The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

ECON10171 Chap.7 Solving the Consumer's Problem

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 7 of 7 · ECON10171

Solving the Consumer's Problem

Solving the Consumer's Problem brings preferences and the budget together and finds the bundle a rational consumer actually chooses. The chapter starts from the picture: at an interior optimum the consumer spends her whole income and her indifference curve shares the slope of the budget line, so the marginal rate of substitution equals the marginal rate of transformation.

It then reaches the same two conditions in two algebraic ways. The substitution method uses the budget to eliminate one good and sets a single derivative to zero; the Lagrangian method adds a multiplier for the budget and solves three first-order conditions, which delivers equal marginal utility per pound across goods.

Cobb-Douglas utility is solved through its logarithm, perfect complements at the kink, and perfect substitutes by comparing utility per pound.

The final section explains when a tangency can mislead: corner solutions arise when no tangency exists on the budget line, and with concave preferences a tangency can mark the worst affordable point, which is why convexity matters and why every answer should end with a check of spending and slopes.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Interior and corner solutions

  • 02

    The two conditions: income spent and MRS equal to MRT

  • 03

    The substitution method and its first-order condition

  • 04

    The Lagrangian and its three first-order conditions

  • 05

    Equal marginal utility per pound

  • 06

    Kinked and linear preferences

  • 07

    Necessary versus sufficient conditions and convexity

Worked example · free

Verify the Cobb-Douglas optimum and read the multiplier

Q [6 marks]. Utility is U = q1^0.4 q2^0.6, prices are p1 = £8 and p2 = £6, and income is £240. Show that the bundle (12, 24) satisfies both optimality conditions, find the spending share on each good and find the Lagrange multiplier for the log form 0.4 ln q1 + 0.6 ln q2. The marks shown are an original practice weighting, not an official university allocation.
The shaded triangle is the opportunity set for £240 at prices £8 and £6.The shaded triangle is the opportunity set for £240 at prices £8 and £6. The indifference curve I* touches the budget line only at e = (12, 24), where both slopes equal −4/3, so every other affordable bundle is worse.Good 1, q1Good 2, q2budget lineI*e (12, 24)12302440
The shaded triangle is the opportunity set for £240 at prices £8 and £6. The indifference curve I* touches the budget line only at e = (12, 24), where both slopes equal −4/3, so every other affordable bundle is worse.
  • 1Budget: 8(12) + 6(24) = 96 + 144 = 240, so all income is spent.
  • 2Slopes: MRS = −(0.4/0.6)(24/12) = −4/3 and MRT = −8/6 = −4/3, so the indifference curve touches the budget line at (12, 24).
  • 1Shares: 96/240 = 0.4 of income goes on good 1 and 144/240 = 0.6 on good 2, matching the exponents.
  • 2Multiplier: from 0.4/q1 = 8λ, λ* = 0.4/96 = 1/240; the second condition gives 0.6/144 = 1/240 as well.
The bundle (12, 24) spends the whole £240 and equates the MRS of −4/3 with the price ratio, so it is the optimum. Spending splits 0.4 to 0.6 in line with the exponents, and the last pound on either good adds 1/240 to log utility.
Sia tip — With Cobb-Douglas utility, check the answer by its spending shares: each good's share of income should equal its exponent divided by the sum of the exponents.
Glossary

Key terms

Interior solution
An optimal bundle containing a strictly positive quantity of every good, so it lies on neither axis.
Corner solution
An optimal bundle on an axis, where the consumer buys none of at least one good.
Tangency condition
The requirement that the marginal rate of substitution equal the marginal rate of transformation at the chosen bundle.
First-order condition
An equation obtained by setting a derivative of the objective to zero, necessary for an interior optimum.
FAQ

Solving the Consumer's Problem FAQ

When can I assume the consumer spends all of her income?

Under strict monotonicity more of a good is always better, so any bundle that leaves money unspent is beaten by one on the budget line. That is why the lecture replaces the inequality constraint with an equality before using calculus. State the assumption explicitly at the start of a written answer.

Which method should I use in the exam: substitution or Lagrangian?

Both reach the same tangency condition, so either earns the bundle if the working is complete. The Lagrangian is the method the lecture favours because it generalises to more goods and constraints, and a problem set asks for it by name. If a question specifies a method, use that one and show each first-order condition.

What does the Lagrange multiplier tell me?

At the optimum the multiplier equals each good's marginal utility divided by its price, so it is the extra utility from the last pound spent on any good. Its numerical value depends on which utility representation you maximise, so compare it only within one representation, but the optimal bundle is the same for all of them.

How do I spot a corner solution?

Look for preferences that cannot produce a tangency with both quantities positive: linear utility where one good gives more utility per pound, or concave preferences. Compare the utility at the two ends of the budget line directly. For perfect complements there is no tangency either, but the answer sits at the kink rather than on an axis.

Why is MRS equal to MRT not always enough?

The condition only says the slopes match, which is necessary for an interior optimum but not sufficient. With concave indifference curves a matching slope can be the least preferred point on the budget line. When curves are convex, with a diminishing MRS in size, the condition does identify the best affordable bundle.

Study strategy

Exam move

Practise the solution routine until the order is automatic: state that income is fully spent, write the Lagrangian or substitute the budget, derive the conditions, divide to eliminate the multiplier, substitute into the budget, then check spending and the tangency. Do it for Cobb-Douglas utilities with different exponents, using logarithms each time, and note how the spending shares follow the exponents.

Then work the special cases separately: a min-form utility solved at the kink and a linear utility solved by comparing utility per pound. For every solution draw the diagram with intercepts and the labelled optimum, and finish by asking whether the preferences are convex enough for the condition to be trusted.

Working through Solving the Consumer's Problem in ECON10171? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON10171 Solving the Consumer's Problem question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON10171 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your ECON10171 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
ECON10171 · Principles of Microeconomic Theory 1: Consumers Welfare Production and Costs - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More The University of Manchester subjects · Microeconomics across all universities