The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF LAW

LLAW6350 Chap.2 Collision Fault, Defences and Apportionment

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 2 of 9 · LLAW6350

Collision Fault, Defences and Apportionment

Collision analysis begins with lookout, safe speed, good seamanship and the encounter-specific navigation rule, then proceeds through breach, causation and maritime defences. Property loss is apportioned by relative fault, considering blameworthiness and causative potency, while personal injury follows a separate joint-liability route.

The chapter uses a timeline so the last manoeuvre does not obscure earlier, more powerful failures.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Lookout and safe speed

  • 02

    Overtaking, head-on and crossing

  • 03

    Good seamanship and special circumstances

  • 04

    Causation and intervening acts

  • 05

    Inevitable accident and emergency response

  • 06

    Relative fault and personal injury

Worked example · free

Separate an early breach from a late reaction

Q [10 marks]. A give-way vessel approaches at speed without a lookout, while the stand-on vessel alters late. Explain the order of liability analysis. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not the University's marking scheme.
The upper funnel establishes collision fault, while the lower fork separates proportional property liability from the joint-and-several personal-injury rule.The upper funnel establishes collision fault, while the lower fork separates proportional property liability from the joint-and-several personal-injury rule.From navigation duty to allocationDutyBreachCauseDefenceProperty: relative faultPersonal: joint liability
The upper funnel establishes collision fault, while the lower fork separates proportional property liability from the joint-and-several personal-injury rule.
  • 3Classify the encounter and state each duty.
  • 4Connect each breach to the collision.
  • 3Separate property and personal-injury allocation.
The give-way vessel's speed and lookout failures are early and causally powerful. Stand-on status defines the other vessel's initial duty but does not remove the later obligation to respond when collision can no longer be avoided by the first vessel alone. The late alteration may contribute without breaking the causal chain. Property damage is divided by comparative fault on the available evidence, while injured persons use the separate liability route.
Sia tip — Draw the encounter as a timeline. The most visible final manoeuvre is not automatically the most causally potent fault.
Glossary

Key terms

Good Seamanship
The ordinary navigational judgement that operates with the collision regulations and remains relevant when their specific rules do not complete the answer.
Causative Potency
The relative power of a fault to produce the collision or damage, considered alongside blameworthiness in apportionment.
Inevitable Accident
A defence directed to a collision that could not have been avoided despite the exercise of proper care.
Agony Of The Moment
Protection for a reasonable emergency response to danger created by another party, assessed without demanding perfect hindsight.
FAQ

Collision Fault, Defences and Apportionment FAQ

Does stand-on status remove all responsibility?

No. It defines the vessel's initial role in the encounter, but the vessel may acquire a duty to act when collision cannot be avoided by the give-way vessel alone. Analyse the sequence, available time and reasonableness of the response instead of treating the label as immunity.

How is collision property damage apportioned?

Establish each vessel's fault and causal contribution first, then compare blameworthiness with causative potency. Equal division is a fallback where degrees cannot be established, not a convenient starting point. Personal injury is separated because it follows the joint-liability rule taught in the course.

When does a later act break causation?

A later manoeuvre must be sufficiently independent and causally significant to displace the original negligence. An emergency response made inside danger created by another vessel does not automatically break the chain. Test the intervening-act argument separately from inevitable accident and agony of the moment.

How do the collision rules and ordinary negligence fit together?

Use the navigation rule to identify the conduct required at the relevant stage, then connect any breach to causation and loss. The rule is not a substitute for the whole liability analysis. A vessel may breach a rule without causing the casualty, or contribute through negligent conduct not captured by one quoted rule.

Why should apportionment come after causation?

Comparative percentages divide responsibility only among faults that materially contributed to the damage. List each proven fault, explain its causal potency and blameworthiness, and then justify the relative shares. Do not award percentages merely because both vessels made mistakes; a non-causal error should not enter the apportionment exercise.

Study strategy

Exam move

For every collision problem, draw positions and write the timeline from first risk detection to impact. Label each vessel's duty at every stage. Then create a second list containing breach, causal contribution and defence. Do not discuss percentages until those lists are complete. Finish by separating property, personal-injury and contribution claims, including their different time limits.

Use three versions of the same encounter. In the first, change which vessel is overtaking; in the second, move the first reliable sighting earlier; in the third, change only the final emergency manoeuvre. Explain which legal classification changes and which duties remain. This prevents memorising one geometric diagram as a universal answer.

Next, write causation in paired sentences: identify the breach, then state precisely how it increased the collision risk or damage. If the second sentence merely repeats that the conduct was negligent, the causal analysis is missing. Test every defence against a specific link. Inevitable accident challenges avoidability despite proper care. Agony of the moment evaluates a pressured response to danger created by another.

A new intervening act asks whether the later event displaced the original causal contribution. Keep those questions separate. For apportionment, make two columns headed blameworthiness and causative potency. Place every fault in both columns and explain why its weight differs. Reach a directional result before considering any percentage.

Finally, write distinct conclusions for hull damage, injured persons and contribution between vessels. Add the correct time question to each cause of action. This closing step turns a good navigation analysis into a complete collision answer.

Working through Collision Fault, Defences and Apportionment in LLAW6350? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LLAW6350 Collision Fault, Defences and Apportionment question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LLAW6350 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LLAW6350 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works