ECON0006 Chap.5 Comparative Statics
Comparative Statics
Comparative Statics traces how an optimum or equilibrium changes when an external parameter moves. The defining condition must show both endogenous variables and parameters, and a system must be differentiated as a system rather than equation by equation with other choices frozen. Sign conclusions require explicit assumptions.
Envelope reasoning concerns the optimised value and must not be confused with the movement of the optimiser.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Defining conditions
- 02
Implicit differentiation
- 03
Endogenous responses
- 04
Parameter shocks
- 05
Systems of equations
- 06
Sign assumptions
- 07
Envelope reasoning
Worked example · free
Trace a shifted marginal balance
- 2Show that the old choice now has marginal benefit above marginal cost.
- 2Explain why increasing the choice restores the balance.
- 1State the feasibility and monotonicity assumptions.
Key terms
- Endogenous variable
- A variable determined inside the model being solved.
- Parameter
- A quantity treated as fixed while the model solution is obtained.
- Envelope reasoning
- A method for describing how the optimised value changes with a parameter.
Comparative Statics FAQ
Why differentiate the whole system?
Endogenous variables move together. Holding one fixed calculates only a partial channel and may reverse or omit the actual equilibrium response. Differentiate every equilibrium condition before solving the response system.
What if the response sign is ambiguous?
Report conditional cases or the derived expression and state the additional assumption needed to fix the sign. Do not force a universal direction when the model supports several cases.
Does the envelope theorem give the optimiser response?
Not by itself. It simplifies the change in the optimised value. The movement of the chosen argument remains a separate comparative-static question requiring its own derivative or equilibrium system.
How should I present an unresolved sign?
Display the response expression, list the terms whose signs are known and isolate the term that remains ambiguous. Then give conditional conclusions under the additional assumptions that would make that term positive or negative. This is a complete comparative-static result: it identifies exactly what the model establishes and what further restriction would be needed for one directional prediction.
Exam move
Label endogenous variables and parameters in different colours, then write the equation that defines the solution. Differentiate every direct and indirect channel before solving for a response. For systems, preserve equation and variable order so the response vector can be interpreted. Practise stating sign assumptions before the direction conclusion.
Pair optimiser questions with optimum-value questions to keep envelope reasoning distinct. End with the mechanism that restores equilibrium and the local or boundary condition limiting the claim. Start a revision sheet with three columns headed direct effect, endogenous adjustment and restored condition.
For each parameter change, use the first column to say which equation shifts while the choice is temporarily held at its old value. Use the second to trace how every endogenous variable must move. Use the third to identify the equality or optimality condition that holds again at the new solution. This prevents a partial derivative from being mistaken for the total equilibrium response.
When a sign is not determined, write the competing channels explicitly and state the extra monotonicity or curvature assumption needed to choose between them. For systems, practise the same problem in both equation form and matrix form. Fix an order for equations, variables and response components, then keep that order through differentiation and inversion.
Before calculating, predict which entries represent direct parameter exposure and which represent feedback between endogenous variables. After calculating, substitute the response vector back into the differentiated system. A sign that seems economically surprising is a prompt to inspect the determinant, cross-effects and maintained assumptions, not a reason to reverse it without evidence.
If the relevant matrix is singular, explain why the ordinary local response is not identified. Keep optimiser responses separate from value responses. Ask two questions after every parameter shift: how does the chosen argument move, and how does the best attainable objective value move?
The envelope theorem can simplify the second because first-order terms vanish at an interior optimum, but it does not by itself supply the movement of the choice. Create paired drills where the value rises although the choice falls, or where a boundary becomes active and the smooth interior formula stops applying. Label every conclusion as local unless the model provides enough global structure to support a larger claim.
In the exam, present the defining condition before its derivative so the reader can see where each term originates. Group response terms on one side, factor the required derivative and only then interpret the sign. State the denominator condition that permits division and name any constraint that could change status after the parameter moves. Finish with a sentence describing the adjustment mechanism in economic language.
This structure distinguishes algebra, assumptions and interpretation and makes an ambiguous result defensible rather than forcing a direction the model does not establish.
Working through Comparative Statics in ECON0006? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON0006 Comparative Statics question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON0006 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.