University College London · FACULTY OF LINGUISTICS

CCME0051 Chap.10 Designing and Reporting a Small-Scale Empirical Study

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 10 of 10 · CCME0051

Designing and Reporting a Small-Scale Empirical Study

Designing and Reporting a Small-Scale Empirical Study turns the module's single assessment into a working method.

The report of about 5,000 words follows the layout of an SLA journal article, and this chapter treats its sections as one chain: a critical review that ends in a specific gap, research questions that make the gap answerable, a method whose participants, materials, procedures and scoring all serve those questions, results reported plainly, and a discussion that answers back to the studies reviewed.

It adapts the synthesis routine the module shares from Lourdes Ortega, in which one-page summaries feed a cross-study table so that the review is organised by pattern rather than by paper. A model design paragraph shows how a small comparison of plural marking in speech and writing can be justified from earlier findings and scored transparently.

The chapter also covers the formative outline and the two December tutorials, the ethical standards the study must meet, and the word range and formatting rules that differ slightly between Moodle pages.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The report as one chain from review to discussion

  • 02

    Replication versus original study and the rationale each needs

  • 03

    Synthesis tables and the laundry list problem

  • 04

    Research questions that a small data set can answer

  • 05

    Reporting participants, materials, procedures, coding and analysis

  • 06

    Ethical standards for studies with participants

  • 07

    Outline feedback, word range and submission format

Worked example · free

Place draft sentences into the report sections

Q [5 marks]. Five sentences come from one student's draft: (a) Studies of written tasks report higher accuracy than oral ones, but few studies have compared modes within Mandarin-speaking learners. (b) Do learners mark plural nouns more accurately when writing than when speaking? (c) Twelve learners described two parallel picture sets in counterbalanced order. (d) Mean accuracy was 75% in writing and 50% in speech. (e) The gap matches studies that report mode effects, although the sample was small. Assign each sentence to a section and explain the link between them. This mark weighting is our own study aid and is not published by UCL.
Six boxes follow the report from critical review through research gap, research questions and method to results and discussion, while the dashed arrow shows theSix boxes follow the report from critical review through research gap, research questions and method to results and discussion, while the dashed arrow shows the discussion answering back to the studies reviewed at the start.Critical reviewResearch gapResearch questionsMethodResultsDiscussionanswers return to studies
Six boxes follow the report from critical review through research gap, research questions and method to results and discussion, while the dashed arrow shows the discussion answering back to the studies reviewed at the start.
  • 1Sentence (a) belongs at the end of the critical review, because it names the research gap.
  • 1Sentence (b) is the research question that converts that gap into something the data can answer.
  • 2Sentence (c) belongs in the method under participants and procedures, and (d) belongs in the results because it reports data without interpretation.
  • 1Sentence (e) is a discussion move: it sets the finding beside earlier studies and names a limitation, closing the loop back to the review.
Review (a), research question (b), method (c), results (d) and discussion (e). The sentences form one chain: the gap justifies the question, the method answers it, the results report the answer and the discussion links it back to the studies that defined the gap.
Sia tip — If a results sentence contains words like suggests or because, move that clause into the discussion.
Glossary

Key terms

Replication study
A study that repeats a published design, often with a new group or task, to test whether its findings hold.
Research gap
A question earlier studies leave open, which the review must identify to justify a new study.
Synthesis table
A grid of questions, contexts, methods and results across studies, used to write a review by pattern.
Counterbalancing
Varying the order of tasks across participants so that practice or fatigue does not favour one condition.
Formative outline
A short, ungraded plan of the report on which tutors give feedback before the final version.
FAQ

Designing and Reporting a Small-Scale Empirical Study FAQ

Can I replicate a published study instead of designing my own?

Yes. The handbook allows either a replication or an original study. A replication still needs a rationale in the review, such as testing a new first language background, a different proficiency level or another task type, so that the repeat adds something to what is known.

How many participants does a small-scale study need?

Size the sample to your questions and to what you can recruit, test and analyse within the term; one sample report posted on Moodle, for instance, analyses fourteen participants. Report the number, background and proficiency of your participants clearly, and treat a small sample as a limitation in the discussion.

What should a literature review in this report do?

It should motivate your study, not survey the whole field. Group studies by the patterns they show, explain why some results disagree, and end by naming the specific gap your questions address. A review organised one study per paragraph usually fails to do this.

What goes into the outline for the December tutorials?

The outline is at most two double-spaced pages in 12-point font. For each section and subsection it lists the main points as short phrases and the author and year of the studies supporting them, so tutors can comment on structure and design before you write in full.

Which referencing style should I use?

The handbook recommends APA style but allows another recognised style if you prefer. Whatever you choose, apply it consistently, place direct quotations in quotation marks with author, year and page, and credit any idea or data taken from another source, as the module's plagiarism guidance requires.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Start the report in Week 1 by keeping a synthesis table for every empirical paper you read, with columns for questions, context, methods, results and your own reading of the results. By reading week, choose a narrow topic that one structure, one learner group or one task can capture, and write two research questions that your data could answer.

Draft the method before the review is finished, because design limits shape what the review must justify. Bring a section-by-section outline to the first tutorial, revise it, and settle every data decision before collection. In January, write results plainly, then link each finding to the reviewed studies in the discussion.

Working through Designing and Reporting a Small-Scale Empirical Study in CCME0051? Sia is AskSia’s AI Linguistics tutor — ask any CCME0051 Designing and Reporting a Small-Scale Empirical Study question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how CCME0051 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your CCME0051 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works