University College London · FACULTY OF EDUCATION

EDPS0003 Chap.2 The Education Gospel

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 2 of 12 · EDPS0003

The Education Gospel

The Education Gospel examines the core belief of a schooled society: that education is the solution to individual and social problems. The chapter traces how a social problem is relabelled as a learning gap and answered with more schooling and credentials, a habit the reading list calls educationalization.

It reads a public speech and a spoken-word piece side by side, shows how a critique of school can still preach the gospel, and tests deficit stories that blame groups for not valuing education. The aim is not to dismiss education but to test what a belief in it promises, to whom, and with what result.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The education gospel as a belief system

  • 02

    Educationalization of social and economic problems

  • 03

    Popular culture texts and the gospel

  • 04

    Separating criticism of school from faith in education

  • 05

    Deficit myths about aspiration and attitudes

  • 06

    Education fever and study abroad

Worked example · free

Trace the educationalization loop in one policy

Q [8 marks]. A government responds to youth unemployment by announcing more training courses. Using the educationalization loop, explain how the problem is relabelled at each step and what the loop predicts if the causes lie outside education. This weighting is our own and is not an official UCL scheme.
Read the boxes left to right: a social problem is relabelled as a learning gap, answered with more schooling and credentials, and promised a fix; the dashed redRead the boxes left to right: a social problem is relabelled as a learning gap, answered with more schooling and credentials, and promised a fix; the dashed red arc shows the problem returning when its causes lie elsewhere.Social problemLearning gapMore schoolingCredentialPromised fixproblem returnseach step relabels the problem
Read the boxes left to right: a social problem is relabelled as a learning gap, answered with more schooling and credentials, and promised a fix; the dashed red arc shows the problem returning when its causes lie elsewhere.
  • 2Name the social problem and the moment it is recast as a learning gap, such as young people lacking skills.
  • 2Identify the educational remedy and the credential it offers, here a training certificate.
  • 2State the promised fix and whose responsibility it becomes: the individual who now holds the certificate.
  • 2Explain the return arc: if jobs are scarce for other reasons, unemployment persists while the policy keeps its appeal.
The policy turns unemployment into a skills deficit, offers certificates as the remedy, and shifts responsibility to individuals. If demand for labour is the real constraint, the problem returns, which is the paradox the readings describe as a losing strategy with winning ways.
Sia tip — Write the problem in its original words before writing the educational remedy; the change of vocabulary is the evidence of educationalization.
Glossary

Key terms

Education gospel
The belief that education is the solution to individual and social problems.
Educationalization
The practice of asking schools to solve social and economic problems.
Education fever
Intense family and public investment in education, studied on the module's list in Korea and among Chinese families.
FAQ

The Education Gospel FAQ

Where does the term education gospel come from?

The core reading by Marvin Lazerson in Education Week names it, and Norton Grubb and Lazerson develop it in a book subtitled The Economic Power of Schooling. The module asks whether this belief has become the dominant faith of our time.

Is the module saying education is bad?

No. The section asks you to test a belief rather than reject education. Critics on the list question whether schooling can solve problems whose causes lie in wages, housing or power, and whether faith in education shifts responsibility onto individuals.

How do I analyse a speech or song for the Padlet task?

Ask two questions separately: what the text says about schools, and what it promises education will achieve. A text can attack exams and still promise that learning will rescue its audience, which shows how deep the faith runs.

What does educationalization mean in practice?

It describes the habit of handing social and economic problems to schools, such as tackling unemployment through training or inequality through aspiration programmes. Readings by David Bridges and David Labaree question whether schools can fix problems that begin elsewhere, and why the approach stays politically attractive when results disappoint.

Can I write my report about the education gospel?

Yes, as long as you apply it to one area of life in one setting. Past peer feedback often asked writers to bring in the gospel as a concept, for example when discussing family pressure or health campaigns, so it works well as part of a literature review even when it is not the main topic.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Keep a small gospel log during the term. Whenever you hear a politician, advert, film or relative present education as the answer to a problem, write down the original problem, the educational remedy offered and who is expected to act. After a few entries you will have evidence of educationalization drawn from your own life, which is exactly the individual experience the report and reflection ask for.

Read the two core readings in one sitting, the speech first and the critique second, and note where the critique would push back on specific lines. For the Padlet task, choose a text you know well rather than one you think sounds academic; familiarity lets you analyse detail.

When you meet claims that a group does not value education, treat them as hypotheses and look at the readings that test deficit stories before repeating them. Finally, write one paragraph that applies the three-step gospel audit to a policy from your own country, and keep it for the report. Keep the log going after week two, because gospel language reappears in later sections on meritocracy, work and health.

Working through The Education Gospel in EDPS0003? Sia is AskSia’s AI Education tutor — ask any EDPS0003 The Education Gospel question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EDPS0003 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EDPS0003 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works