The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT

FBTE34511 Chap.6 Digital Technology Appraisal

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 6 of 8 · FBTE34511

Digital Technology Appraisal

Digital Technology Appraisal evaluates Digital Product Passports and one additional technology inside the operating system they support. The chapter begins with a named actor and decision, then examines required data, identity, interoperability, benefits, limitations, burden, governance and failure. Digital visibility is not an outcome by itself.

A passport may preserve material and repair information, but recovery still depends on collection, capacity and accepted routes. A critical comparison applies common criteria to both options and ends with a conditional recommendation, including the pilot evidence required before wider adoption.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Digital Product Passports

  • 02

    Decision use cases

  • 03

    Data quality

  • 04

    Persistent identity

  • 05

    Interoperability

  • 06

    Technology limits

  • 07

    Data governance

Worked example · free

Compare a passport with condition sensors

Q [4 marks]. Durable transport cases are discarded because identity and handling history are unclear. Decide how the technologies should be staged. The displayed marks are an original AskSia practice allocation, not a University marking scheme.
The stacked appraisal begins with a defined use case, adds data and interoperability, weighs benefits and limits, and reaches a governed evidence claim.The stacked appraisal begins with a defined use case, adds data and interoperability, weighs benefits and limits, and reaches a governed evidence claim.use case and decisiondata, identity and interoperabilitybenefits, limits and affected actorsgovernance and evidence
The stacked appraisal begins with a defined use case, adds data and interoperability, weighs benefits and limits, and reaches a governed evidence claim.
  • 1Use the passport for identity, material, repair and route information.
  • 1Use sensors only where condition evidence changes inspection.
  • 1Agree identifiers, exchanged fields and correction ownership.
  • 1Pilot the core record first and add sensors after a decision benefit is shown.
The staged choice matches the passport to the baseline information gap and reserves sensing for routes where its additional evidence changes action.
Sia tip — For every field, name the actor who uses it and the decision it changes.
Glossary

Key terms

Data provenance
Information about where data originated, how it was produced and who is accountable for it.
Persistent identifier
A durable reference that links an item to records across time and organisational hand-offs.
Exception route
A defined process for cases that cannot follow the standard digital or operational workflow.
FAQ

Digital Technology Appraisal FAQ

What should a Digital Product Passport contain?

Include the minimum reliable data required by named actors and decisions, such as identity, composition, care, repair or end-of-life information. Avoid an unlimited lifecycle data wish list without clear purpose, ownership or maintenance.

How do I compare two different technologies?

Use common criteria drawn from the problem and stakeholder analysis: decision benefit, evidence quality, integration, cost or workload, accessibility, failure, governance and the conditions required for value. Different functions can still be compared through their contribution to the operating goal.

Does more traceability guarantee circularity?

No. Traceability can reduce uncertainty at a hand-off, but circularity also needs collection, processing, standards, capacity and a viable destination. State the causal chain rather than attributing the whole outcome to the digital record.

How should vendor lock-in affect the appraisal?

Separate the required service from a named product. Specify minimum functions, data portability, audit access, correction processes, interface continuity, exit terms and the evidence a supplier must provide. Consider what happens if pricing changes, an interface closes or an identifier is no longer supported.

A defensible recommendation preserves the client's ability to migrate while retaining necessary records and service continuity. Treat lock-in as both a governance and operational risk, and include a small exit rehearsal in the pilot rather than accepting a contractual promise as sufficient evidence.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Build one appraisal table for both technologies. Start with the user and decision, then list the information or capability required. Trace data origin, verification, update, access and exception handling. Compare benefits with technical, organisational and human limits. Add interoperability and governance questions, including minimisation, access rights, correction and retention.

Write a counter-case in which the technology adds work without changing the decision. Finish with a preferred configuration, conditions, limitations and a pilot gate. This structure prevents feature description from replacing critical evaluation. Begin with a use-case sentence containing an actor, evidence and choice. A repairer uses verified composition and history to decide whether an item follows repair or another route.

This sentence prevents broad claims about transparency from substituting for value. For the Digital Product Passport, list only fields that support named decisions. Record where each field originates, who can verify and change it, how the identifier persists and what happens when information is missing or disputed. Repeat the exercise for the second technology.

Apply the same comparison headings even when capabilities differ: decision contribution, evidence quality, integration, workload, accessibility, failure, governance and cost or dependency. Examine complementarity without assuming that more technology is better.

If sensing adds condition evidence to a passport, show which uncertain inspection decision improves and whether the benefit warrants devices, maintenance and data volume. Draw the interoperability path across partners. Include identifier mapping, exchanged fields, permissions, update responsibility and a manual exception. Test organisational readiness separately from technical performance.

Roles, incentives, training and contracts can prevent a functioning tool from producing value. Build governance around purpose limitation, data minimisation, access, correction, retention, security and accountability. Consider whether worker or customer data can be inferred even if that was not the stated purpose. Write a failure paragraph in which records become stale, identifiers detach or partners cannot integrate.

Explain how the service continues safely and what evidence triggers revision. End with staged adoption. The baseline capability should be proved first, and optional complexity added only when a clear decision benefit is demonstrated. This yields a critical recommendation rather than a feature catalogue.

Working through Digital Technology Appraisal in FBTE34511? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any FBTE34511 Digital Technology Appraisal question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how FBTE34511 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your FBTE34511 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works