University College London · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

SESS0007 Chap.5 Profit and the Shutdown Rule

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 5 of 8 · SESS0007

Profit and the Shutdown Rule

Profit and the Shutdown Rule brings revenue into the firm's problem. Profit in this module is economic profit: revenue minus economic cost, including implicit costs, so a business can report an accounting profit while earning zero or negative economic profit. The chapter assumes owners maximise profit and studies the perfectly competitive case.

Many small buyers and sellers, free entry and exit, identical products, full information and no transaction costs make each firm a price taker. The firm faces a residual demand, the market demand left after other sellers supply, which is very flat because the firm is small, so its marginal revenue equals the price.

In the short run, with capital fixed, profit maximisation chooses labour so that the marginal product of labour equals the wage divided by the price; graphically, the highest isoprofit line is tangent to the production function. In the long run the problem becomes maximising price times output minus the cost function, giving marginal revenue equal to marginal cost and, for a price taker, price equal to marginal cost.

A specific tax raises variable and marginal cost but not fixed cost. The shutdown rules finish the chapter: a firm shuts down only if that reduces its loss, which happens when price falls below average variable cost, because producing nothing still costs the fixed cost. In the long run there is no fixed cost, so a firm exits when price falls below long-run average cost.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Accounting and economic profit

  • 02

    Conditions for perfect competition and price taking

  • 03

    Residual demand and marginal revenue

  • 04

    Short-run labour choice and isoprofit lines

  • 05

    Price equals marginal cost and specific taxes

  • 06

    The short-run shutdown rules and long-run exit

Worked example · free

Decide whether a loss-making firm should keep producing

Q [5 marks]. A competitive firm has TC = 200 + 4q + q² and the market price is £24. Find its profit-maximising output, its profit, and whether it should shut down in the short run. Marks shown in this model are a practice weighting, not a published scheme.
The shutdown decision first compares price with minimum AVC.The shutdown decision first compares price with minimum AVC. A producer then makes a loss below ATC, breaks even at ATC and earns positive profit only above ATC.p < min AVCp ≥ min AVCp < ATCp = ATCp > ATCCompare p with min AVCshort-run shutdown testShut downloss equals fixed costProduce where p = MCrevenue covers avoidable costShort-run lossexit in the long runZero profitno entry or exitProfitentry attracted
The shutdown decision first compares price with minimum AVC. A producer then makes a loss below ATC, breaks even at ATC and earns positive profit only above ATC.
  • 2MC = 4 + 2q. Setting price equal to MC gives 24 = 4 + 2q, so q = 10.
  • 1Revenue is £240 and total cost is 200 + 40 + 100 = £340, so the firm makes a loss of £100.
  • 2AVC = 4 + q = 14, below the £24 price. Shutting down would lose the full £200 fixed cost, so the firm keeps producing.
The firm produces 10 units and loses £100, but it should not shut down: revenue covers variable cost and contributes £100 towards fixed cost, halving the loss it would make by closing. The marks are an original practice weighting.
Sia tip — Compare the loss from producing with minus fixed cost, not with zero; that is the whole content of the shutdown rule.
Glossary

Key terms

Economic profit
Total revenue minus economic cost, including the opportunity cost of the owner's resources.
Price taker
A firm too small to affect the market price of its output or inputs.
Isoprofit line
The set of output and labour combinations that give one level of profit.
Specific tax
A tax of a fixed amount on each unit produced, which raises variable and marginal cost.
FAQ

Profit and the Shutdown Rule FAQ

Why does marginal revenue equal price for a competitive firm?

The firm can sell any quantity it can produce at the going market price, because its residual demand is nearly horizontal. Each extra unit therefore adds exactly the price to revenue.

Should a firm making a loss close immediately?

Not in the short run if revenue covers variable cost. Closing still leaves the fixed cost to pay, so producing reduces the loss. It should close only when price falls below average variable cost, and leave the market in the long run if price stays below long-run average cost.

Does a per-unit tax change the shutdown decision?

It can. The tax raises average variable cost by the amount of the tax, so a firm close to its shutdown price may move below it. If price still exceeds the higher average variable cost, the firm keeps producing at a smaller output.

Study strategy

Exam move

Learn this chapter as a sequence of checks rather than separate facts. First, practise separating accounting from economic profit with small numerical cases that include the owner's alternative income. Second, list the conditions for perfect competition and explain how each one makes the residual demand flatter.

Third, drill profit maximisation in two forms: the short-run labour condition, marginal product equals wage over price, and the output condition, price equals marginal cost. Fourth, add a specific tax to a cost function and redo the output choice. Finally, apply the shutdown check after every profit calculation, comparing price with average variable cost and the loss with the fixed cost.

Writing the decision tree from memory, with average variable cost first and average total cost second, is a fast way to prepare for true-false questions on this topic.

Working through Profit and the Shutdown Rule in SESS0007? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any SESS0007 Profit and the Shutdown Rule question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how SESS0007 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your SESS0007 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works