University College London · FACULTY OF EDUCATION

EDPS0003 Chap.6 Meritocracy, Mobility and Social Justice

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 6 of 12 · EDPS0003

Meritocracy, Mobility and Social Justice

Meritocracy, Mobility and Social Justice examines how education has reshaped ideas of what a fair society is. The chapter separates meritocracy, social mobility and equality of opportunity, adds the module's concept of education-based discrimination, and maps how unequal starting points flow through school sorting into credentials and rewards that are then used to justify the sort.

It shows how to respond to a critique such as the unfulfillable promise rather than simply repeat it. It also explains why a report that uses these ideas must engage with the module's critiques of them.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Meritocracy as ideal and ideology

  • 02

    Social mobility and its political uses

  • 03

    Equality of opportunity and its limits

  • 04

    Education-based discrimination and educationism

  • 05

    Ladders and snakes in an education system

  • 06

    Responding to a critique in a literature review

Worked example · free

Respond to a critique of meritocracy

Q [6 marks]. Summarise one critique of meritocracy from the reading list, then write a response that narrows where the critique applies and turns it into a question for one setting. This weighting is ours alone and not a published UCL scheme.
Three unequal starting inputs on the left feed one school sorting process, which issues credentials and then rewards; the dashed red arc shows rewards being useThree unequal starting inputs on the left feed one school sorting process, which issues credentials and then rewards; the dashed red arc shows rewards being used to justify the sorting that produced them.rewards justify sortFamily resourcesSchool qualityTalent and effortSchool sortingCredentialsRewards
Three unequal starting inputs on the left feed one school sorting process, which issues credentials and then rewards; the dashed red arc shows rewards being used to justify the sorting that produced them.
  • 2Summarise the critique fairly with its author, for example Mijs on meritocracy as an unfulfillable promise.
  • 2Test where it is strongest, such as early streaming, and where it is weaker, such as second-chance routes.
  • 2Turn the response into a researchable question about who benefits from the weaker cases in one named place.
A response need not reject the critique. Narrowing where it applies shows critical engagement and produces the question the findings section will answer. In practice, the response paragraph might say that the promise is most clearly broken where pupils are streamed before secondary school and most nearly kept where adults can return to study, and then ask which of these routes exists in the chosen place.
Sia tip — After summarising a critique, write one sentence beginning with the conditions under which it holds most strongly; that sentence is where your own voice enters.
Glossary

Key terms

Meritocracy
A social order in which rewards are distributed according to measured talent and effort.
Education-based discrimination
Unequal treatment of people according to their level of schooling.
Equality of opportunity
The principle that everyone should have a fair chance to compete for positions and rewards.
Educationism
Negative attitudes held by highly educated people towards the less educated.
FAQ

Meritocracy, Mobility and Social Justice FAQ

What is wrong with meritocracy if it rewards effort?

The readings question whether merit can be measured fairly when children start school from unequal positions, and whether rewarding credentials makes unequal outcomes look deserved. Some critics also argue meritocracy harms its winners.

What does education-based discrimination mean?

It asks why unequal treatment by level of schooling is widely accepted when unequal treatment by race or gender is not. Stuart Tannock's 2008 article names the problem, and studies of educationism report negative attitudes towards the less educated.

Do I have to agree with the module's critiques?

No. The assessment guide says a report discussing meritocracy should engage with the critiques covered in the module and show some response, but it does not have to agree with them. Narrowing or qualifying a critique is a valid response.

What do Littler's ladders and snakes stand for?

In Jo Littler's introduction to Against Meritocracy, the ladder is the promise that anyone can rise through effort and talent, while the snakes are the hidden routes that let advantage carry some people up and others down. The image helps you analyse any selection system as both a ladder and a set of snakes.

Which readings help with a report on social mobility?

Titles on the list include work on the political redefinition of social mobility, on talking the talk of social mobility as a misguided agenda, and on misalignments between social mobility rhetoric and education for social justice. Pair one of them with local evidence about who actually moves up.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Build a four-column table for meritocracy, social mobility, equality of opportunity and education-based discrimination, and fill it as you read: core claim, main critique, author and an example from your own schooling. Keeping the ideas apart is the single best defence against vague writing in this section.

Read the Littler introduction with a pen, marking each ladder and each snake she describes, then find equivalents in the education system you grew up in. Choose one critique to practise responding to, writing a paragraph that summarises it fairly, tests where it holds and states your position.

Use the week's Padlet question on education-based discrimination to try out an argument you are unsure about, since the Padlet is completed rather than graded. If you plan a report on meritocracy, collect local evidence early: admissions policies, scholarship rules, political speeches about aspiration and data on who benefits.

Return to your four-column table before the peer feedback meeting and check that each concept in your draft meets at least one critique.

Working through Meritocracy, Mobility and Social Justice in EDPS0003? Sia is AskSia’s AI Education tutor — ask any EDPS0003 Meritocracy, Mobility and Social Justice question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EDPS0003 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EDPS0003 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works