The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF PHYSICS

PHYS2261 Chap.10 Third Law and Low-Temperature Limits

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 10 of 10 · PHYS2261

Third Law and Low-Temperature Limits

Related statements with different jobs

The Nernst statement concerns entropy differences approaching zero, the Planck statement assigns zero entropy to a perfect crystal with a unique ground state, and unattainability rules out reaching absolute zero through finite operations.

Absolute entropy follows by integrating heat capacity divided by temperature and adding phase-transition contributions.

Residual entropy

Ground-state degeneracy can leave a positive low-temperature entropy without contradicting the equilibrium limit. The assumption of a unique perfect-crystal state must therefore be stated before setting S(0)=0.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Nernst statement

  • 02

    Planck statement

  • 03

    Unattainability

  • 04

    Absolute entropy

  • 05

    Residual entropy

  • 06

    Low-temperature heat capacity

Worked example · free

Integrate a cubic heat capacity

Q [7 marks]. This weighting is supplied for revision and is not an official university assessment scheme. If Cp=aT³ and S(0)=0, find S(T).
The curve approaches a limiting entropy as temperature falls.The curve approaches a limiting entropy as temperature falls. A unique perfect-crystal ground state gives the zero limit; degeneracy can leave residual entropy.Entropy approaches its low-temperature limitideal perfect crystal: S→0temperature Tentropy S
The curve approaches a limiting entropy as temperature falls. A unique perfect-crystal ground state gives the zero limit; degeneracy can leave residual entropy.
  • 2Write the entropy integral.
  • 3Simplify and integrate.
  • 2Check by differentiation and note transition terms.
S(T)=∫₀ᵀ aT′²dT′=aT³/3, plus any latent-heat contributions for crossed transitions.
Sia tip — State the ground-state assumption before using a zero entropy reference.
Glossary

Key terms

Nernst Statement
The low-temperature limit in which entropy changes for allowed condensed-phase processes approach zero.
Planck Statement
The assignment of zero entropy to a perfect crystal with a unique ground state at absolute zero.
Residual Entropy
Positive low-temperature entropy caused by ground-state degeneracy or frozen disorder.
Unattainability
The principle that absolute zero cannot be reached by a finite process.
FAQ

Third Law and Low-Temperature Limits FAQ

Are the Nernst and Planck statements identical?

No. Nernst concerns entropy differences approaching zero for specified processes, while Planck assigns an absolute zero entropy to an ideal perfect crystal with a unique ground state. The second needs an additional structural assumption.

Why can a crystal retain residual entropy?

If more than one ground-state arrangement remains compatible with the macroscopic state, the multiplicity exceeds one. Boltzmann's relation then gives positive entropy even at the low-temperature limit.

How is absolute entropy calculated above zero temperature?

Begin from the justified low-temperature reference, integrate Cₚ/T along a reversible heating path, and add L/T for every crossed phase transition. Entropy is a state function, so this reference path determines the endpoint value.

What assumptions must accompany an absolute-entropy calculation?

State whether the zero-temperature reference is a perfect crystal with a unique ordered ground state or a sample with residual configurational degeneracy. Experiments measure above zero, so justify the low-temperature heat-capacity form used for extrapolation. Integrate Cₚ/T separately within each phase and add L/T for every transition crossed on the reversible reference route.

A cubic crystal heat capacity gives a convergent low-temperature contribution, whereas extending a nonzero constant heat capacity to zero creates an unphysical logarithmic divergence and exposes the approximation's failure. Keep all temperatures in Kelvin and report molar or total entropy consistently.

If multiple ground-state arrangements remain, use their multiplicity to explain a positive residual entropy rather than silently setting the intercept to zero. Distinguish the Nernst limiting statement, Planck's perfect-crystal reference and unattainability of absolute zero by a finite sequence.

The final result should identify its reference, phases, extrapolation range, transition terms and whether it is an absolute entropy or only a difference.

Study strategy

Exam move

Make a four-row comparison of Nernst, Planck, unattainability and residual entropy. Practise one heat-capacity integral with a phase transition and one conceptual question about ground-state degeneracy. Check every low-temperature expression for Kelvin units, convergence and whether it claims an entropy difference or an absolute value. Begin by writing one sentence for the job of each statement.

Nernst constrains entropy differences in the low-temperature limit, Planck supplies a zero reference for a perfect crystal with a unique ground state, and unattainability rules out reaching absolute zero in a finite process. Residual entropy records the failure of the unique-ground-state assumption rather than a failure of the third law.

Draw an entropy-temperature curve for a perfect crystal and another with a positive residual intercept. Explain both with S=kB lnΩ and identify the ground-state multiplicity. Then calculate absolute entropy from a piecewise path. Integrate Cp/T within each phase and insert L/T at every transition.

Use a cubic low-temperature heat capacity to check convergence near zero, differentiate the final expression to recover Cp/T, and verify entropy units. Repeat with an omitted transition and diagnose why the endpoint value is too small. Connect unattainability to refrigeration by following the Carnot heat ratio as the cold temperature approaches zero.

Describe why extracting a fixed amount of heat requires unbounded work in the limit, without claiming a practical refrigerator follows the reversible formula exactly. Add an experimental perspective: data are measured above zero and extrapolated using a justified low-temperature form, because zero itself is not an accessible calibration point. Keep Celsius out of every denominator and ratio.

Review the historical problem type that combines a low-temperature heat capacity with an entropy integral, but create new coefficients and limits when practising so recall does not substitute for reasoning. Finish each answer by naming whether it reports an absolute entropy, an entropy difference or a limiting statement.

If S approaches a constant, say whether that constant is zero by assumption or positive because degeneracy remains. This distinction is the chapter's central precision test.

Working through Third Law and Low-Temperature Limits in PHYS2261? Sia is AskSia’s AI Physics tutor — ask any PHYS2261 Third Law and Low-Temperature Limits question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how PHYS2261 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your PHYS2261 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works