The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF LAW

LLAW6082 Chap.6 Conflicts, Profits and Fiduciary Accountability

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 6 of 10 · LLAW6082

Conflicts, Profits and Fiduciary Accountability

Two loyalty rules

The conflict rule is preventive. It asks whether a real and sensible possibility exists that a directors personal interest conflicts with duty to the company. The profit rule asks whether a gain was obtained by reason of fiduciary position or an opportunity encountered through it.

A companys inability or unwillingness to take an opportunity does not automatically remove the connection between office and gain.

Disclosure is not the same as authorisation

Identify the interest, what was disclosed, the recipient and whether that person or body could approve. A friendly conversation with another executive may not amount to valid authorisation.

A formal resolution may also fail if material facts were withheld. Authorisation relocates the decision away from the interested fiduciary and requires enough information for the unconflicted decision-maker to judge the proposal.

Remedies protect loyalty

An account of profit can be available without proof that the company could have earned the gain or suffered transaction loss.

That strict response removes incentives for divided loyalty. Keep conflict, disclosure, authorisation, gain and remedy in separate steps, then connect the remedy to the precise breach and proper recipient.

Authorisation is a process, not a label

When a fiduciary interest or gain appears, identify the decision-maker capable of authorisation and the information that body needed.

Disclosure should cover the nature and extent of the interest, the gain or opportunity and any facts material to an independent judgment. Approval by persons who share the conflict may not perform that function. Keep timing visible as well: a later ratification question is not the same as informed approval before the transaction.

The profit rule protects loyalty even where the company could not have taken the opportunity or suffered no provable loss, so compensation is not the only possible response. An account focuses on the unauthorised gain, while rescission or compensation addresses different remedial objectives.

Conclude by matching claimant and relief to the breach and explaining why any consent was, or was not, sufficiently informed and independent.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Objective possibility of conflict

  • 02

    Corporate opportunities encountered through office

  • 03

    Full disclosure of material facts

  • 04

    Valid authorisation by an unconflicted decision-maker

  • 05

    Profit obtained by reason of position

  • 06

    Account of gain and company-centred relief

Worked example · free

A profitable contract with a private fee

Q [9 marks]. The mark allocation for Conflicts, Profits and Fiduciary Accountability is a study aid and is not an official University assessment scheme. AskSia-authored practice. A counterparty pays a director a consulting fee connected with a company contract. The chief executive knows, the board does not and the company gains from the contract. Apply both rules.
The lawful route requires authorisation before appropriation.The lawful route requires authorisation before appropriation. Learning of an opportunity through office creates conflict and profit questions that a directors private assessment cannot settle.From corporate opportunity to fiduciary responseopportunitylearnedpossible conflictor position usefull disclosureand authorisationpermitted routeif validly approvedno valid authorisationaccount for gain or restore lossRejection by the company does not automatically free a director to take the opportunity.
The lawful route requires authorisation before appropriation. Learning of an opportunity through office creates conflict and profit questions that a directors private assessment cannot settle.
  • 3Identify the conflict and connection between gain and office.
  • 3Test disclosure and the authority of the recipient to approve.
  • 3Explain why company profit does not cure the loyalty issue.
The fee may influence the directors advice, creating a real possibility of conflict, and it arises through the directors position in negotiations. Disclosure to the chief executive is not automatically authorisation; the proper approving body and completeness of disclosure must be established. A profitable outcome does not cure divided loyalty. Without valid approval, the gain is vulnerable to an account even if the company would have entered the contract anyway.
Sia tip — Ask who could authorise before treating any disclosure as consent.
Glossary

Key terms

Possible Conflict
A real and sensible possibility that personal interest may conflict with fiduciary duty.
Corporate Opportunity
A business opportunity connected with company activity or encountered through fiduciary position.
Authorisation
Valid approval by an appropriate unconflicted decision-maker after full disclosure of material facts.
Account Of Profit
A remedy requiring surrender of an unauthorised fiduciary gain rather than proof of compensatory loss.
FAQ

Conflicts, Profits and Fiduciary Accountability FAQ

Does the company have to prove loss under the profit rule?

Not necessarily. The profit rule can require a director to account for an unauthorised gain connected with fiduciary position even when the company could not have earned it or received a profitable transaction. The response protects loyalty by removing temptation rather than measuring only compensatory loss.

Is disclosure to another executive enough?

Only if that person or body is capable of authorising the conflict and receives full material information. Identify the proper approving route under the companys arrangements and applicable law. A casual conversation does not automatically relocate the decision away from the conflicted director, and incomplete disclosure undermines a formal approval.

What if the company rejected the opportunity?

Rejection is relevant but not automatically decisive. If the director learned of the opportunity through office or remains conflicted, full disclosure and valid authorisation for personal pursuit may still be required. The interested director cannot be the final judge that the company has finished with the opportunity or cannot benefit from it.

Study strategy

Exam move

For each scenario, create four headings: interest, possibility of conflict, disclosure and authorisation, and gain. Write the facts under the correct heading before choosing a remedy. Change one fact, such as full board disclosure before acquisition, and explain which part of the analysis changes.

Working through Conflicts, Profits and Fiduciary Accountability in LLAW6082? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LLAW6082 Conflicts, Profits and Fiduciary Accountability question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LLAW6082 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LLAW6082 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works