EDPS0007 Chap.2 Three Theories of the Purposes of University
Three Theories of the Purposes of University
Three Theories of the Purposes of University covers the debate at the heart of the first exam question. Human capital theory treats university as an investment in knowledge, skills and abilities that raise productivity and earnings. Signalling theory argues that for most degrees the main value is a signal to employers of intelligence, conscientiousness and conformity.
Self-formation theory describes students forming themselves through autonomy, agency, a will to learn, immersion in disciplinary knowledge and relationships beyond the classroom, and it builds on Biesta's account of qualification, socialisation and subjectification.
The chapter places these theories side by side, adds evidence on what students and parents say they want, introduces university as a life stage through Arnett's emerging adulthood, and shows how class survey data can be turned into analysis rather than description. Its aim is a persuasive argument that names a theory, applies it and answers its strongest rival.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Human capital theory and education as investment
- 02
Signalling theory and the three traits employers read
- 03
Self-formation theory and its five aspects
- 04
Qualification, socialisation and subjectification
- 05
Emerging adulthood and university as a life stage
- 06
Using class survey results in an argument
- 07
Critiques of purely economic models
Worked example · free
Match three student statements to the purposes theories
- 1Statement (a) is signalling: the degree's value lies in what it tells employers, not in specific skills.
- 1Statement (b) is human capital: the degree builds knowledge and skills that raise future productivity.
- 1Statement (c) is self-formation: autonomy and agency are developed by the student rather than given by others.
- 1Human capital and signalling are the two economic theories; self-formation concerns personal development.
Key terms
- Human capital
- The knowledge, skills and abilities people gain through education, training and experience, which raise productivity.
- Signalling theory
- The view that a degree mainly signals traits such as intelligence, conscientiousness and conformity to employers.
- Self-formation
- Students forming their own selves through autonomy, agency, a will to learn, disciplinary immersion and relationships.
- Subjectification
- The individuating effect of education, in which a student develops a unique self, sometimes by rejecting norms.
- Emerging adulthood
- Arnett's life stage of identity exploration, instability, self-focus, feeling in-between and optimism.
Three Theories of the Purposes of University FAQ
Which theory should I argue for in the purposes question?
Any of them, or more than one. The question asks for a persuasive argument in favour of one or more theories, so choose the position you can support best with readings, lecture material and portfolio tasks, and answer its strongest rival.
How is signalling different from human capital?
Both link university to the labour market. Human capital says graduates earn more because they learned more; signalling says the degree mainly certifies traits employers cannot see directly, such as intelligence, conscientiousness and conformity.
What are the five aspects of self-formation?
As taught in the module: autonomy, agency, the will to learn, immersion in disciplinary knowledge, and relational experiences beyond the classroom such as social life. The lecture notes that the social aspect was missing from Marginson's first version.
Do I need to mention authors such as Caplan or Marginson?
Naming key authors helps your argument, but you do not need publication details or a bibliography in the exam. Credit comes from explaining their ideas accurately and using them, not from listing names.
Exam move
Treat the purposes question as a debate you must be able to win from any side. Write a one-paragraph definition of each theory in your own words, including the specific content markers look for: human capital as knowledge, skills and abilities with soft skills such as persistence; signalling's three traits; and self-formation's five aspects.
Next, collect evidence for each theory from the module: the motivations survey evidence, the forced-choice and stated-purposes class surveys, the lockdown study of students' lost university experience, and the debate on whether economic models explain university at all. Then practise the three-step move from feedback on earlier drafts: define, apply to one concrete case, contest with the strongest rival.
Because the exam may pair this question with another, decide in advance which ideas, such as self-formation and AI, you might reuse, and plan how the second use will add something new rather than repeat the first. A week before the exam, write the opening paragraph of a purposes essay from memory in ten minutes, then check it for a clear thesis, a defined theory and a named rival.
Repeat until all three appear without prompting.
Working through Three Theories of the Purposes of University in EDPS0007? Sia is AskSia’s AI Education tutor — ask any EDPS0007 Three Theories of the Purposes of University question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EDPS0007 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.