The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF HEALTH & MEDICINE

CCST9006 Chap.1 Rigorous Inquiry and Question Design

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 1 of 6 · CCST9006

Rigorous Inquiry and Question Design

From reaction to investigation

This chapter treats question asking as a scientific process. It begins with metacognition, then separates divergent generation from later judgement so that a group can see empirical, value, legal and social possibilities before selecting one. Categorisation decides what kind of evidence could answer a question. Prioritisation adds a gatekeeper, affected group and real constraint.

Meta-refinement finishes by naming variables, outcomes or evidence that could make the preferred answer change.

Why the process matters

A broad question can absorb unlimited reading while producing no decision. An actionable inquiry preserves the moral conflict but locates it in a choice that a hospital, laboratory, regulator or patient can make.

The chapter supplies a reusable anatomy: neutral background, explicit question, limiting condition and revision trigger.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Metacognition and critical thinking

  • 02

    Divergent question generation

  • 03

    Empirical and value questions

  • 04

    Gatekeepers and physical constraints

  • 05

    Prioritisation and justification

  • 06

    Operationalisation and revision triggers

Worked example · free

Turn enthusiasm into an actionable inquiry

Q [8 marks]. A hospital can produce patient-derived mini-tissues but has limited laboratory capacity. Replace the broad claim that personalised models will transform care with a decision question. Any marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not the University's marking scheme.
The funnel preserves curiosity while adding discipline.The funnel preserves curiosity while adding discipline. Each arrow removes vagueness and adds a decision, constraint or observable that another person could examine. How a broad reaction becomes an inquiry Generation Categorisation Prioritisation Justification Meta-refinement remove opinion-only wordingname the decision and constraintspecify evidence that could change the answer
The funnel preserves curiosity while adding discipline. Each arrow removes vagueness and adds a decision, constraint or observable that another person could examine.
  • 3Name the decision maker and alternatives.
  • 2Add the capacity constraint.
  • 3State evidence that could change the choice.
Ask whether limited capacity should be reserved for cases in which standard treatment has failed or used earlier when several targets are plausible. Compare turnaround, predictive value, urgency and opportunity cost. The question remains ethical, but it is now answerable because the actor, alternatives and scarce resource are visible.
Sia tip — If no office or person can act on the answer, the question is still a topic.
Glossary

Key terms

Metacognition
Monitoring and regulating one's own cognitive processes during inquiry.
Empirical Question
A question investigated through observation, measurement or comparison.
Value Question
A question about priorities, duties, authority or fair distribution.
Gatekeeper
The actor able to permit, restrict or allocate a biomedical intervention.
Revision Trigger
Evidence or reasoning that would justify changing a recommendation.
FAQ

Rigorous Inquiry and Question Design FAQ

Why generate questions before judging them?

Separating generation from judgement prevents the first familiar framing from controlling the inquiry. It allows empirical, ethical, legal and social questions to appear before a group filters them. Evaluation still follows, but selection can then be justified by relevance, constraint and decision value rather than habit.

Can a value question be made testable?

A value judgement is not converted into a fact, but empirical evidence can discipline it. Name the competing options, affected people and constraint, then identify outcomes relevant to the chosen principle. Evidence can show consequences and feasibility even when the final priority rule still requires justification.

What is the fastest way to narrow a broad topic?

Name the actor who must decide, the two alternatives available and the reason both cannot be chosen. Then state what evidence would reverse the preferred answer. If any of those elements is missing, the topic probably remains too broad for a focused tutorial or poster claim.

How do I justify choosing one question over another?

Compare the questions by relevance to the biomedical mechanism, importance of the affected decision, feasibility of obtaining evidence and whether the answer could change action. A familiar question is not automatically the strongest. Explain what the chosen question reveals that the alternatives leave hidden.

What is a useful revision trigger?

A revision trigger names evidence or reasoning capable of changing the recommendation. It might be a different outcome, a capacity threshold, a failed assumption or a stronger competing claim. Avoid vague promises to reconsider because they do not tell the reader when confidence should actually fall.

Why should the background sentence stay neutral?

A loaded background decides the question before evidence is considered. Describe the mechanism, setting and constraint without calling the intervention revolutionary, dangerous or necessary. Neutral framing does not remove values; it makes the later justification visible and allows another person to challenge the conclusion rather than the wording.

When should an empirical question come first?

Start empirically when the value judgement depends on an uncertain effect, comparison or mechanism. Establish what changes, for whom and with what confidence before allocating benefits or burdens. The later value question still requires a priority rule, but it will no longer rest on an unsupported factual premise.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Take one claim from each later theme and run the full process: generate several questions, mark each as empirical or value-based, choose the real-world bottleneck, name the decision maker and write a revision trigger. Compare the first question with the final one. The visible change is the point of the exercise.

Next, exchange questions with another person and ask them to identify the actor, alternatives, constraint and evidence needed. If they cannot, revise the wording without adding background length. Finish by creating one paired sequence in which an empirical question supplies evidence for a value choice. This shows how the categories cooperate without pretending that measurement alone settles priority or fairness.

Working through Rigorous Inquiry and Question Design in CCST9006? Sia is AskSia’s AI Health and Medicine tutor — ask any CCST9006 Rigorous Inquiry and Question Design question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how CCST9006 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your CCST9006 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works