University College London · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

BCPM0001 Chap.10 Productivity in Construction

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 10 of 10 · BCPM0001

Productivity in Construction

Productivity in Construction closes the module by asking whether the industry's reputation for poor productivity survives careful measurement. The chapter separates physical from value productivity, labour productivity from total factor productivity, and shows how unit labour cost links pay to output.

Because value productivity depends on a price index, a worked example shows the same firm's growth changing from about 1% to about 5% when the deflator changes.

International evidence from the Pearce report, drawing on O'Mahoney and de Boer (2002), finds that in 1999 France and Germany were only 8% and 1% ahead of the UK in construction output per hour, gaps probably within the margin of error, while the manufacturing gaps were far larger. Growth rates from 1973 to 1995 favoured the UK, though they slowed later, and total factor productivity looked remarkably good.

Low recorded research spending and qualification gaps qualify that picture. The chapter connects these findings to sector boundaries, subcontracting and whole-life value from earlier weeks.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Output per unit of input: physical and value productivity

  • 02

    Labour productivity, total factor productivity and unit labour cost

  • 03

    Price deflators and real output

  • 04

    International productivity levels in 1999

  • 05

    Productivity growth before and after 1995

  • 06

    Research spending, skills and the wider productivity debate

Worked example · free

Compare construction and manufacturing productivity gaps in 1999

Q [5 marks]. With the UK set at 100, output per hour worked in 1999 was 114 in the United States, 108 in France and 101 in Germany for construction, and 155, 132 and 129 for manufacturing. Calculate each country's lead over the UK in both sectors and explain what the comparison implies for claims that UK construction is exceptionally unproductive. The marks shown are an original practice allocation, not an official UCL marking scheme.
Bars compare construction and manufacturing output per hour worked in 1999 in the United States, France and Germany, with the UK set at 100.Bars compare construction and manufacturing output per hour worked in 1999 in the United States, France and Germany, with the UK set at 100. The construction gaps (114, 108, 101) are far smaller than the manufacturing gaps (155, 132, 129), so the UK trails mainly in manufacturing.UK = 100ConstructionManufacturing114155United States108132France101129Germany
Bars compare construction and manufacturing output per hour worked in 1999 in the United States, France and Germany, with the UK set at 100. The construction gaps (114, 108, 101) are far smaller than the manufacturing gaps (155, 132, 129), so the UK trails mainly in manufacturing.
  • 1Construction leads over the UK are 14% for the United States, 8% for France and 1% for Germany.
  • 1Manufacturing leads are 55%, 32% and 29% respectively.
  • 1The largest construction gap, 14%, is smaller than the smallest manufacturing gap, 29%.
  • 2The French and German construction gaps are small enough to lie within the margin of error of the statistics, so UK construction is not an international outlier, although construction remains less productive than manufacturing.
In construction the comparison countries are 14%, 8% and 1% higher than the UK, against 55%, 32% and 29% higher in manufacturing. The evidence rejects the claim that UK construction is exceptionally unproductive by international standards, while leaving in place the general point, made by Pearce, that construction has low productivity relative to manufacturing. This allocation is an original study aid, not an official UCL marking scheme.
Sia tip — Say whether a productivity comparison runs across countries or across sectors before drawing a conclusion from it.
Glossary

Key terms

Value productivity
Real value added produced per unit of input, which depends on how output prices are deflated.
Physical productivity
Units of physical work completed per hour, such as square metres of brickwork laid.
Unit labour cost
Labour cost incurred for each unit of real output produced.
Price deflator
An index used to convert nominal values into real values by removing price change.
FAQ

Productivity in Construction FAQ

Is UK construction really less productive than in other countries?

Evidence for 1999 suggests not by much. Output per hour in construction was only 8% higher in France and 1% higher in Germany, gaps the Pearce report treats as probably within statistical error, while the United States led by 14%. In manufacturing, by contrast, the three comparison countries were between 29% and 55% higher than the UK.

Why does the price deflator matter so much?

Productivity in value terms uses real output, which is nominal value added divided by a price index. If the construction price index overstates true price rises, for example by missing quality improvements, real output and productivity growth are understated. Two deflators can turn the same firm's 1% growth into 5%.

What is the difference between labour productivity and total factor productivity?

Labour productivity divides output by hours or workers, so it rises when firms add machinery. Total factor productivity compares output with labour and capital combined and is used as a rough measure of technical progress. The Pearce report calls the UK record good rather than bad: total factor productivity in 1999 was close to the US and France, although 1999 labour productivity levels still trailed all three comparators.

How does unit labour cost relate to productivity?

Unit labour cost is the wage bill divided by real output. It rises when pay grows faster than productivity, which squeezes margins unless prices rise. Because it uses real output, any error in the price deflator flows straight into unit labour cost as well.

How should productivity appear in the essay?

Treat it as a measurement question as well as a performance question. Name the output measure, the input measure, the deflator and the comparison being made, then use evidence on skills, research spending and capital intensity to explain whatever gap remains.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Begin by writing one-line definitions of physical productivity, value productivity, labour productivity, total factor productivity and unit labour cost, each with its numerator and denominator. Rework the deflator example with your own numbers until you can predict which way the answer moves.

Copy the 1999 level table and the growth rates into your evidence table and practise one sentence for each that states the comparison type. Read Ruddock and Ruddock (2011) or Abdel-Wahab and Vogl (2011) to see whether later data change the picture. Finally, draft an essay outline on whether the productivity problem is real or partly statistical, linking at least two earlier weeks to the argument.

Keep the deflator, year and source next to every productivity figure you quote.

Working through Productivity in Construction in BCPM0001? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any BCPM0001 Productivity in Construction question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how BCPM0001 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your BCPM0001 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works