University College London · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

BCPM0001 Chap.7 Risk, Uncertainty and Project Outcomes

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 7 of 10 · BCPM0001

Risk, Uncertainty and Project Outcomes

Risk, Uncertainty and Project Outcomes covers the Week 7 distinction between risk, where outcomes and their likelihoods can be estimated, and uncertainty, where they cannot, and applies it to the specific risk carried by construction projects.

Recorded project outcomes are lopsided: most schemes overrun modestly, a few finish under budget and a small number overrun by a very large margin, so averages understate the danger.

The chapter sets Hirschman's hiding hand, which credits planners' ingenuity with rescuing optimistic projects, against Flyvbjerg and Sunstein's malevolent hiding hand and the planning fallacy, and places Taleb's black swan and Aven's critique within a risk assessment.

Decision trees and expected values show how a contractor compares a fixed-price tender with a cost-reimbursable contract, and a break-even probability shows when that choice would flip. The working habit is to classify an exposure before pricing it, to treat every probability as an estimate with an author, and to look at the size of a possible loss as well as its expected value.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Risk against uncertainty in standard economics

  • 02

    Right-skewed distributions of project cost overruns

  • 03

    The hiding hand and the planning fallacy

  • 04

    Black swans in a construction risk context

  • 05

    Decision trees, expected value and break-even probabilities

  • 06

    Allocating project risk through the choice of contract

Worked example · free

Compare fixed price and cost plus fee with a decision tree

Q [6 marks]. A contractor can tender a fixed price or accept cost plus fee. Under the fixed price, good ground (probability 0.7) gives £0.8m profit and poor ground (probability 0.3) gives a £1.2m loss; cost plus fee gives £0.3m profit whatever the ground. Find each expected value and the probability of poor ground at which the two contracts are equally attractive. The marks shown are an original practice allocation, not an official UCL marking scheme.
The square is the contractor's choice and the circle is the ground condition it cannot control.The square is the contractor's choice and the circle is the ground condition it cannot control. Fixed price pays £0.8m profit with good ground (0.7) or a £1.2m loss with poor ground (0.3), an expected £0.20m against a certain £0.3m from cost plus fee.Fixed priceCost plus feeGood ground 0.7Poor ground 0.3£0.8m profit£1.2m lossEV £0.20m£0.3m profitEV £0.30m
The square is the contractor's choice and the circle is the ground condition it cannot control. Fixed price pays £0.8m profit with good ground (0.7) or a £1.2m loss with poor ground (0.3), an expected £0.20m against a certain £0.3m from cost plus fee.
  • 2Fixed price: 0.7 x 0.8 = 0.56 and 0.3 x (minus 1.2) = minus 0.36, so the expected value is £0.20m.
  • 1Cost plus fee: the £0.3m is earned in both states, so the expected value is £0.30m.
  • 2Break-even: 0.8(1 minus p) minus 1.2p = 0.3, so 0.8 minus 2p = 0.3 and p = 0.25.
  • 1Judgement: at p = 0.3 cost plus fee is preferred, and a firm with thin reserves should also weigh the £1.2m possible loss.
Fixed price has an expected value of £0.20m and cost plus fee £0.30m, so cost plus fee is preferred at a 0.3 chance of poor ground. Fixed price only wins if that chance falls below 0.25. This mark allocation is an original study aid, not an official UCL marking scheme.
Sia tip — Solve for the break-even probability, then ask whether a site survey could move the estimate across it.
Glossary

Key terms

Uncertainty
A situation in which neither the full set of outcomes nor their probabilities can be known in advance.
Hiding hand
Hirschman's principle that underestimated difficulties are often offset by underestimated ingenuity in solving them.
Expected value
The probability-weighted average of the payoffs that can follow a decision.
FAQ

Risk, Uncertainty and Project Outcomes FAQ

Is risk the same thing as uncertainty?

No. Risk describes outcomes whose likelihood can be estimated from comparable cases, such as lost days to rain, so it can be priced or insured. Uncertainty covers events nobody can list or assign a frequency to in advance, such as a long collapse in demand, so it calls for flexibility, reserves and the option to stop.

Why do construction cost overruns not average out?

Their distribution is skewed to the right. Many projects overrun a little and a few overrun enormously, while underruns are small and rare. A handful of extreme jobs therefore pull the mean well above the median, and a contingency set at the typical overrun leaves the firm exposed to the cases that matter most.

What is the malevolent hiding hand?

It is Flyvbjerg and Sunstein's reply to Hirschman. They argue that planners usually underestimate costs and overestimate benefits without any compensating creativity, so the optimism that gets projects approved leads to overruns and disappointing returns, the planning fallacy on a large scale.

When should a contractor prefer cost plus fee?

When the chance of a costly event is high enough that the fixed-price expected value falls below the certain fee, or when one bad outcome could exceed the firm's reserves. The break-even probability gives the first test, and the size of the worst loss relative to capital gives the second.

How should a weekly response use a black swan?

Use it carefully. Ask whether the damaging event came from a known but fat-tailed distribution that better records would have revealed, or from something genuinely unforeseeable. Aven's discussion helps separate the two, and the distinction decides whether the lesson is better estimation or more resilient contracts.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Start by writing one-line definitions of risk and uncertainty and sorting five construction exposures of your own into each. Then redraw the decision tree from memory, compute both expected values and derive the break-even probability without notes. Practise reading a skewed sample: list twenty invented overruns, find the median and the mean, and explain the gap in two sentences.

For the readings, write a short paragraph setting Hirschman against Flyvbjerg and Sunstein, and decide which you find more persuasive for large public projects. In each weekly response, attach a source to every probability you use and say who would bear the loss if it proved wrong. Before the group presentation, test your tree on a classmate by changing one probability and asking whether they can predict the new decision.

Working through Risk, Uncertainty and Project Outcomes in BCPM0001? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any BCPM0001 Risk, Uncertainty and Project Outcomes question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how BCPM0001 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your BCPM0001 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works