INST0098 Chap.3 Choosing Qualitative Traditions
Choosing Qualitative Traditions
Choosing Qualitative Traditions compares narrative research, phenomenology, grounded theory, ethnography and case study by the knowledge each seeks. The same interview or text can be analysed differently depending on whether the project investigates stories, lived experience, social process, culture or a bounded system.
The chapter also introduces abductive movement between surprising observations and competing explanations.
Revise traditions through transformations rather than definitions. Take one topic, such as participation in an online heritage project, and rewrite it five ways. A narrative question asks how participants organise a turning point. A phenomenological question asks how participation is experienced.
A grounded theory question asks which process explains continued involvement. An ethnographic question asks how community practice and meaning develop in context. A case study question asks how the bounded project operates through several evidence types. Each version changes what counts as data and how a finding should be expressed.
Next, identify the unit of analysis.
A transcript is a container, not automatically the unit. Narrative work may analyse the whole account and its sequence. Phenomenological work may examine descriptions of a shared experience. Grounded theory compares incidents and developing categories. Ethnography relates events and talk to practice in a setting. Case study integrates interviews, documents and observations around the case.
Stating the unit prevents coding from becoming an identical procedure with five different labels.
Researcher position also varies. Ask how access was gained, what relationships made visible, what participation changed and which interpretations depend on the researcher's standpoint. Reflexivity should name concrete effects on recruitment, conversation, observation and analysis.
It is not a general confession placed outside the method. Keep field decisions and analytic memos so later claims can be connected to the circumstances that produced them.
Use a boundary exercise to separate method families that are often blended. Write cultural-practice, lived-experience and bounded-case questions about the same digital community.
For each, list the observation period, participant relationship and documents required. Then write one result sentence that would be legitimate and one that would overreach. This comparison reveals that similar collection activities support different knowledge only when the analytical purpose and inferential boundary remain explicit.
Practise abduction with an anomaly log.
When an observation resists the current explanation, write at least two plausible accounts and one mundane data-quality possibility. List evidence that would distinguish them and decide whether further collection or a re-reading is required. This procedure prevents surprise from being treated as automatic confirmation of an exciting theory.
It also makes iteration visible: categories change because a documented case demanded revision.
Finally, write the limitation in the grammar of the chosen tradition. A small narrative sample limits the range of accounts, not merely sample size. A short ethnographic engagement limits claims about cultural practice over time. A single case limits transfer unless contextual similarity is argued.
Precise limitations demonstrate understanding of what the method was designed to know.
For final review, state why the selected tradition is preferable to its nearest alternative. Refer to the desired knowledge and unit, not personal comfort with collection techniques.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Narrative research
- 02
Phenomenology
- 03
Grounded theory
- 04
Ethnography
- 05
Case study
- 06
Abductive reasoning
Worked example · free
Choose a tradition for creator diaries
- 2Identify the intended knowledge as the organisation of turning point stories.
- 2Select narrative research and define the account as the unit.
- 2State how ethnography or case study would answer a different question.
Key terms
- Narrative research
- Qualitative inquiry into how accounts organise events, identity and meaning.
- Phenomenology
- Inquiry focused on the lived experience and meaning of a phenomenon.
- Abductive analysis
- Iterative reasoning that develops plausible explanations for surprising observations.
Choosing Qualitative Traditions FAQ
Can the same data support different traditions?
Yes, but the unit, analytic attention and claim will change. An interview may be treated as a story, evidence of lived experience or one source within a bounded case, and those are not equivalent readings.
How is ethnography distinct from interviewing?
Ethnography investigates cultural practice in context through sustained engagement and observation. Interviews may contribute, but they do not by themselves create an ethnographic design with contextual cultural claims.
What makes abduction disciplined?
The researcher records surprise, considers competing explanations, seeks evidence that distinguishes them and revises the emerging account. Novelty alone is not evidence for the preferred explanation or any plausible rival account.
Assessment move
Create a comparison table with rows for desired knowledge, unit of analysis, researcher role, collection pattern and claim. Populate it for each qualitative tradition, then test the table on one topic. Rewrite the same topic as five different questions and observe how each question changes the evidence needed.
Add an abductive exercise: choose an unexpected observation, propose three explanations and list the evidence that would discriminate among them. Avoid memorising traditions as keyword bundles. Instead, explain why a particular design fits and what would make another tradition more suitable. This prepares critical method comparison in the report and coherent selection in the proposal.
Working through Choosing Qualitative Traditions in INST0098? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any INST0098 Choosing Qualitative Traditions question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how INST0098 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.