The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF MARKETING

FBTE61411 Chap.6 The Ethical Consumption Gap

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 6 of 11 · FBTE61411

The Ethical Consumption Gap

The Ethical Consumption Gap examines why consumers who say they care about ethics so often buy as if they do not. The ethics lecture introduces the gap and its usual explanations, price, convenience and habit, and uses Patagonia's campaign urging customers to buy less to show that even committed brands face it. Three readings take the debate further.

Interviews across eight countries find that consumers rarely see the issues as theirs and justify purchases through economic rationalisation, dependence on institutions or acceptance of harm as part of development. A conceptual critique argues that the gap is ideology: it keeps responsibility with the individual shopper and away from the structures of capitalist consumption.

A study of designer fashion customers treats ethics as ongoing engagement with how clothes are bought and worn. The chapter shows how to set these lenses against each other, repairs a one-sided paragraph, and points to the theoretical, practical and societal implications the module workbook models on a closely related idea, the ethical consumption cap.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The intention and behaviour gap

  • 02

    Price, convenience and habit

  • 03

    Justifications consumers give

  • 04

    The gap as ideology

  • 05

    Ethics as engagement with clothing

  • 06

    Patagonia and ethical branding

Worked example · free

Compare two explanations of the gap

Q [6 marks]. A review must explain why shoppers who value ethics still buy fast fashion. Compare the account-based explanation from the eight-country interview study with the ideological critique, and conclude which better supports an implications section. The step weighting below is an AskSia practice allocation, not a university marking scheme.
The two bars compare the share of UK consumers stating ethical intentions with the ethical market’s share of relevant spending, and the three boxes below show cThe two bars compare the share of UK consumers stating ethical intentions with the ethical market’s share of relevant spending, and the three boxes below show competing ways of explaining the gap between them. the gap Stated intentions Ethical spend 30% 4% Blame the shopper Consumer accounts Gap as ideology
The two bars compare the share of UK consumers stating ethical intentions with the ethical market’s share of relevant spending, and the three boxes below show competing ways of explaining the gap between them.
  • 2Summarise the account view: consumers justify purchases by seeking value for money, trusting institutions to ban harm, or accepting harm as part of development.
  • 2Summarise the ideological view: the gap keeps responsibility on individual shoppers and diverts attention from producers and policy.
  • 1Compare: the first explains individual reasoning; the second questions whether individual reasoning is the right focus at all.
  • 1Conclude: the ideological view yields stronger implications for policy and practice, while the account view still informs communication.
Both explanations help, but the ideological critique supports richer implications because it moves responsibility from the shopper to firms and regulators, while the account view explains the reasoning that brands must still address.
Sia tip — End a comparison with a judgement. Two summaries placed side by side without a verdict stay in the descriptive band.
Glossary

Key terms

Economic rationalisation
A justification in which a consumer puts value for money ahead of ethical concerns.
Institutional dependency
A justification that leaves ethical responsibility to government and other institutions to regulate what is sold.
Developmental realism
A justification that treats some unethical business practice as an unavoidable stage of economic development.
Consumer sovereignty
The belief that consumers hold the power to direct markets through the choices they make.
FAQ

The Ethical Consumption Gap FAQ

Why do people who care about ethics still buy fast fashion?

The lecture names price, convenience and habit. Interview research across eight countries adds that most people cared little about the issues put to them, and in all cases informants justified the inconsistency by seeking value, trusting regulators or accepting harm as part of development. A strong paper weighs these explanations rather than listing them.

What does it mean to call the gap an ideology?

Carrington, Zwick and Neville argue that the gap keeps faith in a sovereign consumer who can fix markets by choosing well. That belief shifts responsibility from firms and policy onto individuals, so they call for research on how marketing constructs the gap instead of on shopper failings.

Is giving shoppers more information the answer?

The eight-country interview study suggests not. Its authors conclude that information and moral appeals are unlikely to change behaviour, and they float emotional appeals and regulation as alternatives. Use that finding to challenge any recommendation that rests only on awareness campaigns.

How does the Patagonia case fit the debate?

The lecture uses Patagonia's campaign urging customers to buy less as an example of ethical branding that still meets the gap, and notes criticism of its refusal to disclose production volumes. It works as evidence that brand messaging alone does not close the gap.

Can the gap be a topic for the research review?

Yes. The lecture lists the gap as one of four inclusion and ethics topics, and the workbook's worked implications example builds on a closely related idea. Choose one lens, review the debate around it and finish with implications for theory, practice and society.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Read the conceptual critique first, slowly, and write down its two claims about what the gap does ideologically. Then read the interview study and list its three justifications with one fashion example of each from your own experience. Set the two readings side by side and write a short paragraph on where they agree and where they part. Add the designer fashion study as a third view that redefines ethics itself.

When you plan a paper, decide which lens frames the literature review and which one tests it, and use the workbook's insight, consequence and response layout to draft implications before you write the introduction. Keep a note of the publication details printed on each article, since the reading list and the papers do not always agree.

Working through The Ethical Consumption Gap in FBTE61411? Sia is AskSia’s AI Marketing tutor — ask any FBTE61411 The Ethical Consumption Gap question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how FBTE61411 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your FBTE61411 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works