The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF LAW

LLAW6350 Chap.7 Wreck Removal Powers and Liability

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
8 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 7 of 9 · LLAW6350

Wreck Removal Powers and Liability

Wreck-removal analysis separates the condition and hazard of a stranded, abandoned or sunk vessel from private ownership, salvage and contract. Navigation or environmental risk can trigger public directions, seizure or removal while title remains unresolved.

The chapter applies Hong Kong domestic powers, treats the Nairobi Convention only as a non-operative comparison, and compares lump-sum, daily-rate and result-based removal forms.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Stranded, abandoned and sunk vessels

  • 02

    Navigation hazard

  • 03

    Environmental hazard

  • 04

    Public directions and removal

  • 05

    Cost recovery

  • 06

    Ownership and salvage

  • 07

    Removal contract structures

  • 08

    Nairobi treaty status

Worked example · free

Separate public powers from private title

Q [9 marks]. A foreign vessel sinks in a Hong Kong approach channel with fuel aboard. The owner retains title while the authority directs removal. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not the University's marking scheme.
Navigation and environmental risk drive the public response to a wreck, while ownership, salvage and treaty status remain separate legal questions.Navigation and environmental risk drive the public response to a wreck, while ownership, salvage and treaty status remain separate legal questions.Risk drives the public responseStranded or sunkNavigation risk?Environmental risk?Directions or removalControl and recoveryOwnership separateSalvage separate
Navigation and environmental risk drive the public response to a wreck, while ownership, salvage and treaty status remain separate legal questions.
  • 3Identify the navigation and environmental triggers.
  • 3Apply the domestic public-power route.
  • 3Separate title, contract and treaty status.
The channel obstruction and remaining fuel support the public hazard route under the domestic sources taught in the course. Retained title does not neutralise directions or removal powers. Cost recovery from the owner and payment of the contractor under its removal form are separate questions. The Nairobi Convention cannot be applied as current Hong Kong law because the syllabus states that it is not in force locally.
Sia tip — Write the treaty-status sentence before discussing the Nairobi model. A late disclaimer cannot repair an analysis built on inapplicable law.
Glossary

Key terms

Wreck Removal
The public or contractual process of dealing with a stranded, abandoned or sunk vessel that creates a relevant hazard.
Navigation Hazard
A risk posed by the vessel or wreck to safe use of a waterway, supporting public intervention under the applicable source.
Removal Direction
A statutory instruction requiring specified action in response to the vessel's condition or hazard.
Daily-Rate Form
A removal contract that prices time spent, shifting duration risk differently from a lump-sum or result-based form.
FAQ

Wreck Removal Powers and Liability FAQ

Does ownership decide whether a wreck can be removed?

No. Public powers can respond to navigation or environmental hazards while title remains with the owner or is disputed. Analyse the statutory trigger and authority separately from ownership, salvage and the contractor's payment. The same wreck can occupy all of those legal tracks at once.

Does the Nairobi Convention apply in Hong Kong?

The course syllabus states that the 2007 Wreck Removal Convention is not in force in Hong Kong. Apply the domestic Hong Kong sources taught in the course. Nairobi may be used as a comparison model for strict liability, insurance or direct action only after its non-application is explicit.

Can a removal contractor demand salvage instead?

An existing removal duty points away from voluntary salvage. Start with the pricing and risk allocation in the removal form, including variation or termination provisions. A public benefit or unexpected difficulty does not automatically replace lump-sum or daily-rate payment with a salvage reward; the salvage elements still require proof.

Why should ownership and public removal power be analysed separately?

Title identifies the proprietary interest but does not by itself answer whether an authority may mark, direct or remove a hazardous obstruction. Establish the statutory trigger and procedural power first, then address ownership, cost recovery and any contractor relationship. This prevents a property label from swallowing the public-law analysis.

How should I use the Nairobi Convention in a Hong Kong answer?

Use it only in the comparative role supported by the course materials because the syllabus states it is not in force locally. Apply the current domestic sources to the problem, then identify any convention difference explicitly. Do not present a desirable international rule as if it already governed Hong Kong.

Study strategy

Exam move

Draw two parallel tracks. On the public track place condition, hazard, authority power and cost recovery. On the private track place ownership, salvage and the removal contract. Add treaty status above both. Work three short variations in which only the hazard, contract form or place changes, and identify which track changes with it.

Begin with a vessel stranded outside a navigation channel, then move it into the channel and add fuel aboard. Identify the evidence that changes the public trigger without changing ownership. Next, keep the same hazard and vary the authority's action among directions, seizure, sale and contracted removal. For each action, locate the domestic source and procedural condition taught in the course.

On the private track, compare a lump-sum form, a daily-rate form and a result-based form. State which party bears duration and performance risk under each. If the contractor later claims salvage, test the scope of its existing removal duty before discussing peril or success. Maintain a treaty-status box at the top of every answer.

Write that the Nairobi Convention is not in force in Hong Kong before using its strict-liability, insurance or direct-action features as a comparison. A comparison paragraph should identify the claimant who would benefit and the recovery problem the newer model would change.

Finish by writing four separate conclusions: whether public intervention is authorised, how public cost may be recovered, what the contractor earns under the form, and whether any private salvage or ownership issue remains. Separation is the chapter's main skill.

Working through Wreck Removal Powers and Liability in LLAW6350? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LLAW6350 Wreck Removal Powers and Liability question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LLAW6350 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LLAW6350 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works