ECON10171 Chap.4 Specific Taxes and Tax Incidence
Specific Taxes and Tax Incidence
Specific Taxes and Tax Incidence asks who really carries a tax that the law collects from sellers. A specific tax adds a fixed amount per unit, so a firm facing market price p keeps only p − t and its supply at that price becomes S(p − t). The market then settles where demand equals this shifted supply, and the price buyers pay rises by less than the full tax whenever both sides of the market can respond.
Differentiating the equilibrium condition with respect to the tax gives the lecture's incidence result: the buyer price moves by η/(η − ε) while the seller's share is −ε/(η − ε), where ε is the price elasticity of demand and η that of supply. The two shares always sum to one. The less responsive side bears more, so inelastic demand pushes the burden onto households even though firms hand the money to the government.
The chapter derives the formula, confirms it on a solved linear market where it holds exactly, and practises the verbal argument that exposes claims about who is harmed.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Specific taxes collected per unit sold
- 02
Supply rewritten in the price the firm keeps
- 03
New equilibrium from demand equal to taxed supply
- 04
Differentiating the equilibrium condition
- 05
Incidence on buyers and on sellers
- 06
Why the less elastic side bears more
- 07
Limiting cases of perfectly elastic and inelastic supply
Worked example · free
Split a £5 per-unit tax between buyers and sellers
- 1Without the tax, 90 − 3p = 2p − 10 gives 100 = 5p, so the market clears at £20 with 30 units.
- 2Sellers keep p − 5, so taxed supply is 2(p − 5) − 10 = 2p − 20. Equating 90 − 3p with 2p − 20 gives 110 = 5p: buyers pay £22 and 24 units trade.
- 1Sellers keep £22 − £5 = £17. Buyers pay £2 more and sellers keep £3 less, so the shares are 0.4 and 0.6 of the tax.
- 2At the untaxed point ε = −3(20/30) = −2 and η = 2(20/30) = 4/3, so η/(η − ε) = 0.4 and −ε/(η − ε) = 0.6, exact because both lines are straight.
Key terms
- Specific tax
- A tax charged as a fixed amount of money on each unit of a good that is sold.
- Tax wedge
- The gap between the price buyers pay and the price sellers keep, equal to the per-unit tax.
- Incidence on consumers
- The rise in the market price per unit increase in the tax, written dp/dt.
- Incidence on firms
- The change in the price sellers keep per unit increase in the tax, written d(p − t)/dt and negative for normal slopes.
Specific Taxes and Tax Incidence FAQ
If the tax is collected from firms, why do consumers pay any of it?
Once firms keep only the price minus the tax, they offer less at every market price, and the resulting shortage at the old price bids the price up. Buyers end up paying part of the tax through that higher price. The legal duty to remit the money says nothing about where the economic burden finally lands.
How do elasticities decide who bears more of a tax?
The buyer share is the supply elasticity divided by the supply elasticity minus the demand elasticity. When demand is inelastic, households keep buying almost the same amount, so the price can rise a lot and they bear most of the tax. With very elastic demand, firms must absorb more because buyers would otherwise walk away.
Is the incidence formula exact or approximate?
It comes from differentiating the equilibrium condition and treating p − t as close to p, so for curved demand or supply it is an approximation that works best for a small tax. When both demand and supply are straight lines, the slopes are constant and the formula gives the exact split for any size of tax.
What happens when supply is perfectly elastic or perfectly inelastic?
With perfectly elastic supply, firms will not accept any lower price, so buyers pay the whole tax and the consumer price rises by the full amount. With perfectly inelastic supply, quantity cannot change, the consumer price stays put and sellers absorb everything. These extremes are useful sanity checks for any answer.
How should I set out a tax question in a written answer?
Solve the untaxed market first. Then rewrite supply using the price firms keep, note where that supply is zero, and solve the new equilibrium, discarding any root without economic meaning. Report the new buyer price, the seller price and quantity, then finish with a sentence naming which side carries the larger burden and why.
Exam move
Learn the derivation rather than the result. Starting from demand equal to supply evaluated at the price firms keep, differentiate with respect to the tax, collect the terms in dp/dt and convert slopes to elasticities by multiplying by price over quantity. Repeat it from a blank page until it takes four minutes.
Then practise on pairs of linear markets: solve each one directly, compute both price changes, and check them against the formula at the untaxed point. Finish with quick verbal checks: perfectly elastic supply, perfectly inelastic demand, and a policymaker's claim that a tax on firms spares households.
Working through Specific Taxes and Tax Incidence in ECON10171? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON10171 Specific Taxes and Tax Incidence question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON10171 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.