The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

ECON10171 Chap.2 Comparative Statics, Shocks and Minimum Wages

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
8 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 2 of 7 · ECON10171

Comparative Statics, Shocks and Minimum Wages

Comparative Statics, Shocks and Minimum Wages asks what happens to a market when something the model held fixed suddenly changes. Lecture 2 calls such an exogenous change a shock and studies it by comparing the equilibrium before and after.

The method is mechanical once the right function is identified: a shock to an input price or a related product price redraws supply, a shock to income or tastes redraws demand, and the size of the horizontal shift equals the partial derivative of quantity with respect to the shocked variable times its change. Solving the new pair of functions gives the new price and quantity, and the signs of those changes are the answer.

The first problem set extends the idea to policy. A minimum wage is a floor on the price of labour that matters only when it sits above the market wage, in which case it creates excess supply of labour. Demand that depends on income lets the equilibrium price be written as a function of income and differentiated, and a per-unit tax on sellers is handled by rewriting supply in terms of the price the firm keeps.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Exogenous shocks and the variables held constant

  • 02

    Parallel shifts of demand and supply curves

  • 03

    Measuring a shift with a partial derivative

  • 04

    Old and new equilibrium compared

  • 05

    Binding and non-binding minimum wages

  • 06

    Excess supply of labour at a wage floor

  • 07

    Equilibrium price as a function of income

  • 08

    Per-unit taxes rewritten into the supply function

Worked example · free

Trace a supply shock from e1 to e2

Q [5 marks]. Demand is Q = 50 − 2p and supply is Q = 2 + 3p − 2w, where w is an input price. Suppose w rises from £6 to £11. Find the original equilibrium, the size and direction of the supply shift, the new equilibrium, and the excess demand at the old price. The marks shown are an original practice weighting, not an official university allocation.
Demand D is fixed while a rise in the input price w from £6 to £11 moves supply from S1 to S2, ten units to the left at every price.Demand D is fixed while a rise in the input price w from £6 to £11 moves supply from S1 to S2, ten units to the left at every price. The equilibrium moves from e1 (Q = 26, p = £12) to e2 (Q = 22, p = £14); at the old price only 16 units would now be offered.Quantity, QPrice, p (£)DS1S2e1e21622261214
Demand D is fixed while a rise in the input price w from £6 to £11 moves supply from S1 to S2, ten units to the left at every price. The equilibrium moves from e1 (Q = 26, p = £12) to e2 (Q = 22, p = £14); at the old price only 16 units would now be offered.
  • 2With w = 6 supply reads Q = 3p − 10; equating it with demand gives 60 = 5p, so e1 is p = £12 with 26 units.
  • 1Since ∂Q/∂w = −2, a £5 rise removes 10 units at every price: supply becomes Q = 3p − 20, a parallel shift to the left.
  • 1Solving 50 − 2p = 3p − 20 gives 70 = 5p, so e2 is p = £14 with 22 units.
  • 1At £12 after the shock, buyers still want 26 units but firms offer only 36 − 20 = 16, an excess demand of 10 that pushes the price up.
The equilibrium moves from £12 and 26 units to £14 and 22 units. Supply shifts ten units left, and the price rises by £2, less than the vertical distance between the two supply lines.
Sia tip — Differentiate quantity with respect to the shocked variable to get the horizontal shift before re-solving the system.
Glossary

Key terms

Exogenous shock
A change in a variable that the model treats as given, such as an input price or income, which redraws one of the curves.
Parallel shift
A move of a linear curve in which the intercept changes but the slope with respect to the good's own price stays the same.
Minimum wage
A legal floor below which the hourly price of labour may not be set.
Binding floor
A price floor set above the market-clearing price, so that it changes the traded quantity and creates excess supply.
Per-unit tax
A fixed charge on every unit sold, which lowers the price a seller keeps by the amount of the charge.
FAQ

Comparative Statics, Shocks and Minimum Wages FAQ

How do I know which curve a shock moves?

Look at which function contains the variable that changed. An input price or the price of an alternative product appears in supply, so only supply moves. Income, tastes or the price of a complement appear in demand. The other curve stays where it was, and the market then moves along it to the new equilibrium.

How far does a linear curve shift after a shock?

Differentiate quantity with respect to the shocked variable and multiply by the size of its change. If supply falls by two units for each pound added to an input price, a five-pound rise removes ten units at every price. Because the price coefficient is untouched, the shift is parallel.

When does a minimum wage create unemployment in this model?

Only when the floor exceeds the wage that clears the labour market. Then firms hire fewer hours than workers offer, and the gap is excess supply of labour. A floor below the market wage is irrelevant: the wage stays where supply meets demand and there is no involuntary unemployment.

How do I show how the equilibrium price responds to income?

Solve the equilibrium condition for the price as an explicit function of income, then differentiate it with respect to income, using the chain rule if a root or power appears. A positive derivative means higher income raises the price, which on a diagram is an outward shift of demand along a fixed supply curve.

How is a per-unit tax on sellers added to a supply function?

Replace the market price in the supply function by the price the seller keeps after paying the tax. With supply 2p and a tax of five pounds, supply becomes 2(p minus 5) and is zero below five pounds. Solve the new system; the buyer price usually rises by less than the tax.

Study strategy

Exam move

Practise comparative statics as a short ritual. Name the shocked variable, find the single function it enters, compute the shift as derivative times change, and solve the new system. Report the change in price and in quantity with signs, then draw both equilibria on one diagram with the unchanged curve labelled.

For policy questions, always compare a floor with the equilibrium before computing quantities, and compute excess supply using both functions at the floor. Finish each session by writing one equilibrium price as a function of income and differentiating it without notes, because that derivation combines algebra, calculus and interpretation in one answer.

A labelled sketch of the wage floor, with the excess supply marked as a horizontal gap, completes the set.

Working through Comparative Statics, Shocks and Minimum Wages in ECON10171? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON10171 Comparative Statics, Shocks and Minimum Wages question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON10171 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your ECON10171 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
ECON10171 · Principles of Microeconomic Theory 1: Consumers Welfare Production and Costs - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More The University of Manchester subjects · Microeconomics across all universities