Environment

Genetically Modified Crops and the Environment asks whether GM crops are a threat to the biosphere and shows why the honest answer is conditional. GM cultivation began in the mid to late 1990s, met criticism over health and environmental risk from the start, and has nevertheless spread widely: by 2017 GM crops were grown in two dozen countries on around 190 million hectares, mostly soybean, maize, cotton and canola.

Almost all are modified for pest control, either herbicide tolerance, so weeds can be sprayed in the growing crop, or insect resistance through production of Bt toxin.

The lecture lists six potential environmental concerns: greater fitness leading to invasiveness, effects on non-target organisms, selection for resistant super-pests or super-weeds, knock-on effects of changed crop management, changed cropping patterns, and altered interactions with plant pathogens.

None is automatic; each depends on the gene introduced. Evidence then shows both directions at once. Herbicide-tolerant crops allow reduced tillage, saving fuel, cutting erosion and protecting soil invertebrates, but wider herbicide use reduces plant diversity.

Bt crops reduce insecticide spraying and increase predator insects such as ladybirds, spiders and lacewings, but target pests may evolve resistance.

Gene flow to wild relatives is possible through pollen, yet successful pollination does not guarantee that a modified gene persists, so its importance is debated.

A 2013 European science academies report found no validated evidence that GM crops harm the environment more than other breeding technologies, while more research is still called for. The chapter closes on the distinction between the trait and the intensive farming system it supports.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Global adoption of GM crops

  • 02

    Herbicide tolerance and insect resistance

  • 03

    Six potential environmental impacts

  • 04

    Reduced tillage and soil benefits

  • 05

    Bt crops and predator insects

  • 06

    Gene flow and the state of the evidence

Worked example · free

Weigh the benefit and risk branches of herbicide-tolerant and Bt crops

Q [5 marks]. For an original exam-style prompt, write a balanced assessment of whether Bt maize is good or bad for farm biodiversity, giving one documented benefit, one documented risk and a conclusion. AskSia assigned these practice marks; they are not a University marking scheme.
Herbicide-tolerant and Bt crops each split into a green benefit branch and a red risk branch, showing that reduced tillage or insecticide use comes paired with Herbicide-tolerant and Bt crops each split into a green benefit branch and a red risk branch, showing that reduced tillage or insecticide use comes paired with more herbicide use or a resistance risk. HT crops Bt crops Less tillage More herbicide Less insecticide Toxin resistance risk Soil invertebrates gain Plant diversity falls Predator insects rise Super pests possible
Herbicide-tolerant and Bt crops each split into a green benefit branch and a red risk branch, showing that reduced tillage or insecticide use comes paired with more herbicide use or a resistance risk.
  • 2Benefit: Bt maize controls its target pests selectively, so insecticide spraying falls and predator insects such as ladybirds, spiders and lacewings increase. This allocation is an AskSia practice weighting.
  • 2Risk: if the toxin does not kill every target pest, resistance can evolve and the gains may be lost over time.
  • 1Conclusion: the trait benefits non-target insects now, but its value depends on resistance management and on the wider intensive system it supports.
Bt maize can raise farm insect biodiversity by replacing broad-spectrum spraying with selective control, which also strengthens natural pest control. The benefit is conditional because target pests may evolve resistance, and because the trait sustains intensive farming whose wider impacts remain. These marks are not an official allocation.
Sia tip — Pair every GM benefit with the specific risk attached to the same trait; mixing a herbicide-tolerance benefit with a Bt risk produces an answer that compares two different crops.
Glossary

Key terms

Herbicide tolerance
A GM trait that makes a crop insensitive to a particular herbicide so weeds can be sprayed in the growing crop.
Bt toxin
A bacterial protein produced by insect-resistant GM crops that kills specific classes of insects feeding on them.
Super-weed
A weed that has evolved resistance to a herbicide through repeated selective pressure.
Genetic pollution
The term used for a modified gene passing by cross-pollination into a neighbouring plant or wild relative.
FAQ

Genetically Modified Crops and the Environment FAQ

Are GM crops a widespread or limited approach?

Widespread and growing, in both developed and developing countries. In 2017 they were grown in 24 countries on about 190 million hectares, mainly soybean, maize, cotton and canola.

Why is it hard to call GM impacts positive or negative?

Gains for the farmer may be paid for by the natural processes of the ecosystem. Herbicide-tolerant crops help soil through reduced tillage but lower plant diversity, so the overall judgement depends on which part of biodiversity is considered.

Is gene flow a major threat?

It is possible because most crops have wild relatives, but it is complex. Successful pollination does not mean the modified gene will be maintained and selected in later generations, so the lecture treats the size of the risk as debatable.

Study strategy

Exam move

Build this chapter around balance. Make a two-column summary for each trait, benefits on one side and risks on the other, so that herbicide tolerance shows reduced tillage against lower plant diversity and super-weeds, and Bt crops show fewer insecticide applications and more predator insects against resistance. Memorise the six potential impacts in the order the lecture gives them and attach a one-line explanation to each.

Learn the adoption figures and the main crops, and the four gene-flow risk factors: long-distance pollen dispersal, close relatives flowering at the same time, fertile first-generation hybrids and fertile later generations. Practise writing a short evaluative paragraph that ends with a conditional conclusion rather than a verdict, and rehearse the closing distinction between the trait and the intensive system.

Finally, check your answers to the weekly quiz questions on GM against the lecture reasoning, particularly on why faster growth could make a GM plant invasive.

Working through Genetically Modified Crops and the Environment in EART62051? Sia is AskSia’s AI Environmental Science tutor — ask any EART62051 Genetically Modified Crops and the Environment question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EART62051 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EART62051 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works