ECON20003 Chap.3 Comparing Two Population Central Locations
Comparing Two Population Central Locations
Comparing Two Population Central Locations is the which-test forest in miniature. You first decide whether the two samples are paired (same units measured twice) or independent (two separate groups). For paired data you use the paired t-test on the differences.
For independent groups you run an F-test of equal variances first: if variances are equal use the pooled (equal-variance) t-test, and if they differ use the Welch (unequal-variance) t-test. When normality fails, the rank-based alternatives take over — the Wilcoxon signed-rank test for paired data and the Wilcoxon rank-sum / Mann-Whitney test for independent groups.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Paired vs independent designs — choose the design first
- 02
Paired t-test on the differences (df = n − 1)
- 03
F-test of equal variances as the gatekeeper
- 04
Pooled (equal-variance) t-test with S²_p and df = n₁ + n₂ − 2
- 05
Welch (unequal-variance) t-test with Satterthwaite df
- 06
Nonparametric: Wilcoxon signed-rank (paired) and rank-sum/Mann-Whitney (independent)
Pooled two-sample t-test (equal variances)
- 1 markState the hypotheses (two-tailed): H₀: μ₁ = μ₂ versus H₁: μ₁ ≠ μ₂.
- 1 markBecause variances are not rejected as equal and both groups are normal, use the pooled t-test with df = n₁ + n₂ − 2 = 20.
- 2 marksPool the variances: S²_p = [(n₁−1)S₁² + (n₂−1)S₂²]/(n₁+n₂−2) = [9×36 + 11×25]/20 = (324 + 275)/20 = 599/20 = 29.95.
- 2 marksStandard error: √(S²_p (1/n₁ + 1/n₂)) = √(29.95 × (0.1 + 0.08333)) = √(29.95 × 0.18333) = √5.491 = 2.343.
- 1 markTest statistic: t = (X̄₁ − X̄₂)/SE = (85 − 80)/2.343 = 5/2.343 = 2.13.
- 1 markDecision rule: the two-tailed critical value is t₀.₀₂₅,₂₀ = 2.086. Since 2.13 > 2.086, reject H₀.
- 1 markConclude in context: there is significant evidence at the 5% level that the two training methods produce different mean scores.
Key terms
- Paired vs independent samples
- Paired samples measure the same units twice (before/after, matched pairs) and are analysed on the differences; independent samples come from two separate groups. Misclassifying the design picks the wrong test and loses easy marks.
- Pooled t-test
- The equal-variance two-sample t-test. It combines both samples into one pooled variance S²_p and uses df = n₁ + n₂ − 2; valid only when the F-test does not reject equal variances and both populations are roughly normal.
- Welch t-test
- The unequal-variance two-sample t-test. It does not pool variances and uses a Satterthwaite-adjusted df; use it when the F-test rejects equal variances.
- Wilcoxon rank-sum (Mann-Whitney)
- The nonparametric alternative for two independent groups. It compares locations by ranking all observations together, making no normality assumption — used when the t-test's normality requirement fails.
Comparing Two Population Central Locations FAQ
How do I know whether to use the pooled or the Welch t-test?
Run the F-test of equal variances first. If it does not reject H₀ (variances look equal), use the pooled t-test; if it rejects (variances differ), use Welch. When in doubt, Welch is the safer default because it stays valid even when variances are unequal.
When do I drop to the rank-based tests?
When the normality assumption behind the t-tests fails — a curved Q-Q plot or a small Shapiro-Wilk p. Use the Wilcoxon signed-rank test for paired data and the Wilcoxon rank-sum / Mann-Whitney test for two independent groups.
Exam move
Draw the decision tree once and reuse it on every two-sample question: paired or independent → normal? → equal or unequal variance (run the F-test) → parametric or nonparametric. The pooled-variance and SE formulas are on the sheet, so practise substituting fast and keeping df straight.
Working through Comparing Two Population Central Locations in ECON20003? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON20003 Comparing Two Population Central Locations question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON20003 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.
