The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT

FBTE64441 Chap.2 Literature Search and Review

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 2 of 7 · FBTE64441

Literature Search and Review

Literature Search and Review builds a transparent route from a broad field to a defensible body of evidence. The reviewer defines the problem, selects a review type, sets scope, translates the question into concept blocks, searches appropriate sources, screens against explicit eligibility rules and records study details in an evidence matrix.

Relevance and quality remain separate judgments: a directly relevant study may have important design limits, while a high-quality paper about another intervention may belong only in background theory. The chapter shows how search revisions, exclusion reasons and structured reading protect the later synthesis from selective memory and confirmation bias.

It also distinguishes a narrative review from a systematic promise so the label matches the process actually completed.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Review purpose and scope

  • 02

    Narrative and systematic approaches

  • 03

    Concept blocks and search terms

  • 04

    Eligibility and exclusion reasons

  • 05

    Evidence matrices and structured reading

  • 06

    Transparent search revision

Worked example · free

Design a transparent literature search

Q [7 marks]. Build a search plan for how fashion-rental services shape perceptions of luxury-brand exclusivity. The marks shown are not a published university assessment scheme.
The funnel narrows a broad field into a scoped question, selected evidence and synthesis, while the side arrow requires each exclusion and grouping decision to The funnel narrows a broad field into a scoped question, selected evidence and synthesis, while the side arrow requires each exclusion and grouping decision to be documented. Broad field Scoped question Selected evidence Synthesis document each decision
The funnel narrows a broad field into a scoped question, selected evidence and synthesis, while the side arrow requires each exclusion and grouping decision to be documented.
  • 2Create concept blocks for access-based services, luxury exclusivity and consumer perception.
  • 2Set justified field, publication, date and method boundaries rather than limits based only on convenience.
  • 1Screen consistently and record one reason for each full-text exclusion.
  • 2Extract context, sample, method, finding, limitation and contribution before thematic synthesis.
The plan uses linked concept blocks, justified eligibility rules, documented screening and a structured evidence matrix. It reports imbalances in the evidence rather than forcing a preferred story. The weighting is original practice guidance.
Sia tip — Write one sentence for relevance and a separate sentence for confidence in the design.
Glossary

Key terms

Eligibility criterion
A prespecified rule that determines whether a source belongs in the reviewed evidence body.
Narrative review
A critical interpretive review that does not claim exhaustive systematic identification and screening.
Evidence matrix
A structured record of study context, method, findings, limitations and relevance to the review question.
FAQ

Literature Search and Review FAQ

How do I choose literature-review boundaries?

Start from the research problem and identify the fields, populations, constructs, periods and evidence types needed to answer it. Explain each limit. A database or date restriction is defensible when it follows the purpose, not merely because it makes the search easier.

Can I exclude a study because I disagree with it?

No. Eligibility depends on relevance to the stated question and rules, not agreement with the preferred conclusion. Include relevant counter-evidence, appraise its method and explain how much weight its design deserves within the synthesis.

What belongs in an evidence matrix?

Record the research problem, theoretical perspective, context, sample, design, collection, analysis, principal finding, limitation, reviewer appraisal and contribution to the current question. Keep author claims separate from your judgment so the analytical trail remains visible.

How should search terms be organised?

Build a concept block for each indispensable idea, place synonyms and spelling variants within blocks, then connect the blocks according to the database syntax. Test whether known relevant studies are retrieved. A long untested string is not automatically systematic because it may encode unnoticed exclusions.

Why record full-text exclusion reasons?

A single explicit reason for each excluded full text makes the boundary auditable and prevents criteria drifting toward a preferred conclusion. Reasons should correspond to the protocol, such as an ineligible population or outcome, rather than vague labels like irrelevant or poor quality.

How do I distinguish searching from synthesising?

Searching identifies evidence under declared retrieval and eligibility rules. Synthesis then compares what the included studies mean, how their designs differ and how confidently their findings can be combined. Reporting many database hits cannot compensate for an analysis that merely lists one article after another.

What should I do with duplicate records?

Remove duplicate database records before screening while retaining a reproducible count of what changed. If several publications report the same underlying study, link them during extraction so one participant sample is not mistaken for several independent pieces of evidence in the synthesis.

When is a search sufficiently complete?

Completeness is judged against the review purpose and declared boundaries, not by claiming that every publication was found. Use suitable databases, transparent terms, citation checking where justified and a recorded final search date. Then acknowledge evidence types or contexts the strategy may have missed.

Study strategy

Exam move

Begin with the review question and convert it into concept blocks. Build synonym lists without making them so broad that the results lose the focal relationship. Record databases, dates, fields and limits at the time of searching. During screening, apply explicit eligibility criteria and use consistent full-text exclusion reasons such as wrong population, phenomenon, outcome or publication type.

Maintain a matrix that captures what each study asked, who or what it observed, how evidence was collected and analysed, what it found and what limits the inference. Separate relevance from quality: a weak relevant study may still inform a cautious claim, while an excellent adjacent study may provide background only. After several studies are recorded, sort them by themes, methods or contexts that reveal an argument.

Test whether apparent disagreement comes from different definitions, samples or time horizons. Practise writing one claim-led paragraph with supportive evidence, a counter-case and a design explanation. Finish by documenting search revisions so the final review explains how the evidence body was formed and does not imply exhaustive coverage when the process was selective.

Working through Literature Search and Review in FBTE64441? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any FBTE64441 Literature Search and Review question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how FBTE64441 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your FBTE64441 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works